Evil choices you hardly couldnt get yourself to do

[CutCrane]

This Topic is especially for Gamers who appreciate games with
a Choice-System like KOTOR, Dragon Age or Mass Effect. And most of the People i know
start with a good playtrough and follow up with an Evil one. But when you took the
dark path, was there ever an evil choice you really hesitated to do?
For me it would be the possessed Son of Arl Eamon and the descission to kill him while hes unconscious. (Alistair was pissed)
So, how about you guys?

 

[McMullen]

ME2:
I imagine the whole internet will post this one too, but betraying Tali during her loyalty mission is something I've never done and felt bad about just watching on YouTube.

ME1:
Giving Udina the council seat. Fuck that guy forever.

KOTOR:
The woman on Tatooine who's trying to sell a valuable Wraid plate as the last thing of value she has. Took it from her forcefully, felt so terrible about it that an hour or so later I resolved to reverse course and come as far back to the light as possible (had gone almost fully dark at that point).

 

[Moonlight Butterfly]

Killing the rachni queen.

I mean punching a reporter is one thing...but genocide?

:<

My renegade Shepard is never mean to Joker because well....It's Joker guys. The rest of the crew probably have some sort of complex over it.

 

[AlternatePFG]

I don't think I could take the evil path in Mask of the Betrayer.

 

[sbb]

Does the Witcher count? Choices aren't really black or white, but often made me feel like a huge dick. Siding with the genocidal humans instead of the terrorist elves and dwarves made me feel like a huge racist, but THEY GAVE ME NO CHOICE!

 

[TheLastSamurai14]

I couldn't bring myself to kidnap the baby in The Pitt DLC of Fallout 3. I can slaughter and enslave almost anyone, and I can detonate a nuclear bomb a million times over, but kidnapping an infant is just...wrong.

 

[Vausch]

I can't listen to Caesar in New Vegas. Sometimes I even set out to do so and I can't do it.

 

[Wierdguy]

Its just absolutley impossible for me to play KOTOR and NOT turn on Juhaani and Jolee and go with bastila on top of the temple. Even if I play it 100% goody-two-shoes I just cant stop myself... and I love it every single time!

Edit: I seem to have missread exactly what the question was about :/

Hesitated eh, never could bring myself to kill Leliana in DA:O, still dont have that achievement for corrupting the urn because of it.

 

[OmniscientOstrich]

This Topic is especially for Gamers who appreciate games with
a Choice-System like KOTOR, Dragon Age or Mass Effect. And most of the People i know
start with a good playtrough and follow up with an Evil one. But when you took the
dark path, was there ever an evil choice you really hesitated to do?
For me it would be the possessed Son of Arl Eamon and the descission to kill him while hes unconscious. (Alistair was pissed)
So, how about you guys?

Yeah, but Alistair gets pissy with you whatever choice you take the hypocritical shit. A for your question:

ME2:
I imagine the whole internet will post this one too, but betraying Tali during her loyalty mission is something I've never done and felt bad about just watching on YouTube.

ME1:
Giving Udina the council seat. Fuck that guy forever.

This. Fuck him forever indeed, that option makes no sense for Paragon or Renegade Shep.

 

[Wapox]

I usually start off with an evil playthrough.. cuz it's generally more fun..

It's actually in the GOOD playthrough that I have problems... like in Fable 3... yes I made 2 playthroughs.. I found out the positive side to being "evil" and then I couldn't get myself to SPEND money that was needed for protection... without having another form of income... so I was pretty screwed... although... I did have a hard time killing a lot of citizens in my "evil" playthrough... I don't like farming evil points.... I want to be truly evil... and not... Hey look at me I can kill the entire world and then I'm full evil...

So... Mindless evil farming is the hard part in the evil playthrough... I guess...

Sorry if this iis off track... kindda tired xD

 

[Al-Bundy-da-G]

I can't listen to Caesar in New Vegas. Sometimes I even set out to do so and I can't do it.

yeah one mission from him after than i wiped out the whole legion camp with Boone and EDE still didn't make up for helping him even once.

 

[00slash00]

Does the Witcher count? Choices aren't really black or white, but often made me feel like a huge dick. Siding with the genocidal humans instead of the terrorist elves and dwarves made me feel like a huge racist, but THEY GAVE ME NO CHOICE!

my second playthrough of the witcher was so difficult for me. when i sided with the humans and when i killed the werewolf (im trying to make this as spoiler free as i can but i think you know what im talking about) i felt so awful and almost didnt want to keep going because it was so against what i felt was right....god i love the witcher

 

[DustyDrB]

Spoiler: KotOR actually has the hardest one to do

Making Zalbaar kill Mission. That was the last time I made myself do an evil playthrough of anything. It's not worth it.

 

[Smertnik]

Nope, I love being a dick in video games. If a choice is given I always make the "evil" playthough first (often enough it remains my only playthrough). I regret nothing!

Spoiler: KotOR actually has the hardest one to do

Making Zalbaar kill Mission. That was the last time I made myself do an evil playthrough of anything. It's not worth it.

I found that part the best one in the dark Jedi arc. It was nearly as good as

Spoiler

enslaving your teammates

in Jade Empire.

 

[StellarViking]

I can never really do an evil quest line. I always feel bad about stealin' innocent people's stuff. That being said, though, what's bizarre is I loved the Dark Brotherhood quests in Oblivion, though when I found out That the dead drops were sabotaged and had me killing off members of the Dark Brotherhood I felt kinda crappy, and I also felt bad when Lucien LaChance was all murdered and stuff though he wasn't to blame .

 

[OldGus]

Betraying any friend in any game is usually difficult for me, especially if I've spent a lot of time with them.
ME2. The game calls it the good action, but I consider it more evil, and have serious problems deciding to rewrite the renegade geth. Also, trying to do all-renegade, I've made a lot of dialogue choices which have really, really been difficult, or that I have regretted, usually involving the crew.

 

[Azure-Supernova]

Enslaving people to get into Paradise Falls in Fallout 3 tugged on my heart strings a bit. In the end I couldn't do it and just saved, enslaved them and reloaded after completing the quest just for the trophy. Just too good hearted for that. I had no trouble slaughtering the Paradise Falls residents and claiming the place as my own heavily guarded base.

 

[Atticus89]

ME1:
Giving Udina the council seat. Fuck that guy forever.

"Nobody stabs me in the back, Udina. Nobody!"

 

[Fr]anc[is]

I felt really bad the first time I killed Dog in DA:O, my very first time I was a noble so I didn't have a choice. I can do it no problem now, all the little jerk does is make noise when I'm trying to talk to people