I read an article today about "pushy parents", mothers and fathers who want their children to be superstars by making them do 9001 different extra-curricular activites (violin, science clubs, football, etc.). It was the format of several different columns written by several different mothers detailing their opinions on the matter and how they act with their own kids. One mother who was making her kids take part in all kinds of things said she was bribing one of her daughters to take GCSE Latin (that's Standard Grade for us Scots, high school level for everyone else, I think).
My question is this: in this day and age, when Latin isn't a widely-spoken language anymore, why would anyone want to study it? There are literally 100+ more useful languages out there to learn (including, but not limited to, Mandarin, Spanish, Russian and Arabic). Can someone enlighten me as to the uses for studying such a redundant language?
I'm all for kids learning languages - I really wish my parents had pushed me to do more of that sort of thing - but surely the time is better spent on languages that will actually be of use. On a related note, I watched this programme tonight that featured a young girl (possibly 10 or 11) who spoke fluently Vietnamese, English, Hindi, Arabic, Mandarin, Spanish, Japanese and Russian - pretty astonishing (though not as much as the guy who spoke 64 languages fluently back in the 1800s; can't remember the name).
TL;DR Why doesn't Latin suck? Tell me.
Edit again: So the most common answer people are giving is that learning Latin helps learning other Romance languages - does anyone have any actual experience of this or are you just assuming things? This poster would beg to differ:
My question is this: in this day and age, when Latin isn't a widely-spoken language anymore, why would anyone want to study it? There are literally 100+ more useful languages out there to learn (including, but not limited to, Mandarin, Spanish, Russian and Arabic). Can someone enlighten me as to the uses for studying such a redundant language?
I'm all for kids learning languages - I really wish my parents had pushed me to do more of that sort of thing - but surely the time is better spent on languages that will actually be of use. On a related note, I watched this programme tonight that featured a young girl (possibly 10 or 11) who spoke fluently Vietnamese, English, Hindi, Arabic, Mandarin, Spanish, Japanese and Russian - pretty astonishing (though not as much as the guy who spoke 64 languages fluently back in the 1800s; can't remember the name).
TL;DR Why doesn't Latin suck? Tell me.
Edit: Please don't assume I'm a philistine - I like learning for the sake of learning (studying Japanese atm); still doesn't seem reason enough to learn Latin, though.[br]Pic Related: "Pushy Parent"![]()
Edit again: So the most common answer people are giving is that learning Latin helps learning other Romance languages - does anyone have any actual experience of this or are you just assuming things? This poster would beg to differ:
tautologico said:I studied some Latin (not much, but enough to have an idea of the language). My native language is Portuguese and I speak French, Spanish and Italian with varying levels of ability.
This thing about knowing Latin helping to learn romance languages is mostly bullshit. It does not help much beyond the basic roots and one or two things about syntax (verb tenses, a few things). Maybe if you know Latin really really well it does help to understand why some piece of syntax in the current romance languages is the way it is, but I doubt it. The romance languages have evolved for millenia after branching off from Latin, there is a lot of stuff there that is due to independent language evolution. The romance languages themselves are similar because of common roots and because they evolved in geographic proximity. Even so, French for instance is quite different from Portuguese, and Romanian has a lot of words with slavic roots.
So I don't think studying Latin is very useful today, in most cases. Not even to learn the romance languages. It may be useful if you want to study classic literature or the history of the Roman Empire or something like this. If someone want to study because they think it is cool, no problem with that. But it's not terribly useful, no.