Poll: Captain America role down to two actors?

[Vigilantis]

Source: http://screenrant.com/captain-america-cast-chad-michael-murray-ryan-mcpartlin-rob-44303/

So a new rumor has come out stating that we are down to two actors, Ryan McPartlin and Chad Michael Murray fighting to play main role in the upcoming Captain America movie. Personally Ryan would be my choice between the two, he at least somewhat looks the part where as Chad looks like a pretty face that would ruin the image of Captain America.

So now I want to ask, who would you choose if these were the last contenders for Cap's part, Ryan or Chad?

And for extra points who would you cast as Captain America if you personally had the choice?

(Big Ben Ryan hits the nail on the head for the 'look' of Captain America though.)

 

[SnootyEnglishman]

I say Zac Efron since the studio behind the movie is really going to make him sing.

 

[titankore]

Hey I thought Will Smith was going to get the role.

 

[nimibro]

didn't sam worthington got it?

 

[Batfred]

Matthew Mcconaughey I thought would have been good. He has an odd looking but chiselled face, he's ripped, it suits his contract to get his shirt off at least once in the film, he's 6'1" or something, blonde, blue eyes and has a mid-American drawl.

How much more Captain America can you get?!

How much of a gay fanboy do I sound?!

 

[mannsporte]

That guy in Jericho that played the farmer boy who fell in love with the insurance girl after she stayed with him and the guy was first pissed off then loved her and there was some catastrophe and her family was in another state or something like that...I'm a little fuzzy about the details but that guy (that played the farme.....) strongly reminded me Captain America as I recall...

 

[Crimson_Dragoon]

I know its not a popular opinion, but I liked the rumors that it would be Brad Pitt. He looks the role, has done action movies, and is a good actor (Fight Club, Seven, or Benjamin Button for those who disagree). Also, he has a lot of charisma, something a character like Captain America needs, especially in an Avengers movie where the actor will have to stand out beside other actors like Robert Downey Jr. and Samuel L. Jackson. Unfortunately, there's no chance of this actually happening.

 

[WolfThomas]

Who would I cast? Well it would have to one of these in no particular order.

Spoiler: Aaron Eckhart

No real explanation necessary just look at him, that's Steve Roger right thar.

Spoiler: Jon Hamm

Okay so he's not a natural blonde, but he has that all round American hero look to him with a strong jaw. But most importantly Mad Men shows us that he can convincingly act like someone from the fifties, which is close enough for Captain America and his out of date social behaviours and atitudes. Also he plays a compassionate older brother role to many of the other characters in that role, similar to Steve Rogers role in the Avengers.

Spoiler: Alexander Skarsguard

Tall, blonde and an excellent jawline. Also very physically fit. Although more popular recently for being in True Blood, Generation Kill showed us that he effectively can play a career soldier. The way he interacts with his men is exactly the way I'd imagine Captain America would, friendly and respectful but very serious and professional at important times (they call him Ice Man for a reason in the show).

Also:

Spoiler: Mark Valley

and

Spoiler: Jensen Ackles

 

[dalek sec]

I think John Barrowman would have been a good choice as well but that's just me.