I'm trying to be a writer. (wall of text)

Recommended Videos

SleepyOtter

New member
Apr 28, 2010
215
0
0
Now I just want someone to read this short story and tell me what you think. The only real problem I have is finding someone to critique my writing to make it better, any help would be nice, thanks.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Six minutes to midnight. Read my watch by silver hands, it stopped for a moment, I tapped its glass cover to restart the gears inside. It jerked forward reluctantly, then went back into its aligned spot. I took a sip of coffee, it was cold now, bitter too, but that was unimportant. I sat, alone, at a small table indoors, the leather seats would squeak lightly every so often. Asking me in a soft rubbery voice to move. I ignored it. Instead taking another sip of my coffee, then looking down to my watch again.

Five minutes to midnight. The diner was quiet, cold, and smelled of an old tire. The reasons for coming here were lost to me at this point. The coffee?s taste declined, as well as the hamburgers they supplied. They were always cold, just like the coffee I now drank, alone. I waited for a person whom was most certainly not coming, but my perseverance preceded my annoyance. A small ring from the bell hung above the door excited me like a dog awaiting food. An old couple walked in, hand in hand, together, smiling. I looked back down to my watch.

Four minutes to midnight. I looked over towards the small waitress smiling as she took the old couple?s order. Her hair was tied neatly behind her head, a small paper cap lay over it. Her apron was dirty, the knot looked tight behind her back, aggressively tight even. She would pull at the knot behind her back occasionally to stop the choking it would induce, still smiling and writing down the order for the old couple. She completed the order and walked to the kitchen, wiping fallen hair out of her face and fixing her paper cap. I looked back down to my watch.

Three minutes to midnight. I turned to the counter near the entrance, there was a man sitting, alone. He had a light hooded jacket on, grey and black pinstripes aligned vertically on the coat. He was sitting with a friend of the same age, younger even, whom was smoking a cigarette butt. Unaware that the cigarette?s tobacco had burnt out for some time, he started coughing feverishly, crushing the butt on the marble counter in front of him. He held a tightly packed fist in front of his mouth, catching the debris in his palm. His friend patted his back for comfort, unfocused by the waitress whom carried out coffee for the old couple, still was she pulling at the apron?s knot. I looked back down to my watch.

Two minutes to midnight. The Waitress placed the coffee?s down for the old couple, turned to see the coughing boy?s friend as he stared back at her, smiling. The waitress blushed while tugging at her apron knot and approached the coughing man?s friend. The coughing boy, still coughing, got up to go to the bathroom, his face was dug into the corner of his arm. As he went out of sight, I heard the bathroom door squeak close, his coughs muffled by the walls separating us. Back to the coughing boy?s friend who was flirting with the waitress, still tugging at her apron knots. They would smile at each other lightly, then laugh, then smile again. The never ending cycle of flirting, compressed within a minute. I looked back down to my watch.

A minute to midnight. I reached for my coffee, now empty, the stained mug was heavy in my hands, the smell of African coffee beans assaulted my sinus?s. The coughing boy left the bathroom, pale, and weary. He stopped just short of the edge of the counter, staring at the waitress, still tugging at her apron knot. He moved to her with purpose, pushing his friend out of the way he grabbed the waitress, leaned her back, resting the back of her head in the corner of his arm. He kissed her strongly, color returning to his face, they stayed together, faces compacted together, never leaving one another. The man straightened out, along with the girl, whose apron had fallen to the ground amidst the kissing. The Man?s friend sat, quiet, stunned, now pale, he took a sip of the coffee in front of him, cringed, then left the store, without a word. I looked down to my watch.

The hands were frozen again, stuck at exactly the fifty ninth second on the fifty ninth minute of the eleventh hour. I tapped the glass again, the hands stayed the same. I took off the watch, held it to my ear, listened for a noise, nothing. I turned the dials on the side, nothing. Suddenly the hand lurched forward yet again as suspected. The old couple across the diner had left after the kissing fiasco, as did the man and waitress. I looked down to my watch.

