Does Madden 11 deserve its praise?

[cloudskyff7]

What do you think? Also, why can't I skip the replays?

Escapist vs TGWTG Fight!

1) http://www.escapistmagazine.com/articles/view/editorials/reviews/7995-Review-Madden-NFL-11

2) http://www.lordkat.com/lordkat-rants-madden-2011.html

Personally, the in game product placement goes too far.

 

[Miumaru]

I personally do no think so, but I just hate sports and sport games.
But its popularity supports the fact that gamers do not want new.

 

[JourneyThroughHell]

I am disappointing and utterly crushed to see Jason descend to such levels. I am part of both communities and I really don't think Madden deserves the good reviews it gets, but what he did was petty and low.

I am not the one who usually agrees with John Funk (though the guy is entertaining and he is a nice person, different tastes and all), but to bash the whole Escapist community based on one fucking review is unacceptable.

Also, no, I don't think Madden deserves its praise.