Poll: Is GTA 4 longer than Red Dead Redemption?

[Denis Trailin]

I'm not that in into multi-player, so I was wondering which single-player will keep me entertained longer?
I'm not asking which one is longest but which one I will want to play longer.

 

[kurupt87]

Woops, voted before reading. Seriously, change the name of the poll to the question you actually mean dude. RDR has a shorter (I think) story than GTAIV, I also prefer the story and world of RDR to GTAIV.

 

[GundamSentinel]

I don't now whether or not the main story line is longer in Red Dead Redemption, but the side activities are certainly so much more interesting. Those alone will keep you playing for a very long time.

 

[Onyx Oblivion]

GTA 4 is much longer for at least the story, by a mile. And I think it has more things to do, personally. Red Dead doesn't have much to do but play cards and do a few of those random missions.

Plus, GTA is dirt cheap now.

 

[AMMO Kid]

I personally have tons more fun with RDR, but it's your call. Also GTA4 is longer but it does kind of over stretch the story in my opinion

 

[Amnestic]

I completed GTA4 first time through in less than 30 hours which gave me the achievement. Don't think I particularly rushed it, but I didn't spend a long time sandboxing

Dunno how long RDR lasts people though, not bought it (yet)

 

[GLo Jones]

I completed GTA, played some multiplayer, then got bored. It didn't take long.

While RDR may have a shorter main storyline, I've definitely found that it's taking up a lot more of my time, there's so much to do!

 

[Psychophante]

I just finished RDR, and I enjoyed it more than GTA IV, which just got boring after a while IMO.

 

[Omikron009]

I've finished GTA 4, but I'm not done RDR yet. I imagine it'll be longer for me, because I enjoy the diversions and odd things to do much more than the ones in GTA 4. Hunting and gang hideouts > going bowling with Roman.

 

[MiracleOfSound]

GTA4 is a lot longer.

RDR is a lot better.

 

[Carnagath]

I have no idea what everyone is talking about. It took me 45 hours to finish GTA 4's story while maintaining 100% like-status with all the characters and it took me 92 hours to finish RDR without even doing the challenges (about lvl 3-4 on all), treasure hunts or all the stranger quests. RDR lasted two times longer for me and I'm not really sandbox-happy.

 

[tiredinnuendo]

GTA4 sure as hell felt longer. Painfully so.

- J