BabyfartsMcgeezaks said:
You could easily say the same for Red Dead Redemption 1 on PC, and yet here we are.
I can see a couple of reasons why it didn't release on PC, plenty of game developers always had a negative view on PC as their games do not usually sell nearly as much on PC compared to consoles, so why spend a lot of money and time on optimizing a game for PC? Not to mention that more developers/publishers back then thought pirating was a big issue. One last thing could be that the horrendous port of GTAIV left a bad taste in PC gamers mouth and left Rockstar skeptical to port another open-world game to PC so shortly after.[/quote]
Don't forget that RDR was released at the height of the "PC Games are dying!"-era. Back in 2010 it was not a clear cut decision to port to PC if you released a console game, and it was not until 2015 or so that it became obvious that the current console generation was not selling as well as projected. But other then that, all your points are real solid and probably contributed to Rockstars decision not to port.