Depends, you in it for the long term or the short. Forget pros and cons and just think," do I see myself with this girl down the line." I'm not spouting the old,"listen to your heart," BS that's been shoved at us since we were 6, I'm saying which one would you get more of an experience. Personally, I see romantic relationships more as a really long term intimate friendship. So choose the one you'd likely get along with, or fight with if you believe opposites attract.