Poll: Red Thread Redemption

[Captain Pirate]

Ok, random general RDR discussion thread here.
What was your favorite moment in RDR campaign? Put in spoiler boxes if it's spoilerific.
What was your finest moment in multi or single player?
Are you looking forward to the Zombie DLC?
Favorite Gang Hideout?

1) Not completed yet, so can't say.
2) Me and three friends totally annihilating the law enforcement of a Mexican village and RPing taking it over.
3) YESYESYES
4) Gold Mine one, definately.

You guys' turn.

 

[Judgement101]

I hate multiplayer because of those people that constantly spawn kill. It erritates me like a bed full of biscut crumbs.

 

[Sronpop]

The single player was by far the best part of the game. I probably had the most fun just wandering around in the dessert, role playing, and hunting. The ambient challenges were the best. So much fun. The only annoying ones were the speicific animal hunting ones. Skinning deers = easy, skinning 5 skunks and 5 raccoons and 5 fucking armadillos or whatever = not so much. Finding them was such a ****, had to resort to online guides, other than that, no complaints really.

 

[JWRosser]

Single player was fun as soon as I completed it then I became bored. It wasn't like GTA where you could just go on a killing spree or crazy cop chase (though I didn't actually mind Jack).
Online annoyed me seeing as as soon as you spawn someone kills you. ALL I WANT TO DO IS RIDE MY HORSE AND DO THIS HIDE OUT SO I CAN LEVEL UP YOU PRICK. LET. ME. BE!

 

[EightGaugeHippo]

If multiplayer had trains. But it dosnt so single player.

Spoiler: absolute story ruining spoiler

Spoiler: no really, dont click unless you have finished it

The Real ending when Jack kills the agent guy, That was the only part I didnt like, I would prefere it if agent Ross(?)was completely helpless when he was killed, like John was.

 

[Thunderhorse31]

Single player, easily, for the great story/characters. Multi is fun for a while, but not for very long. Anyway:

1) The final, final mission. You're not there yet, so I won't give more detail.
2) Finest moment came in the final, final mission. Here I will be more specific.
After torturing Ross' wife and brother (wounding them, dragging them through the desert, throwing one in a river - chased by dynamite - and leaving another to be killed by coyotes, I come to Ross. We duel, I empty every last bullet from my LeMat into his face, and as soon as I do an achievement pops, saying "In a Hail of Bullets." It was unrelated to the story (earned for 500 pistol kills), but killing my nemesis with 9 headshots before getting that to pop felt pretty awesome.
3) Nope.
4) They're all too similar for me to have a favorite, but the one in the deserted town (leading up to the mansion full of baddies) stands out.

 

[Grayjack]

The single player. I only play multiplayer in private rooms.

 

[Les Awesome]

to avoid spoilers I'll just say
The Ending

 

[latenightapplepie]

1. The end. Or my first minutes in Mexico when this is playing:


2. I frequently kick a lot of arse in online multiplayer. Any of those moments will suffice.

3. Not sure. I'm hoping it doesn't get too silly.

4. Tumbleweed. Creepy ghost town is creepy. And somehow a cool place for a shootout.

 

[TimeLord]

Fallout 3 was a ridiculously awesome game for the reason that they didn't have to worry about shoehorning in a multiplayer feature!

Same idea goes for the Ratchet and Clank series (barring R&C2)

 

[Borntolose]

The singleplayer was fantastic, but the multiplayer got old fast(still have to grind to the top level for a trophy...)
1)The end was one of the best endings I have ever seen in a game.
2)Killing the last Buffalo in the great plains.
3)No, I don't really buy DLC.
4)The gold mine is also my favourite because it's the fastest to finish in Co-op.

 

[DeadlyYellow]

For the poll: Don't have the game, but rarely play multiplayer.

 

[GonzoGamer]

RDR was fun. I tried the Multiplayer a bit but it doesn?t work too well for me so I guess I liked the single player more.
What I liked most is that R* seems to have brought back the in-game rewards for doing stuff. I liked unlocking stat changing outfits and new guns.
I don?t know about the zombie dlc. I hope it?s worth it but I have yet to see a R* DLC pack that?s worth the price they ask.
My favorite part of the game: trying to help some broad who (as it turned out) was trying to ambush me. I killed all her friends then tied her to the railroad tracks while wearing a top hat. The only thing missing was a twirly mustache.

 

[Jasper Jeffs]

1. I've hardly played the single player, I forgot how far I am into it, but I've only got 75GS and some of that comes from multiplayer, so that says something.

2. I don't have any memorable moments because I don't play it very often, the only time that sticks out is watching my brother play, him and his friend got chased by about 15 bears and they tried to kill them all with their fists, was quite hilarious to watch.

3. Depends what it changes, but I doubt I'll buy it anyway. I don't really like DLC.

4. I don't remember any. :3

 

[PissOffRoth]

I liked multiplayer, but I LOVED the single player story. Just way too epic for me to handle. Thank you Rockstar.

As for the poll:
1.

Spoiler: If you haven't finished the game, DO NOT OPEN THIS!

Watching John get riddled with bullets just tugged all of my heartstrings. I died a little inside when that happened. I was like the end of 1984. A big "WTF?!?!?!?!" depressing ending that makes a profound statement. The West died with Mr. Marston, it truly did.

2. Having snap-shooting battles with snipers. So great.
3. I don't like the idea. Might be fun, but anything that changes the single player is BAD! BAD BAD BAD!
4. I love assaulting Fort Mercer. Plus you get the LeMat revolver there in multi player, so that's an added bonus.

 

[Quaxar]

First off, this is my favourite game. I love it to death.
Single player of course, making a proper multiplayer for this kind of game is hard. Only thing that annoys me are some of the online trophies. Consecutive wins? Aw, I dont wanna!
Sadly you need them for 100% trophies.

1 Like everyone else I'll have to go for the campaign end as favourite moment.

Spoiler

It was tragic, but so well done I cried a little at the grave scene when the music came up. I never had that much immersion with any other game I can remember.
And after John getting shot I switched to revenge-mode, rushed through the quest and filled that fucker with bullets until I nearly ran out.

2 Maybe the Friends in high places trophy. It was great fun luring marshals into Armadillo and then killing them by the dozens from the saloon's roof.
3 Don't know. I'm going with "wait and look".
4 Fort Mercer. I love Ford Mercer. And it's even more fun in multiplayer due to more enemies, worse equipment and the fear of player snipers.

 

[Goldeneye103X2]

1.The end ending. The proper ending. It's like an Alexandre Dumas novel. Especially when jack turns away and then the screen turns red and says "Red Dead Redemption" next to him. Bad-Ass.
2.Any moment with a gatling gun kicks ass, but raiding towns with friends in multi is really fun.
3.The idea of shooting zombies with a winchester and double-barelled shotgun excites me, sure, but if it gets deleiberately ridiculous, then I might leave it.
4.Tumbleweed's big, but Tezoro Azul is just endless and awesome, especially when they start throwing fire bottles in. Its like a meteorite shower.

 

[LogicNProportion]

The multiplayer was a monumental pit of shame and disappointment for me.

I was looking forward to forming a permanent gang, trolling around. =[

The single player was awesome, however.