Poll: Creativeness vs. Corporational controll

Recommended Videos

Kiltguy

Lurker extraordinaré
Jan 23, 2011
252
0
0
Ignore my avatar for a second (if it's possible)

Look past your prejudiced, and let me ask you a question, or rather I'll give you something to question.

A company hires a team of creative consultants for a project, said project met huge success, the creative team has developed some iconic main characters beloved by the hundreds, everything is fine in corporation world, the money keeps rolling in.

Now, the creative team creates other characters inhabiting the world of there success (let's call these background characters[BS for short]), one of these BC's get a huge following, a fan-base of epic proportion, does this affect marketing? In a small amount, nothing major.

Now, this BC is supposed to be killed off, for no other reason that it is an imperfect being in an otherwise perfect "universe".

(I could go into how intolerant and "such and such" this is, but that is a debate for another time)

Now the kicker...

I can comprehend, even understand the implications of creative control, franchise, and brand... Sure a company has first and last say about there "idea", but at the same time, they have hired this team of creative minds for a reason... to re-boot a dead franchise (to flog a dead horse, pardon the pun), and now they want to "milk the cow" and slaughter it at the same time.

Something doesn't ring right to me in this matter. My real question is somewhat rhetorical in nature; "Why does the big companies keep on doing this?"

When ever the money starts to really roll in, they start to change, decide, and effectively kill there own brand (sometimes slow, sometimes at alarming speed) by making changes that work against there market targets.​

(I'm not saying change is bad, but man sometimes it makes me wonder, is creativeness dead?)

Thoughts on the matter?

To keep this tread from flame please keep all MLP related arguments in spoilers, thank you.

If you haven't already sniffed it out, there are rumors about some huge changes in SE4. The one thing that caught my attention was the fact that they are killing of my beloved Derpy Hooves, and that made my brain work.
 

Loop Stricken

Covered in bees!
Jun 17, 2009
4,723
0
0
Corporations are not clever ponies.

In general, corporations will do everything they can to make sure their immediate income is as high as they can get it, and they don't think particularly hard about the future.
One could say that's because of the revolving door nature of management, but I just think it's because people who go for those kinds of jobs are greedy and self-absorbed, and just aren't capable of forward thinking.
 

Kiltguy

Lurker extraordinaré
Jan 23, 2011
252
0
0
Loop Stricken said:
Corporations are not clever ponies.
That may be so... The fact remains that I have seen it done more than once, and with more than once franchise/brand.

I guess as a consumer the only thing one can do, one thing that will have an impact, is to simply stop consuming products from given company.
 

Aris Khandr

New member
Oct 6, 2010
2,353
0
0
Even if Derpy isn't in the background, she can't be taken away. People will still make fanart, they'll still mention her. Nothing will really change. If Hasbro has their knickers in a twist over the potential negative backlash, they'll do what they have to do to cover their bums. But the character will still continue to be loved by the fans who love her. They can't change that.
 

mParadox

Susurration
Sep 19, 2010
28,600
0
0
Country
Germany
First off, editing. That middle alignment is making my eyes hurt.

Secondly, while I'm not familiar with MLP and Hasbro in general, I do know that sometimes, regardless of the love a character may get, that said character is pulled off air. the character may clash with the over all story or maybe it esentially interfered with the direction the story was taking. Though, then again, as far as I'm aware, DH is like... a minor character no? So, the idea behind the letting go of that one... seems odd.

I mean, be glad it isn't literal killing off. Imagine the backlash then.
 

Angie7F

WiseGurl
Nov 11, 2011
1,704
0
0
Business often kills great stories. One Piece and Naruto was dragged out way too long.
More sponsors leads to more seasons. More seasons often destroys the original...