Out of the choices listed, I'm going with Silent Hill. I completely skipped over Homecoming. When I found out you play as a 'soldier' and therefore I he knew how to fight and could dodge and stuff, I knew they'd screwed the game up. Bought Downpour, and while it still doesn't measure up to 2 or 3, it was a step in the right direction. Zero Punctuation sums up my feelings on it.
I would like to throw out Fatal Frame as well. I have never played the games, but from what I understand they were very Japanese-style horror, not U.S. "Oh, let's make this a bloody, gory, and graphic as we can" horror.