My Review of The Beatles Rock Band

Recommended Videos

IceWarm

New member
Apr 8, 2008
25
0
0
http://blog.icewarm.org/?p=443

The Beatles Rock Band Review:

I?ve been playing quite a bit of The Beatles Rock Band lately and here are my thoughts on the game.

First things first, if you're not a fan of The Beatles you will not like this game. If you are a fan you should enjoy it very much. The game has a variety of modes like the other Rock Band games however the story mode in this game does not get progressively harder. Instead you follow the career of The Beatles from the Cavern Club all the way to their rooftop performance of the Apple Corps building. The songs also follow this chronological order so the difficulty tends to fluctuate quite a bit with some difficult songs at the beginning and some harder songs in the end and so on

The graphics are beautifully done and the cutscenes are amazing, especially the opening and closing cutscenes. The environments in each area are nice as well with the earlier levels featuring crazed Beatles fan girls screaming when they see The Beatles. The later stages take place it the Abbey Road studios and you get treated to beautiful dreamscapes for each song in these levels. These dreamscapes start a little after the song and usually follow the theme to the song. For example in Yellow Submarine you start the song and you see the Yellow Submarine floating around and you see The Beatles dressed in their clothing from the cartoon movie. In Sgt. Pepper?s Lonely Hearts Club band you see the band playing in their iconic band uniforms. These dreamscapes really add a lot to the game and capture the essence of the music in the later half of their career.

The rest of the gameplay is basically the same as any other Rock Band game. The only real new feature is the three part harmony sections. If you have the microphones available up to three people can sing in this game. One lead singer and then there are two harmony sections and then they come together in a three part harmony. This is definitely a nice feature. I hope to see it in future Rock Band games.

There are some nice unlockables as well including photographs, and videos.

The music in the game is great. I won?t go into detail on the songs since they are all Beatles songs.

Even though there are many high points in the game there are still some downsides. The main downside being there is only 45 songs included in the game. 45 songs is still a decent amount but considering a lot of them are fairly short you can complete the story mode in about four hours. DLC will fix this and give us more songs but the only DLC available as of now is the song All You Need Is Love. The remaining Abbey Road tracks are scheduled to be released in mid-October.

Another downside is that the three part harmony sections can?t be played over Xbox Live. It would have been a nide touch to be able to have three people come together in the vocal harmony sections over Xbox Live. These sections need to be played on the same system.

Overall Beatles fans will really enjoy this game and it is a very good game. Non-Beatles fans should stay away.

Pros:

* Excellent music
* Dreamscapes and cut-scenes look amazing
* Three part vocal harmony sections

Cons:

* Fairly small track list(Bigger list after three DLC albums, but still not enough especially if they don't release the rest of the White Album.)
* Not for everyone
* No three part harmony sections over Xbox Live

Overall Score: * * * *
 

JourneyThroughHell

New member
Sep 21, 2009
5,010
0
0
"Not for everyone" is not bad. In fact, it's the whole idea of band-specific rhythm games. They are not for everyone.
The tracklist, IMHO, was fantasticc especially since it included my favorite George Harisson songs. Alright, "Help" would be nice but...
The story mode was completed by me and my friend in three hours but The Beatles: Rock Band is still the most played game on our get-togethers, defeating both GH:WT and the original Rock Band.
 

Darth_Dude

New member
Jul 11, 2008
1,302
0
0
Great review, but maybe some pictures or sommething?

I know its on the xbox, but you could have a few screenshots from google or something in there. Might add to it a little bit.
 

IceWarm

New member
Apr 8, 2008
25
0
0
Journeythroughhell said:
"Not for everyone" is not bad. In fact, it's the whole idea of band-specific rhythm games. They are not for everyone.
The tracklist, IMHO, was fantasticc especially since it included my favorite George Harisson songs. Alright, "Help" would be nice but...
The story mode was completed by me and my friend is three hours but The Beatles: Rock Band is still the most played game on our get-togethers, defeating both GH:WT and the original Rock Band.
I didn't mean anything in that review as a knock or the completion time as being a bad thing, I cried during the ending cinematic. The "Help" album as well as the remainder of the White Album though should be released as DLC. "Help" is in my opinion one of their best albums.

I wrote that review as objectively as I could. It breaks my heart to say anything bad about the game, however I have to be objective.

I feel like Jeremy near the end of the Yellow Submarine movie...gagged.
 

