Poll: Motion Commotion! Who has got it done right?

[Goombadude3]

Since the Wii introduced games controlled by mostly a motion controller. This past E3 introduced 360's attempt with Project Natal, which promises unparalleled gaming using nothing but your self to control many different games. Then later on in Sony's conference, we see Sony's swing at motion with the Playstation "Move". Its going more along the Wii route with the wand controller. While both Natal and The Move look very innovative and cool, will they work? Both brands demonstrated that there creations work with games, but the thing is that those games were designed to be only used with the respective controllers. We saw MILO, and thats all fine and good but would you really want to play HALO or MW2 with no controller? Sony has demonstrated the Move will work with SOCOM 4, but you have to purchase 2 of them. Both brands have demonstrated that they have the technology to make these work with games, but do we, the gamers, want to stand up to play games like MW2, or stay comfy in our couches. Or should we leave motion to the Wii?
Gamers...YOU DECIDE!
Are you going to buy into the new motion options for these consoles?
Are you going to stick with the Wii's motion?

 

[Delusibeta]

Where's the "none of the above" option?

The Wii executed motion controls very badly in my opinion, and I doubt either Natal or Move will be much better.

 

[Goombadude3]

Where's the "none of the above" option?

The Wii executed motion controls very badly in my opinion, and I doubt either Natal or Move will be much better.

Oops, forgot to add that.

 

[Goombadude3]

I added the option but its not putting it there when i push post.

 

[Gigaguy64]

Im sticking with the wii.
While there are bad examples of Motion Control on the Wii there are many good examples as well.
Metroid Prime Trilogy is a great example.
The controls were spot on and moved perfectly with my aiming.

Microsoft may have something going but, they still have a lot of work to do and as for Sony.....all they have is a Wii-mote with a light bulb on the end of it.
It works in almost the same way as a Wii-mote.

 

[soulasylum85]

there should be a motion control is horrible option