Midnight. The bell rang, yet again, I looked up, hopeful. I looked up into his pair of dark Blue eyes and wept quietly to myself.
 

Kpt._Rob

Travelling Mushishi
Apr 22, 2009
2,417
0
0
Well, you have some small problems, everything from bad grammar here and there the the aggressive overuse of adjectives and adverbs, but if you want me to be perfectly blunt with you here, as I hope you would if you want to be a writer, you've got another problem so big that I hesitate to even mention the small problems. Specifically, the problem you have is that the story you're telling here really isn't interesting as a short story. Part of being an artist is picking your medium, some stories are better told in prose, some in film, or even in graphic novels, this piece wants desperately to be a poem, though to be honest, even as a poem it wouldn't be all that interesting. What you've got here is a lot of pretty words, but nothing is happening. It's maddening. Then there's something at the end, I'm not sure if it's supposed to be a twist ending or what, but if it is then you'll have to make it more clear what it is, and have more substance for it to twist. Writers with a reputation can afford to be cryptic and demand the reader to solve mysteries, up and comers, however, generally can not afford that luxury.

So let me say this, obviously you know your way around the English language, you've clearly devoted a lot of time to figuring out how to say things in a pretty way, but saying things in a pretty way won't do you much good as an author if you haven't got anything interesting to say in a pretty way. And beyond that, saying things in a pretty way is often disadvantageous for contemporary authors, and it can be disastrous for new authors. The first thing you should do, if you want to be an author, is come up with a story or with characters around which you can create a story. After that, then you can get to putting words with it, though I would suggest trying less to make things sound nice, and more to make them concise.

If I can give you two other pieces of advice that I inevitably end up giving when I see people looking for advice on their stories around here:

1) Pick up a copy of On Writing by Stephen King. Regardless of what you think of the man's writing, there's no denying that he's one of (if not the) most successful contemporary authors. He's a man who knows his way around a story, and not just around horror stories, in fact, my personal opinion is that some of his best stories are those which don't have horror themes at all. He creates interesting characters with depth that you want to know more about. On Writing is partially his memoirs, and partially a master class on writing. It's full of excellent stuff, and I can't imagine how any prospective author could go wrong with it.

2) See if there are any creative writing classes that you can take in your area. No matter how good an author you are already, taking a writing class will really help you see your strengths and weaknesses as an author, not just by having your story critiqued by other writers, but by critiquing the stories written by others. Seriously, I can not understate how much you will learn by critiquing stories that your classmates have written. If you're in college, there's a good chance you can take a class there, and if not if your town has a community center or something like that, those often offer writing classes. It's fun and as I've already said, you'll learn a lot. It's an invaluable resource, and if you want to be an author it'll do a lot for you.
 

Lilani

Sometimes known as CaitieLou
May 27, 2009
6,581
0
0
Kpt._Rob said:
Thank you! :D I am not the OP, but I'm working on a story myself and I've been digging around for some good advice on how to start. Next semester I'm already signed up for a creative writing class at my university, and I'll see about that Stephen King book this summer.
 

Kpt._Rob

Travelling Mushishi
Apr 22, 2009
2,417
0
0
Lilani said:
Kpt._Rob said:
Thank you! :D I am not the OP, but I'm working on a story myself and I've been digging around for some good advice on how to start. Next semester I'm already signed up for a creative writing class at my university, and I'll see about that Stephen King book this summer.
Well I'm glad to help, I used to be an aspiring author myself, and now I'm an aspiring graphic-novelist. Writing and storytelling in general is something I've devoted a sizable chunk of my life to, it's something I love, and I'm always happy to offer whatever advice I can to other aspiring artists.

And if you want, feel free to friend me, and you can send me any stories you've written or that you write, which I'd be happy to critique. That goes for you as well if you're reading this OP (or anyone else for that matter). I won't claim to be the world's most brilliant editor (I'm not), or claim that my advice is sage wisdom (It's not), but I try to offer what I can, and it always seems to me that there are lots of people looking for story critiques.
 

