Australian Dragon Age Inquisitor's Collector Edition (mostly) all damaged

Recommended Videos

JayRPG

New member
Oct 25, 2012
585
0
0
I thought I would share some interesting news with you all.

A memo from EB games head office was sent to all the stores Australia wide advising staff to open and check every DA:I collector's edition box that arrived in stock because there had been reports of damaged and missing items.

The actual figures are roughly 15% of the received stock is so badly damaged (or there is so much missing) they are completely unsellable and head office did not even send them out to stores, of the remaining 85%, 80% have minor to moderate damage and/or are missing items, and only 5% are complete and undamaged.

The damage ranges from outer box damage, to items inside being broken like the plastic lock picks snapped in half, the map markers broken in half/pieces broken off them, quill and ink set broken/smashed;
The most common missing item are the Orlesian coins, which are housed in a box, in about 30% of the editions, those boxes are empty. Some are also missing the tarot cards, badge and lockpick set.

EB games will be offering partial refunds depending on the level of missing or damaged items but they have been advised by head office they will not be receiving anymore stock, so Australian customers do not even have the choice of waiting it out to get a replacement.

This looks like cheap decisions on the part of EA, the collector's box itself had no foam, there were no ties to hold items in place, all the items were just sitting in cheap plastic shells (and other items are just loose inside the box).

I have a feeling it will be blamed on the shipping companies, but every other big collector's edition in very recent times (ACU, Farcry 4) all arrived completely undamaged (and were shipped by the same shipping companies), and it's probably because the arrangement and retainment of the items inside the box seemed like it was an actual priority for them.
 

Dansen

Master Lurker
Mar 24, 2010
932
39
33
It seems like people went through them before hand if what you are saying is true. Seems really sketchy. Everybody loses, sucks pretty hard.
 

Dragonbums

Indulge in it's whiffy sensation
May 9, 2013
3,307
0
0
Either their first shipments were done by absolutely horrid carriers or someone wanted to be a colossal ass hole and went on a mass destruction spree. Either way it's shitty as fuck.
 

Jamash

Top Todger
Jun 25, 2008
3,638
0
0
There was a similar situation with The Witcher 2 Limited Collector's Edition.

Apparently the publisher in Europe, Atari, had opted for cheaper and less substantial packaging which wasn't up to the task of supporting the weight of the Geralt bust (it was barely supported in a flimsy plastic insert), leading to quite a few busts being damaged in transit, with bits broken off or prominent features abraded into dust where it collapsed the packaging and rattled around inside the box.

Fortunately, CD Projekt replaced any broken sculptures free of charge (and at substantial cost to themselves as they had to order another production run for this limited item) and posted them to every CE owner who e-mailed them photographic proof of their damaged Collectors Edition content, but this time mailed in a substantially protective package and bundled with a replica Witcher medallion as way of an apology.

I'm not expecting EA or Bioware to be as awesome as CD Projeckt and replace the damage items, but if they did it would be a tremendous display of good will.
 

ninja666

New member
May 17, 2014
898
0
0
Well, that sucks for our Australian gaming brethren. The worst part about it is they can only get a partial refund at best. I'd be pissed if I were in their shoes.
 

StormShaun

The Basement has been unleashed!
Feb 1, 2009
6,948
0
0
Well, shit.
I'm probably going to pray to the maker that nothing of mine is damaged.
Otherwise I'm going to be really pissed off at whoever did this.

The stores on this side of Australia are about to open soon.
So wish me luck.
 

ninja666

New member
May 17, 2014
898
0
0
StormShaun said:
Well, shit.
I'm probably going to pray to the maker that nothing of mine is damaged.
Otherwise I'm going to be really pissed off at whoever did this.

The stores on this side of Australia are about to open soon.
So wish me luck.
Isn't it safer to buy an imported one? You'll pay a bit more, but at least you'll be sure to get the full package.
 

StormShaun

The Basement has been unleashed!
Feb 1, 2009
6,948
0
0
ninja666 said:
Isn't it safer to buy an imported one? You'll pay a bit more, but at least you'll be sure to get the full package.
I haven't exactly tried importing before, so I'm somewhat skeptical of that.
And ... well, I have paid it all off.

If nothing can teach me the wrongs of pre-ordering, this certainly might.
Still, the mention of a refund might be good. I'll be able to put it on my Witcher 3 pre-order. [sub][sub]... and the lesson was not learnt.[/sub][/sub]

EDIT:

Okay, I picked up my Inquisitor's edition.
The guys there already knew of the news, and they were checking each edition with detail.
Good news though, all of my stuff is in tip top shape.
Hopefully this isn't a majority for everyone. :/
 

JayRPG

New member
Oct 25, 2012
585
0
0
Dragonbums said:
Either their first shipments were done by absolutely horrid carriers or someone wanted to be a colossal ass hole and went on a mass destruction spree. Either way it's shitty as fuck.
Dansen said:
It seems like people went through them before hand if what you are saying is true. Seems really sketchy. Everybody loses, sucks pretty hard.
Head office always checks a small portion of editions before they are distributed to stores, these editions are usually sold on the online store only for a cheaper price. All the ones that arrived in stores were factory sealed, and had to be opened to assess the damage. So the missing items is 100% a manufacturing issue.

