Poll: Do YOU think the 3DS/3D TVs/3D phones cause seizures?

Recommended Videos

BlueGlowstick

New member
Nov 18, 2010
224
0
0
My question for this is because I have seizures, and I'm getting a 3DS for X-Mas because mine is broken. I've had 4 in the past few weeks alone, and I've actually had one played my DS, so of course I'm scared to death of having one playing my new DS.

So: what do y'all think? My neurologists don't really care; so I turn to my fellow gamers.
 

Clive Howlitzer

New member
Jan 27, 2011
2,783
0
0
I don't know about seizures but they sure as hell give me a headache. I really hope the whole 3D gimmick goes away.
 
Jun 11, 2008
5,331
0
0
Well for a 3DS you can turn of the 3d effect if it does indeed cause seizures so on that end I don't see a problem. Also I do not know if does cause seizures only crappy effects.
 

Gladion

New member
Jan 19, 2009
1,470
0
0
BlueGlowstick said:
My neurologists don't really care;
I guess you should see others, then. It's highly unlikely you'll find experts on this topic answering to your question here...

I suppose they could cause seizures, but that's just because I personally get headaches from the things and they make me dizzy. I always look away from 3D-screens when it gets too hard to look at.
 

BlueGlowstick

New member
Nov 18, 2010
224
0
0
Gladion said:
BlueGlowstick said:
My neurologists don't really care;
I guess you should see others, then. It's highly unlikely you'll find experts on this topic answering to your question here...

I suppose they could cause seizures, but that's just because I personally get headaches from the things and they make me dizzy. I always look away from 3D-screens when it gets too hard to look at.
they didn't care about my going to strobe-light-filled concerts, so 3DS' are the same way. I have an appointment on the 19th with a new neurologist; hopefully he can find out what really causes my seizures.
 

Gladion

New member
Jan 19, 2009
1,470
0
0
BlueGlowstick said:
Gladion said:
BlueGlowstick said:
My neurologists don't really care;
I guess you should see others, then. It's highly unlikely you'll find experts on this topic answering to your question here...

I suppose they could cause seizures, but that's just because I personally get headaches from the things and they make me dizzy. I always look away from 3D-screens when it gets too hard to look at.
they didn't care about my going to strobe-light-filled concerts, so 3DS' are the same way. I have an appointment on the 19th with a new neurologist; hopefully he can find out what really causes my seizures.
Best of luck. I hope you'll be able to carefreely enjoy your 3DS ;)
 

geK0

New member
Jun 24, 2011
1,846
0
0
Well considering they have warning labels for normal games potentially causing seizures, I guess 3D games would as well.

More than normal games? maybe not
 

Vivi22

New member
Aug 22, 2010
2,300
0
0
Unless someone on here either knows of or has conducted research on this stuff to find out then anyone's opinion is fairly worthless.

That said, standard games and strobing lights can cause seizures in some people. I don't know if 3D would affect it and I doubt anyone else here does either, but have you tried not playing any games and seeing if your seizures either go away or are reduced in frequency?
 

Galite

New member
Sep 11, 2011
24
0
0
You do realize how bad of an idea it is to poll people about medical opinions right? If you are that worried about it use it without the 3D effect until your doctor can give you a definitive awnser.
 

jsolodar

New member
Jun 27, 2011
2
0
0
Most neurologists I've seen with my daughter (who has video game seizures) don't know a great deal about photosensitivity. They rely heavily on your EEG results, even though EEGs are far from reliable. Also, photic stimulation with a strobe light does not replicate the experience of playing a video game, so your response in the EEG lab doesn't necessarily predict how your brain will handle the conditions of playing an actual game. I'm going to guess that you were tested with the standard strobe light procedure (photic stimulation) and that the EEG didn't show any unusual response. Apparently only 3-5 percent of people with epilepsy test positive for photosensitivity. It's a genetic trait that is passed down separately from genes for "regular" epilepsy. Most people with epilepsy don't have a problem with visual provocation from video games and other flashing things--and some get offended when the rest of the world assumes that they do. They don't want to limit their everyday activities unnecessarily because of a risk that is no higher for them than for anyone else.

Researchers say that one way to prevent seizures while playing if you are in fact photosensitive is to keep one eye covered. You can wear a patch. Without both eyes supplying the brain's vision receptors with input that can be overstimulating, seizures won't happen.

If you want to read more about this subject, I've got a site, videogameseizures.org and a blog, videogameseizures.wordpress.com, where I have links to a lot of information. Best of luck.

Jessica Solodar
 

TheDooD

New member
Dec 23, 2010
812
0
0
BlueGlowstick said:
My question for this is because I have seizures, and I'm getting a 3DS for X-Mas because mine is broken. I've had 4 in the past few weeks alone, and I've actually had one played my DS, so of course I'm scared to death of having one playing my new DS.

So: what do y'all think? My neurologists don't really care; so I turn to my fellow gamers.
I'll say just try to avoid the cause as much as possible it's better safe then sorry. Overall 3D hasn't been proven safe for those that have such medical issues and in my opinion practical yet.