Paksenarrion

New member
Mar 13, 2009
2,911
0
0
SleepyOtter said:
Six minutes to midnight.

The silver hands of my watch silently state, stopping for a moment, before I tap its glass cover to restart the gears inside. It jerked forward reluctantly, then went back to marking time. I take a sip of coffee, now cold and bitter, but that was unimportant. I sit alone at a small table, the leather seats squeaking lightly whenever I move. I ignore it. Instead, I take another sip of my coffee and look down at my watch again.

Five minutes to midnight.

The diner is quiet, cold, and smells like aged rubber. My reasons for coming here are lost to me at this point. The coffee?s taste declines, as well as the hamburgers they supply. The burgers were always cold, just like the coffee I now drank alone. I wait for a person who is certainly not coming, but my perseverance (outweigh/surpass) my annoyance. A small ring from the bell hanging above the door excites me like a dog awaiting food. An old couple walks in hand in hand, smiling. I look back down at my watch.

Four minutes to midnight.

I look over towards the small waitress, who is smiling as she takes the old couple?s order. Her hair is tied neatly behind her head, a small paper cap lying on top. Her apron is dirty, the knot aggressively tight behind her back. She pulls at the knot behind her back occasionally to try and loosen it, still smiling and writing down the order for the old couple. She completes the order and walks to the kitchen, wiping fallen hair out of her face and fixing her paper cap. I look back down at my watch.

Three minutes to midnight.

I turn towards the counter near the entrance, and see a man sitting alone. He has a light hooded jacket, with grey and black pinstripes running vertically on his coat. He is sitting with a friend of the same age, perhaps younger, who is smoking a cigarette. Unaware that the cigarette is close to gone, he starts coughing feverishly, crushing the remaining butt on the marble counter in front of him. He holds a tightly clenched fist in front of his mouth, catching the debris in his palm. His friend pats his back for comfort, distracted by the waitress who is carrying out coffee for the old couple. She keeps pulling at her apron?s knot. I look back down at my watch.

Two minutes to midnight.

The waitress places the coffee down for the old couple, turns to see the coughing man?s friend as he stares back at her, smiling. The waitress blushes while tugging at her apron knot and approaches him. The coughing man, still struggling to clear his lungs, gets up to go to the bathroom, his face dug into the corner of his arm. As he goes out of sight, I hear the bathroom door squeak close, his coughs muffled by the walls separating us. Back to the coughing man?s friend, who is flirting with the waitress. She's still tugging at her apron knots. They smile at each other lightly, then laugh, then smile again. The never ending cycle of flirting, compressed within a minute. I look back down at my watch.

A minute to midnight.

I reach for my coffee, now empty, the stained mug heavy in my hands. The smell of African coffee beans assault my sinuses. The coughing man comes back from the bathroom, pale and weary. He stops just short of the edge of the counter, staring at the waitress, who is still tugging at her apron knot. He moves to her with purpose, pushing his friend out of the way. He grabs the waitress, leans her back, and rests the back of her head in the corner of his arm. He kisses her strongly, color returning to his face. The man lets go of the waitress, whose apron has fallen to the ground amidst the kissing. The man?s friend sits, stunned and pale. He takes a sip of the coffee in front of him, cringes, then leaves the store without a word. I look down at my watch.

The hands are frozen again, stuck at exactly the fifty ninth second on the fifty ninth minute of the eleventh hour. I tap the glass again, but the hands stay the same. I take off the watch, hold it to my ear, listening for a noise.

Nothing.

I turn the dials on the side.

Nothing.

Suddenly the hand lurches forward yet again. The old couple across the diner had left after the kissing fiasco, as did the man and the waitress. I look down at my watch.

Midnight.

The bell rings, yet again, and I look up, hopeful. I look up into the coughing man's dark blue eyes and weep quietly to myself.
Something like this, right? This took me quite some time to correct.