Recent content by RedTyger

I'm from Houston. Lived there most of my life. Never met anyone who fits the sterotype. Though, one thing I've always wondered. Do other states carry the same state pride Texans do? Living in California, I haven't seen a single California flag displayed outside of someones house, but I have seen...

Your first post stated nothing of "position of authority." You only started using that train of thought in our argument. Your initial argument against him was rejecting his personal taste. Which was the argument I was responding too. If you had a different opinion, you didn't state it until...

I'm not trying to slip out of anything. If that wasn't in the original post, then it wasn't in my post. But nice try to deflect, yet again. And when did I ever misrepresent your argument? I refuted it quite clearly. And when did I say, that this poster carried more weight than any other. I'm...

When did you correct me on straw man? Because you didn't. Might want to try that before you start trying to throw stones. An argument from authority is only a fallacy when the person isn't an authority, or when there isn't an consensus. Argument from authority doesn't even apply to my...

I don't think that you understand Argument from Authority either. I am not using him as an authority by any measure. Since no one has played the game, no one could be considered an authority. In my analogy, however, the fantasy chef would be considered an authority. I think you believe argument...

That's the third time you've said "straw man" and not once, have you used the concept properly. Please stop saying this. You don't know what it means. I was turning your analogy against you, and using it to prove my point, not to discredit your use of the analogy, which was fine in its...

Yeah. If was trying to Straw Man, I would've circumvented your argument and used this point as the basis of any counter argument. But since I didn't do that, I'm not using a Straw Man. I countered your argument on its own merits. Nevermind that I never implied that this was the basis of your...

No, he's not. His first point is that he believes (And I agree) that fans would've preferred a sequel to tie together the plot. His second point is pointing out that they've already done a younger Dante. The third point is the most grounded in your unreasonable want to quelch any kind of...

You're missing the point so completely that I really don't think you had a good argument. He wasn't trying to make his fandom into an authority, for one. And two, to make an analogy that you wont miss the point on. Its like a chef having an opinion on a dish. Yeah, everyone has different...

I'm not really following what you mean when you say "Guess what You opinion is no better than Michael Bays in your example". Because I really wasn't talking about Michael Bays opinion. I was talking about his capabilities as a director. But in anycase. Liking something generally means you know...

Except, its not a perfect transition. This isn't Christopher Nolan making Batman. This is Michael Bay making Batman. See, Christopher Nolan was known for making great movies, like Memento. Michael Bays high point was The Rock. Nevermind that this is a reboot, and reboots -always- turn out great...