[jaysol]

]

 

[The Unworthy Gentleman]

Your game idea consists of slamming three concepts stolen from other games together. Not cool, man.

Two rules:
1) Be original.
2) If your idea only fits onto two lines then it isn't good enough. Flesh 'em out.

 

[David Bjur]

Your game idea consists of slamming three concepts stolen from other games together. Not cool, man.

Two rules:
1) Be original.
2) If your idea only fits onto two lines then it isn't good enough. Flesh 'em out.

If he improves the original ideas then it's totally okay in my book. Oh wait, he didn't.

 

[minuialear]

Your game idea consists of slamming three concepts stolen from other games together. Not cool, man.

Two rules:
1) Be original.
2) If your idea only fits onto two lines then it isn't good enough. Flesh 'em out.

Agreed. At the very least, a new game idea should outline some new storyline/game mechanic that hasn't already been done (or at least done to pieces) in other AAA games, even if you don't have the entire game planned out from start to finish. What you posted is a somewhat vague mashing up of a bunch of things from other games and hard to find novelty in.