Poll: Did the music industry set-up Megaupload to be shut down?

Recommended Videos

Mediteral

New member
Apr 15, 2009
112
0
0
I've been looking into the whole MegaUpload thing, just out of curiosity really and I've come across some strange coincidence with the whole thing...

The US government says that Megaupload founder Kim Dotcom masterminded a vast file sharing conspiracy that swindled the entertainment industry out of millions by letting users illegally download movies and songs.

By putting Dotcom behind bars, the feds didn?t just end Megaupload though, once one of the most visited sites on the Web. By ending the operation, authorities have also pulled the plug on an endeavor that was scheduled to launch later this year that could have legitimately disrupted Hollywood by letting users download songs ? and rewarding the artists with compensation unheard of in the industry.

It was called Megabox. Basically, what it was going to do was allow users to legally download songs, some for free, while still allowing the artists to collect compensation. It was going to be a partnership between Megaupload execs and others in the online industry, including Amazon, to allow users to legally download songs, some for free, while still allowing the artists to collect compensation. It was going to be a partnership between Megaupload execs and others in the online industry, including Amazon... but it was also going to be a big thorn on the side of record labels.

In short, artists would only have to pay studios for recording, then they could upload their songs to Megabox and they would get about 90 percent of the profits from the sales. They would even get money if the gave away their songs for free. It essentially cuts the record labels completely out of the process.

Did Kim Dotcom break the law by operating Megaupload? Maybe yes and maybe no. But when those laws are made and enforced by people in the pockets of Hollywood, you can imagine that Washington isn?t exactly interested in hearing what Megaupload has to say in their defense. Even less likely, however, would be letting Dotcom finally put some money in the pockets of musicians.
 

Awexsome

Were it so easy
Mar 25, 2009
1,549
0
0
Mediteral said:
Did Kim Dotcom break the law by operating Megaupload?
The correct answer is yes. Or at least 99% likely to be yes. The only way it wasn't is if the accusers have forged bunches of emails and past records otherwise their evidence is damning.

http://www.scribd.com/doc/78786408/Mega-Indictment

On topic, quite the conspiracy theory you got there. Look I know Megaupload was convenient for a lot of people (legitimate uses or not) but can't people just accept at this point with the evidence that they were completely willfully and knowingly breaking the law here in many steps beyond, "just hosting some pirated content"? The only grey area in this whole thing is the jurisdiction argument but as for against the law it was clearly so.
 

Monkeyman O'Brien

New member
Jan 27, 2012
427
0
0
Kinda. But Megaupload just painted a giant target on themselves.
That stupid ass song bragging about how much traffic they get, then them bitchslapping Universal over Uni yanking their video off youtube, it was just a great big wavey red flag that got their dumb asses bull rushed.
Ultimately MU did nothing illegal but hey, what does that matter when you have multi billion dollar studios running the feds.