JourneyThroughHell

New member
Sep 21, 2009
5,010
0
0
IceWarm said:
Journeythroughhell said:
"Not for everyone" is not bad. In fact, it's the whole idea of band-specific rhythm games. They are not for everyone.
The tracklist, IMHO, was fantasticc especially since it included my favorite George Harisson songs. Alright, "Help" would be nice but...
The story mode was completed by me and my friend is three hours but The Beatles: Rock Band is still the most played game on our get-togethers, defeating both GH:WT and the original Rock Band.
I didn't mean anything in that review as a knock or the completion time as being a bad thing, I cried during the ending cinematic. The "Help" album as well as the remainder of the White Album though should be released as DLC. "Help" is in my opinion one of their best albums.

I wrote that review as objectively as I could. It breaks my heart to say anything bad about the game, however I have to be objective.

I feel like Jeremy near the end of the Yellow Submarine movie...gagged.
Just saying - band specific games are definitely not for everyone.
 

IceWarm

New member
Apr 8, 2008
25
0
0
Journeythroughhell said:
IceWarm said:
Journeythroughhell said:
"Not for everyone" is not bad. In fact, it's the whole idea of band-specific rhythm games. They are not for everyone.
The tracklist, IMHO, was fantasticc especially since it included my favorite George Harisson songs. Alright, "Help" would be nice but...
The story mode was completed by me and my friend is three hours but The Beatles: Rock Band is still the most played game on our get-togethers, defeating both GH:WT and the original Rock Band.
I didn't mean anything in that review as a knock or the completion time as being a bad thing, I cried during the ending cinematic. The "Help" album as well as the remainder of the White Album though should be released as DLC. "Help" is in my opinion one of their best albums.

I wrote that review as objectively as I could. It breaks my heart to say anything bad about the game, however I have to be objective.

I feel like Jeremy near the end of the Yellow Submarine movie...gagged.
Just saying - band specific games are definitely not for everyone.
I loved The Beatles Rock Band as well as Guitar Hero Metallica...I got Guitsr Hero Van Halen too...they failed. The Van Halen tracks are awesome but the only other track I knew and liked was Semi-Charmed Life because that song was overused back in 1998.
 

Cherry Cola

Your daddy, your Rock'n'Rolla
Jun 26, 2009
11,940
0
0
The Beatles Rock Band: Hubilubs Game of the Year 2009.

All hail the Beatles!
 

JourneyThroughHell

New member
Sep 21, 2009
5,010
0
0
IceWarm said:
Journeythroughhell said:
IceWarm said:
Journeythroughhell said:
"Not for everyone" is not bad. In fact, it's the whole idea of band-specific rhythm games. They are not for everyone.
The tracklist, IMHO, was fantasticc especially since it included my favorite George Harisson songs. Alright, "Help" would be nice but...
The story mode was completed by me and my friend is three hours but The Beatles: Rock Band is still the most played game on our get-togethers, defeating both GH:WT and the original Rock Band.
I didn't mean anything in that review as a knock or the completion time as being a bad thing, I cried during the ending cinematic. The "Help" album as well as the remainder of the White Album though should be released as DLC. "Help" is in my opinion one of their best albums.

I wrote that review as objectively as I could. It breaks my heart to say anything bad about the game, however I have to be objective.

I feel like Jeremy near the end of the Yellow Submarine movie...gagged.
Just saying - band specific games are definitely not for everyone.
I loved The Beatles Rock Band as well as Guitar Hero Metallica...I got Guitsr Hero Van Halen too...they failed. The Van Halen tracks are awesome but the only other track I knew and liked was Semi-Charmed Life because that song was overused back in 1998.
They had "I want it all" by Queen.
That, alone, is an epic win.
 

JourneyThroughHell

New member
Sep 21, 2009
5,010
0
0
Hubilub said:
The Beatles Rock Band: Hubilubs Game of the Year 2009.

All hail the Beatles!
I loved it, too, but the GOTY for me is still Modern Warfare 2.
I guess you already figured that out by the avatar.
 

neoman10

Big Brother
Sep 23, 2008
1,199
0
0
It was only a matter of time before I found this thread

But I love this game, I bought all the DLC as of yet and will buy more if released. Surprised how many of their best songs were left out. I want to play strawberry fields forever >:O

Edit: How does a true Beatles fan not cry at this ;_;

<youtube=_HOoKMcVMY8>
 

Avatar Roku

New member
Jul 9, 2008
6,169
0
0
Great review, I loved this game too. I usually don't sing in a Rockband game, but I was practically begging to in this one, I love the Beatles.
 

Onyx Oblivion

Borderlands Addict. Again.
Sep 9, 2008
17,032
0
0
As a Beatles hater, because of the following song, and a guy who plays GH on Medium (and doesn't even 100% any song, ever!), because he doesn't play it much, I will stay away from this.