The damaged items I'm also squarely placing in the manufacturer square because it's basically just a box, with 3 plastic shelves that have little spaces for the items to sit in. The items inside are not held in place with little wire ties like most childrens toys are, there was no foam inside the box, for the items that were awkward shapes, there was nothing in between the spaces to make sure hanging/dangling bits did not break off. It was just poor packaging, honestly, Barbie dolls are packaged more securely than this $229AUD collector's edition.

StormShaun said:
EDIT:

Okay, I picked up my Inquisitor's edition.
The guys there already knew of the news, and they were checking each edition with detail.
Good news though, all of my stuff is in tip top shape.
Hopefully this isn't a majority for everyone. :/
Autumnflame said:
Luckily my guy checked the edition before it left the store and all was perfect for me.
Congrats guys!

I've heard most stores got 1 or 2 undamaged copies each.

Head office advised all managers to open every edition to check damage, and if possible, to combine items to make the most complete editions (for ones with missing items). They gave them a preliminary check and then were also going to go through the editions with each customer to make sure they are happy with it and the partial refund.

Most of the stores around here were doing a "first in, best dressed" type deal where the first people to come in would get the better of the editions (all customers were called and informed the day before), but I am sure there were stores that went by pre-order date and gave the best ones to the people who'd had it on pre-order the longest.
 

silver wolf009

[[NULL]]
Jan 23, 2010
3,432
0
0
Jamash said:
There was a similar situation with The Witcher 2 Limited Collector's Edition.

Apparently the publisher in Europe, Atari, had opted for cheaper and less substantial packaging which wasn't up to the task of supporting the weight of the Geralt bust (it was barely supported in a flimsy plastic insert), leading to quite a few busts being damaged in transit, with bits broken off or prominent features abraded into dust where it collapsed the packaging and rattled around inside the box.

Fortunately, CD Projekt replaced any broken sculptures free of charge (and at substantial cost to themselves as they had to order another production run for this limited item) and posted them to every CE owner who e-mailed them photographic proof of their damaged Collectors Edition content, but this time mailed in a substantially protective package and bundled with a replica Witcher medallion as way of an apology.

I'm not expecting EA or Bioware to be as awesome as CD Projeckt and replace the damage items, but if they did it would be a tremendous display of good will.
The horrors released in the name of a quick buck...


Dark times, friend.
 

Jamash

Top Todger
Jun 25, 2008
3,638
0
0
silver wolf009 said:
Jamash said:
There was a similar situation with The Witcher 2 Limited Collector's Edition.

Apparently the publisher in Europe, Atari, had opted for cheaper and less substantial packaging which wasn't up to the task of supporting the weight of the Geralt bust (it was barely supported in a flimsy plastic insert), leading to quite a few busts being damaged in transit, with bits broken off or prominent features abraded into dust where it collapsed the packaging and rattled around inside the box.

Fortunately, CD Projekt replaced any broken sculptures free of charge (and at substantial cost to themselves as they had to order another production run for this limited item) and posted them to every CE owner who e-mailed them photographic proof of their damaged Collectors Edition content, but this time mailed in a substantially protective package and bundled with a replica Witcher medallion as way of an apology.

I'm not expecting EA or Bioware to be as awesome as CD Projeckt and replace the damage items, but if they did it would be a tremendous display of good will.
The horrors released in the name of a quick buck...


Dark times, friend.
Ha Ha, that's hilarious. It looks like Geralt has received the Monkey Jesus treatment.

My bust was just a bit abraded on his nose, cheek, chin and ponytail where it had rubbed around inside the box (the part supporting it had collapsed), but that looks like it melted and was re-sculptured by a well meaning but ultimately talentless individual.

It doesn't even look like it's made from the same soapstone material that mine was and is show in the official picture, it looks like it's made out of unfired clay (and the box seems too clean, mine was full of soapstone dust). It's that even genuine or just somebody messing about with modelling clay?
 

ecoho

New member
Jun 16, 2010
2,093
0
0
Whatislove said:
Dragonbums said:
Either their first shipments were done by absolutely horrid carriers or someone wanted to be a colossal ass hole and went on a mass destruction spree. Either way it's shitty as fuck.
Dansen said:
It seems like people went through them before hand if what you are saying is true. Seems really sketchy. Everybody loses, sucks pretty hard.
Head office always checks a small portion of editions before they are distributed to stores, these editions are usually sold on the online store only for a cheaper price. All the ones that arrived in stores were factory sealed, and had to be opened to assess the damage. So the missing items is 100% a manufacturing issue.

