My Two Cents: District 9

Recommended Videos

kemosabi4

New member
May 12, 2009
591
0
0
[HEADING=1]My Two Cents Reviews[/HEADING]

I've decided to brand my reviews from now on, although I'm not sure how many reviews I'll actually write. This will be my second review after my Prototype review [http://www.escapistmagazine.com/forums/read/326.127937]. I was in the process of writing a FarCry 2 review, but somewhere along the way, I gave up. I hope that you will enjoy my review, and I hope to write many more on the Escapist. So, without further adieu, my review of District 9.

District 9 follows Wikus Van de Merwe (Sharlto Copley), an employee of Multi-National United. MNU is a corporation that engineers and adapts new technologies for the betterment of society. MNU also holds power in many industries such as mining and healthcare. They also happen to be a private military company.

In 1982, a historic moment took place. An alien mother-ship glides to a stop above Johannesburg, South Africa. But for three months, nothing happened. Finally, the humans decided to cut their way in. But, instead of finding sophisticated, intelligent beings, they found a dirty, hungry mass of refugees, huddled in the dark recesses of the ship. The aliens were moved to a camp on the outskirts of the city. With heavy policing, it soon turned into a slum.



The international community, concerned about the conditions of District 9, tasked MNU with relocating the aliens to a clean, safe camp, called District 10. Wikus is put in charge of the operation, but becomes wounded in the line of duty. As a strange infection begins to alter his DNA, the MNU turns against him. He soon becomes the most hunted man in the world. Wikus soon forms a friendship with an alien who might know how to escape.

The most intriguing part of District 9, in my opinion, was the theme behind the movie. The central message comes in the form of the human's attitude towards the prawns. From the get-go, humans, even Wikus, are bigoted and and biased against the aliens. Armed forces willingly open fire with any provocation. Koobus Venter, head of the security division, seems to find any excuse to shoot a prawn.

Prawns are dirty animals to them. Wikus doesn't see this until MNU begins hunting him. He realizes that humans are naturally inclined to shun anything unnatural to them. That humans hate rather than accept. The feeling of absolute terror that Wikus projects to the audience is powerful. Sharlto Copley does an amazing job of projecting his emotions to the audience. You truly feel what you feel. I can only hope that Copley has the opportunity to act in more films, because the characterization he brings to the screen is amazing.


Wikus serves a eviction notice to a prawn

District 9 does a wonderful job of immersing the viewers. As with Copley's character, District 9 retains the feel of a classic sci-fi movie, while keeping it believable. The slum gives the viewers the gritty, dirty, dog-eat-dog feel of the real thing. The aliens' plight can be felt just by looking into their eyes. The immersion also links to the film's brilliant special effects.

District 9 is a pretty film. Everything from the aliens to the explosions felt and looked realistic. Wikus's transformation is amazing as well, but I don't want to go into details on that. I even stumbled across a forum for helicopter enthusiasts that had a discussion about how realistic the helicopters in the film were. The camera work also brings immersion to the film. Third-person camera work merges seamlessly with documentary-style and news-style cameras.

My only problem with District 9 is that it seems to subscribe to the same plot holes and cliches that many sci-fi films fall prey to. One big problem is Wikus's infection. The prawns use a genetic fuel inside their technology to ensure that only the prawns can use it. When this liquid enters his bloodstream, he begins to transform. But District 9 makes no attempt to explain it. It doesn't make any sense. The only thing that really turns me off is that most of the science behind it is, as Yahtzee would say, "so soft you can spread it on a croissant". Another plot hole is the conflict between Wikus and Koobus. Wikus zaps, burns, smashes, and blows his way through platoons of Koobus's men, but when confronted numerous times with a chance to kill Venter, he never takes it. Plot convenience is one thing, but when they stare each other in the face without even pointing their weapons, that's a little ridiculous.


Wikus (Sharlto Copley), alienated and on the run.

In conclusion, District 9 is beautiful, well-written, and immersive. The only things that set it off are a few plot holes and cliches. I highly recommend it. If there is a theatre that is showing it, see it when you can. I would even recommend buying it on DVD if you can't make it to a theater.

Thank you for reading my review. If you have any comments or points to make, feel free to post.
 

kemosabi4

New member
May 12, 2009
591
0
0
Furburt said:
Nice review. Very well structured and readable.

I didn't know the ship actually landed in 1982, interesting.
Thanks. Love your avatar, by the way.
 

Aunel

New member
May 9, 2008
1,927
0
0
well done, good chap,

although you might have spoiled it a little bit, that he becomes hunted and everything
but I trust every escapee has already seen it,

well done, I'll play some tunes for you,
 

Flap Jack452

New member
Jan 5, 2009
1,998
0
0
Nice review, and great movie. And because it's appropriate (0:57-0:59 is the funniest I think):
<youtube=E49BB1vE2tY>
 

mandrilltiger

New member
Mar 19, 2009
90
0
0
Nice review. This movie was freaking awesome and my only critque was that there wasn't engough of it. Which isn't a critque at all.
 

Marik2

Phone Poster
Nov 10, 2009
5,462
0
0
Flap Jack452 said:
Nice review, and great movie. And because it's appropriate (0:57-0:59 is the funniest I think)
Lol thank you for giving me another video I can add to my favorites.
 

kemosabi4

New member
May 12, 2009
591
0
0
Flap Jack452 said:
Nice review, and great movie. And because it's appropriate (0:57-0:59 is the funniest I think):
<youtube=E49BB1vE2tY>
I halfway considered mentioning the number of times he says "fook" in that movie. There are even #34 images of him saying "fook".
 

