Foolery said:
I actually really like the world of Drangleic.
"The fire will fade, and the souls of old will reemerge. With Dark unshackled, a curse will be upon us. And men will take their true shape?"
Vendrick gets built up as this godly king from the start, and when you finally reach him, he's a pale shadow of his former self. My biggest complaints with DS2 is that some of the mechanics and world design are janky. I don't like having my health degrade (the binding ring helps), and the hitboxes/hit areas for some bosses are off (grabs that shouldn't happen); and in the SOTFS edition, there are way too many mob encounters (have fun with all those Alonne knights in the Iron Keep).
Not to mention WeaponSmith Ornifex.
Right down the road my ass....If there was a more inhospitable place in Dranlegic to have a shop, I'm not sure where she could have found one(aside from Black Gulch, obviously).
But Venrick's whole plot arc was one of the high parts of the story and the part that seemed the most fleshed out. A lot of the rest of it seemed like it was kind of there, or meant to be part of a larger whole that never quite came together.
For example: The Great souls. Implied to be the same great souls from the first game but in NG+ you actually get souls that specifically say "Old Witches Soul", "Old Dead One's Soul" and so on. It's implied that maybe the creatures are reincations of Seethe, The Witch, Gwyn, etc except other evidence that seems to say otherwise.
Venrick apparently collected 4 great souls himself so he could claim the throne, so somewhere along the way those souls migrated back to become the new old ones(Who are both so old they don't have names but at the same time apparently younger then Venrick, unless I'm reading it wrong).
Then there's the matter of the Primal Bonfires which, as far as I can tell, have no lore about them at all. They exist as a gameplay mechanic and always show up near the Great Souls to take you back to Majula(without violating the no-bonfire run conditions) but beyond they're not even mentioned. It feels like yet another idea that they planned to flesh out and never got around to.