Ok i have played over 100 mmo's, free and p2p and private and very small ones alike, and i still do (currently im in 2moons) So far all mmorpgs have problems... atm 2moons is that too many hackers and no control over them (so far) I just got out of Battle of the Immortals which looked promising, a diablo clone of a mmo... but oh my god.. the quests, every level the quests, the npc's and the zones.. i dont like teleporting zones. Went from a desert hunting scorpions to underwater fighting crabs? and PETS! i hate pets. games always endorse having pets now.. and hundreds of mounts, so everyone is glowy and has a pet and a mount and it looks like crap. Each town had hundreds of npc's, each npc had a list of options, for every mini quest and event and item type, the game probably had 4 types of currencies and 6 quest/event currencies to complete for tokens to turn in for items or points to get other items and pets.. they just didnt know when to stop stuffing it with content, i remember when a town had 10 NPC's max, a couple shops, couple skill trainers, couple usual quest guys, done. BoI lined the streets with NPC's like a private WoW server would.
If anyone is looking for a mmo to try just pm me, i've been all over the internet trying them, little and big ones new and old, i might know something somewhere to suit you.