Hurr Durr Derp

New member
Apr 8, 2009
2,558
0
0
Meh, I've always thought District9 was overrated. A decent enough flic, sure, but not as good as most people seem to claim.

The whole apartheid thing was shallow, the zOMG EVIL SCIENCE CORPORATION OR WHATEVER HUMANS ARE THE REAL MONSTERS is boring and predictable, The evil cannibal voodoo negroes are retarded, the plot is full of holes, and halfway through it gets tired of its own weak shit and is like "fuck it I'm gonna do an action movie in stead".

But yeah, I know most people liked it and I can see why because it was pretty cool. It'd just be a lot better if it just accepted that it was a cool and reasonably original action sci-fi and didn't bother to pretend that it had an interesting plot because IMO it didn't.

Also don't use "without further adieu". It's "ado", not goodbye in French.
 

Garaw

New member
Sep 22, 2009
239
0
0
hURR dURR dERP said:
Meh, I've always thought District9 was overrated. A decent enough flic, sure, but not as good as most people seem to claim.

The whole apartheid thing was shallow, the zOMG EVIL SCIENCE CORPORATION OR WHATEVER HUMANS ARE THE REAL MONSTERS is boring and predictable, The evil cannibal voodoo negroes are retarded, the plot is full of holes, and halfway through it gets tired of its own weak shit and is like "fuck it I'm gonna do an action movie in stead".

But yeah, I know most people liked it and I can see why because it was pretty cool. It'd just be a lot better if it just accepted that it was a cool and reasonably original action sci-fi and didn't bother to pretend that it had an interesting plot because IMO it didn't.

Also don't use "without further adieu". It's "ado", not goodbye in French.
The biggest problem I had with this movie was the fact that its protagonist was an unsympathetic douchebag who had no concern whatsoever for his company's ruthlessness until it was turned on him. I can't think of an actor/script combination that better captures 'weaselly little shit'.

The nagging little details about the alien camp and why exactly alien gasoline manipulates humans genetically came in a distant second.
 

kemosabi4

New member
May 12, 2009
591
0
0
hURR dURR dERP said:
Meh, I've always thought District9 was overrated. A decent enough flic, sure, but not as good as most people seem to claim.

The whole apartheid thing was shallow, the zOMG EVIL SCIENCE CORPORATION OR WHATEVER HUMANS ARE THE REAL MONSTERS is boring and predictable, The evil cannibal voodoo negroes are retarded, the plot is full of holes, and halfway through it gets tired of its own weak shit and is like "fuck it I'm gonna do an action movie in stead".

But yeah, I know most people liked it and I can see why because it was pretty cool. It'd just be a lot better if it just accepted that it was a cool and reasonably original action sci-fi and didn't bother to pretend that it had an interesting plot because IMO it didn't.

Also don't use "without further adieu". It's "ado", not goodbye in French.
First off, the "evil humans" motif was thoughtful and fleshed-out. This and the apartheid were based off of real-life events taking place in Cape Town in the 1970s, where 60,000 blacks were forcibly removed from their homes and moved to bleak government settlements.

And please offer more about the Nigerian gang than "retarded". Their behavior is based off of real beliefs and behavior. The eating of body parts to gain power is a popular belief in underground South Africa.

And I thought the transference to action was justified and seamless. There was pretty much no other way to do it. I thought that the action in the movie felt natural, rather than forced.

The plot was interesting and contained virtually no holes aside from the ones mentioned in my review.
 

AkJay

New member
Feb 22, 2009
3,555
0
0
"Wikus (Sharlto Copley), alienated and on the run."

That was very funny. Sharp, witty, and punderful!
 

kemosabi4

New member
May 12, 2009
591
0
0
Garaw said:
The biggest problem I had with this movie was the fact that its protagonist was an unsympathetic douchebag who had no concern whatsoever for his company's ruthlessness until it was turned on him. I can't think of an actor/script combination that better captures 'weaselly little shit'.
Maybe I'm being an artsy douche by saying this, but I thought Wikus's attitude towards the aliens only captured how easily humans can break trust and how quick they can betray others without a second thought. His turnaround only amplified the message behind the movie.
 

kemosabi4

New member
May 12, 2009
591
0
0
AkJay said:
"Wikus (Sharlto Copley), alienated and on the run."

That was very funny. Sharp, witty, and punderful!
I didn't even realize that pun until I was 90% done with the review. Thanks for the compliment.
 

Jonny49

New member
Mar 31, 2009
1,250
0
0
Aye, District 9 is an amazing film. While I did feel that some parts were a little far-fetched, even considering the subject of the film, I found it impossibly compelling. Everything about the film was utterly fantastic. Good review.
 

Lullabye

New member
Oct 23, 2008
4,425
0
0
good solid review.

I loved district 9, and found it too be much better than*gets soap ready*...a....a...AVATAR!*quickly shoves soap down throat and scrubs furiously* i said a bad thing again.....
 

Woodsey

New member
Aug 9, 2009
14,553
0
0
Good review, well written and presented.

It's "an historic" not "a historic" though.

EDIT: Bah forget that, it's down to personal preference I suppose - I've always been taught the former.