THIS SONG SUUUUUUUUUUUUUCKS.

 

JourneyThroughHell

New member
Sep 21, 2009
5,010
0
0
Onyx Oblivion said:
As a Beatles hater, because of the following song, and a guy who plays GH on Medium (and doesn't even 100% any song, ever!), because he doesn't play it much, I will stay away from this.

THIS SONG SUUUUUUUUUUUUUCKS.

You serious???
Well, different strokes for different folks, I guess.
Still, a Beatles hater? How can that be?
 

Cherry Cola

Your daddy, your Rock'n'Rolla
Jun 26, 2009
11,940
0
0
Onyx Oblivion said:
As a Beatles hater, because of the following song, and a guy who plays GH on Medium (and doesn't even 100% any song, ever!), because he doesn't play it much, I will stay away from this.

THIS SONG SUUUUUUUUUUUUUCKS.

Must... not.... kill....
Journeythroughhell said:
Hubilub said:
The Beatles Rock Band: Hubilubs Game of the Year 2009.

All hail the Beatles!
I loved it, too, but the GOTY for me is still Modern Warfare 2.
I guess you already figured that out by the avatar.
It was a pretty damn good experience.

It was better than AC 2 at least.
 

JourneyThroughHell

New member
Sep 21, 2009
5,010
0
0
Hubilub said:
Onyx Oblivion said:
As a Beatles hater, because of the following song, and a guy who plays GH on Medium (and doesn't even 100% any song, ever!), because he doesn't play it much, I will stay away from this.

THIS SONG SUUUUUUUUUUUUUCKS.

Must... not.... kill....
Journeythroughhell said:
Hubilub said:
The Beatles Rock Band: Hubilubs Game of the Year 2009.

All hail the Beatles!
I loved it, too, but the GOTY for me is still Modern Warfare 2.
I guess you already figured that out by the avatar.
It was a pretty damn good experience.

It was better than AC 2 at least.
I haven't played it yet so please don't spoil but...
Was the ending really that bad? Since you seem to hate the game just because of it.
 

Onyx Oblivion

Borderlands Addict. Again.
Sep 9, 2008
17,032
0
0
Journeythroughhell said:
Onyx Oblivion said:
As a Beatles hater, because of the following song, and a guy who plays GH on Medium (and doesn't even 100% any song, ever!), because he doesn't play it much, I will stay away from this.

THIS SONG SUUUUUUUUUUUUUCKS.

You serious???
Well, different strokes for different folks, I guess.
Still, a Beatles hater? How can that be?
Okay, not a total hater. But a psychedelic bullshit hater.

I like stuff like this:

 

Cherry Cola

Your daddy, your Rock'n'Rolla
Jun 26, 2009
11,940
0
0
Journeythroughhell said:
Hubilub said:
Onyx Oblivion said:
As a Beatles hater, because of the following song, and a guy who plays GH on Medium (and doesn't even 100% any song, ever!), because he doesn't play it much, I will stay away from this.

THIS SONG SUUUUUUUUUUUUUCKS.

Must... not.... kill....
Journeythroughhell said:
Hubilub said:
The Beatles Rock Band: Hubilubs Game of the Year 2009.

All hail the Beatles!
I loved it, too, but the GOTY for me is still Modern Warfare 2.
I guess you already figured that out by the avatar.
It was a pretty damn good experience.

It was better than AC 2 at least.
I haven't played it yet so please don't spoil but...
Was the ending really that bad? Since you seem to hate the game just because of it.
Yes, the ending is that bad.

It ruined the whole experience for me.
 

JourneyThroughHell

New member
Sep 21, 2009
5,010
0
0
Hubilub said:
Journeythroughhell said:
Hubilub said:
Onyx Oblivion said:
As a Beatles hater, because of the following song, and a guy who plays GH on Medium (and doesn't even 100% any song, ever!), because he doesn't play it much, I will stay away from this.

THIS SONG SUUUUUUUUUUUUUCKS.

Must... not.... kill....
Journeythroughhell said:
Hubilub said:
The Beatles Rock Band: Hubilubs Game of the Year 2009.

All hail the Beatles!
I loved it, too, but the GOTY for me is still Modern Warfare 2.
I guess you already figured that out by the avatar.
It was a pretty damn good experience.

It was better than AC 2 at least.
I haven't played it yet so please don't spoil but...
Was the ending really that bad? Since you seem to hate the game just because of it.
Yes, the ending is that bad.

It ruined the whole experience for me.
Can't you just... pretend it's not there?