Poll: Best Metallica Album and three best songs? (fixed poll)

[Dreamer of Theaters]

Recently I bought Master of Puppets (finally) for myself when I was going shopping for a birthday present for a friend. Since it is my first Metallica album (no, I'm not some little kid, I just never listened to them, I prefer the progressive metal like Tool) can someone tell me what they think their best album, and why not tell me what your favourite three songs by Metallica are?

 

[Dreamer of Theaters]

And this is the fixed version, I'm gonna delete the other thread now.

 

[Swny Nerdgasm]

Master of Puppets is pretty much, at least to me their best album.

 

[BlackStar42]

Pretty conclusive so far....

Anyway, my favourite songs would be One, Master of Puppets and Battery.

 

[DJDarque]

Master of Puppets is hands down their greatest album. Master of Puppets, Battery and The Four Horsemen are probably their best songs.

 

[Dreamer of Theaters]

Umm, how exactly do I delete previous threads? I can't get rid of the other one...
Can anyone help me about this?

 

[MiracleOfSound]

Puppets in general best album.

Justice would have been the best for me if it didn't have that horrible tinny production and clicky drum sound.

What is it with Lars and shitty drum sounds? Compensating for how much he sucks I guess.

Top 3 songs:

1. Orion
2. Wherever I May Roam
3. For Whom The Bell Tolls

 

[surg3n]

Top 3:
1: One
2: Unforgiven
3: Nothing Else Matters

What can I say, I like the Black Album, more mellow Metallica stuff.

 

[GeorgW]

The black album, and Sad but True, Enter Sandman, and Nothing Else Matters.
Duh.

I'll lock your other thread.

 

[Dreamer of Theaters]

What do you mean by "lock?"

 

[TheBananaKing]

Ride The Lightning for me

and favourite songs wise it has to be

Blackened (...And Justice for All)
Call Of Ktulu (Ride The Lightning)
Hit The Lights (Kill Em All)

all of which i saw live at Knebworth recently...(not being smug at all...)

 

[heavy-metal-ink]

I'd say Ride the Lightening is the best, though its hard to choose a favourite between the first 4 albums.
Anyway 3 favourite songs would be...
1- Battery
2- Fade to Black
3- Creeping Death

 

[Loop Stricken]

S&M is not on the list. This list is invalid!

 

[EightGaugeHippo]

Since Symphony and Metallica is not an option.
I put Master of Puppets for best album.

1. For Whom the Bell Tolls
2. Battery
3. Suicide and Redemption

 

[BumblebeeEU]

Ride the Lightning for album, for individual songs;

1. Fade to Black
2. Creeping Death
3. Master of Puppets (obvious I know.)

 

[The Elcor Batman]

I expected puppets to get the most votes, but its cool to see im not alone im my adoration for Lightning.

My three song choices: No Leaf Clover, For Whom the Bell Tolls and Battery.