The damaged items I'm also squarely placing in the manufacturer square because it's basically just a box, with 3 plastic shelves that have little spaces for the items to sit in. The items inside are not held in place with little wire ties like most childrens toys are, there was no foam inside the box, for the items that were awkward shapes, there was nothing in between the spaces to make sure hanging/dangling bits did not break off. It was just poor packaging, honestly, Barbie dolls are packaged more securely than this $229AUD collector's edition.

StormShaun said:
EDIT:

Okay, I picked up my Inquisitor's edition.
The guys there already knew of the news, and they were checking each edition with detail.
Good news though, all of my stuff is in tip top shape.
Hopefully this isn't a majority for everyone. :/
Autumnflame said:
Luckily my guy checked the edition before it left the store and all was perfect for me.
Congrats guys!

I've heard most stores got 1 or 2 undamaged copies each.

Head office advised all managers to open every edition to check damage, and if possible, to combine items to make the most complete editions (for ones with missing items). They gave them a preliminary check and then were also going to go through the editions with each customer to make sure they are happy with it and the partial refund.

Most of the stores around here were doing a "first in, best dressed" type deal where the first people to come in would get the better of the editions (all customers were called and informed the day before), but I am sure there were stores that went by pre-order date and gave the best ones to the people who'd had it on pre-order the longest.
ok just want to point out how easy it would be to open one of these things take out what you wanted and put it back together. you can slide of the dam plastic and the box is designed to open. Personally I put the fault for this on

1. the carriers, not in that they did a bad job transporting it just maybe did a bad job making sure no one stole from their packages.
2. customs. I don't know about Australia but in the US if customs messes with your stuff they tend to not give two shits about damage after they've seen inside to the point that ive had discs flying around in the case so badly they chipped.
 

JayRPG

New member
Oct 25, 2012
585
0
0
ecoho said:
ok just want to point out how easy it would be to open one of these things take out what you wanted and put it back together. you can slide of the dam plastic and the box is designed to open. Personally I put the fault for this on

1. the carriers, not in that they did a bad job transporting it just maybe did a bad job making sure no one stole from their packages.
2. customs. I don't know about Australia but in the US if customs messes with your stuff they tend to not give two shits about damage after they've seen inside to the point that ive had discs flying around in the case so badly they chipped.
Slide off the damn plastic?

They were factory sealed, as in, the entire box was 100% heat sealed in plastic, with no tears/rips or repairs in the sealing, they had to be physically unsealed with a box cutter to get into them to be checked for damage.

If it were shipping companies or customs, I highly doubt that 95% of them would have been damaged and stolen from, we aren't talking about some of them being damaged, we are talking about ALL but some of them being damaged.

You could argue that the shipping companies or customs re-sealed them (which is a bit out there, I doubt customs have heat sealers and plastic of the same variety and size, customs also doesn't have to do that as anything seized by customs has to be labelled and they have no obligation to keep it in the same condition), but a quick youtube search of unboxings and seeing what the factory seal looked like on the editions that arrived in Australia would seem to suggest they came direct from the factory and were never opened.
 

GreyDevil

New member
Jul 4, 2009
26
0
0
Wow even Australia are getting DAI before me D: sucks that the Collector's edition are damaged. At the very least you are getting your money back (not quite the same as a nice shiny new Collector's edition but take what you can get).
 

LongAndShort

I'm pretty good. Yourself?
May 11, 2009
2,376
0
0
Only EB Games? Because if it is just EB Games then that might really be a carrier/warehousing fuck-up rather than because of EA.

Anyone know if JB Hi-Fi or any of the other big retailers have had a similar issue?
 

Killclaw Kilrathi

Crocuta Crocuta
Dec 28, 2010
263
0
0
ninja666 said:
Well, that sucks for our Australian gaming brethren. The worst part about it is they can only get a partial refund at best. I'd be pissed if I were in their shoes.
Balderdash. EB is only OFFERING partial refunds, but Australian consumer law says they can be forced to give a full refund if it's demanded. They can't refuse a full refund if the product they're offering is damaged or incomplete (i.e. not as advertised). They'll do everything they can to avoid letting people know that, but threaten to take it to the Ombudsman and they won't be able to hand your money back fast enough.
 

chozo_hybrid

What is a man? A miserable little pile of secrets.
Jul 15, 2009
3,479
14
43
LongAndShort said:
Only EB Games? Because if it is just EB Games then that might really be a carrier/warehousing fuck-up rather than because of EA.

Anyone know if JB Hi-Fi or any of the other big retailers have had a similar issue?
Over here in NZ they're the only retailer that got this edition, I imagine it's the same in Australia too. If so, that doesn't rule out EA.