Recent content by Riesel87

If you forgot anytime that you encounter them, then it is not possible to retain any knowledge of their existence as you have no encounters to refer to. your theory doesn't quite hold water as none of that is alluded to in the show. The writers have potrayed the silence in a certain way, then...

The Silence..... you forget them instantly once you look away is an established fact of the Dr who universe. So I ask, in this finale, the Dr says " I've always wondered what they looked like" That makes no sense, how can you wonder about something you cannot remember. Every encounter is...

Fair enough, point well received. I don't think he had no foward plan with regards to the story, as im sure he knew from day one her overall role. Its just the journey getting there I have a problem with. Humans making timelords in the tardis, and half episode cameo characters to explain new...

Just wanted to ask. Is it me or does the Silence have a very warped moral stand point. They want to kill the Dr to prevent him ending the universe, yet they kill any and all that get in the way. For the greater good? does that make them good guys or what. Im not swure what to make of it, or have...

What i question is whether or not the writters intended for these plot points from day one, or they added them to make the new story work. In theory anything and everything that is a fact can be changed in dr who because of the paradox of time travel. But in the real world that paradox doesn't...

I may have got the technical term incorrect, but at least I put a view foward. All you are doing is complaining about grammatical errors and corect use of techincal terms. As if I am going to spend any time checking that my spelling and grammar is perfect while on an internet forum. I also went...

haha yes my friend you are just spot on here.

yeh that has been my major gripe (other than not liking amy) is that the entire series has been based on this idea of the Dr dieing. Knowing full well he won't, it made the constant build up to the finale, ruin some good moments of the series.

Right first off, calm down and stop swearing. I havent been offensive to you so don't be offensive to me. If you being insulting to put your put across is your only way, then it shows your level of intellect for what it is. I have admitted to someone else that these may not be technically...

Well i have to agree with you on that and my faith in him is the same as you. I just find it very hard to believe that any of river song was planned. Thinking back to the library when she died, I just cannot beleive he knew her story for 2 seasons ahead and linked to characters that hadnt been...

Ok well they may not directly contradict anything, and if they are not techinally retcons, then are very poor plot additions to accomodate a convaluted character. The mel introduction was laughable. Oh did we not mention our mutual best friend that has been there the entire time, taken a massive...

Well i was thinking mainly of the 4th series when i wrote that. I have to disagree, with you however. Every episode was not centered around the finale episode. Yes references were made, but you were allowed to enjoy each episode on it's own merit.If you happend to not enjoy the end, then...

No those are retcons. Discovering something never previously known about someone after the fact is called a retcon. Changing something about someone i.e introducing the black girl at the end, into amy and roreys past is retro active continuity. She was added after the fact, a retcon. I dont know...

well making her amy and roreys daughter for one. Making river that black girl who died for another. making river song part timelord. these are all retcons.

What an awful end to a truely awful series of Dr Who. Only the james cordon episode was really good, spoiled by Amy Pond's cameo. This series has been full of continuity errors, more retcons than you can count and the truely tiresom plot of Amy pond and river song. River song has been the most...