Rock Band

Recommended Videos

Protag

New member
Jul 1, 2008
20
0
0
Rock Band

Reviewed by Protag

You're stood on a stage, with a guitar hung across your stomach. The crowd stretches on for miles, a pulsing, throbbing mass of bodies, all focused on you. They chant your name. You turn up the volume and step up to the microphone, the drumbeat kicks in and the crowd goes wild. You're a rockstar.

Or, at least, you can pretend to be.

Enter Harmonix Music System's seminal Rock Band. The answer to one of humanity's most primal needs, to be somebody. And now you can, while simultaneously slamming deep fried cakes into your face. Rock Band is the overweight under achievers wet dream, a way to imagine your cool, even if you have about as much charisma as one of Enya's gallstones.
Despite the inevitable hesitation you will feel, you will end up playing Rock Band at some point, and despite its faults its actually very good fun. It is a basic, cardinal premise, and one that should have been thought of years ago.

I bought the full version that includes all the 'instruments' - Drum Kit, Guitar and Microphone. Lets get one thing straight, no one will buy this version to play the guitar or use the microphone. The Drum Kit is the main source of underlying curiosity, and its surprisingly easy to set up, making jumping straight into the game a simple procedure. Once you get there, you have to set upon creating your virtual band.

First you have to choose a band name. I originally went for something subtle and unenterprising, but eventually settled on 'The Cornhole Explosions'.

Next you have to 'Create your Rocker'. I created a tye-dyed midget, something that looked like a cross between Orville and Alan Titchmarsh. Then I had to name it. I threw around a few names, such as 'Axel' and 'Rocky' before settling on 'Mr.Piss'.
Once the drummer was sorted, I had to create the rest of the band. This was the line up:

Drums - Mr. Piss
Guitar - Zombie Hendrix
Bass Guitar - Bruce Campbell

The vocalist I thought should be female, so I dont come across as a chauvinistic sexist pig. I like her. I called her 'Tits'.

Now that my band was complete, I was ready to embark on an epic adventure into the lifestyle of a rockstar. But one thing stood in my way - my complete inability to convince my arms and legs to work together. During the first few songs I resembled an octopus suffering from Parkinsons disease, flailing wildly in the hopes of hitting the right pads to correspond with the colours on the screen. This remained a problem throughout my experience with the game, and despite my talent for drumming on tables and bars in real life, I still had trouble hitting sticks against badly made plastic plates.
As infuriating as it was, it still remained blissfully entertaining throughout. There is a killer track list to make irritang click-clack noises to, including the likes of Metallica, Muse and the Foo Fighters. It even has a Freezepop song up for download, and also the song from the end credits of Portal.
It seemed like a pretty good deal.

Then I realised that I couldnt quite settle into it. Not because I was shit, or because the calibration was out, or because the dog had suddenly started barking and subsequently been greeted with my size ten up its arse. It was because I was painfully aware of what I looked like while playing it. In layman's terms, a twat. Even if you are sure your alone in the house and your curtains are drawn shut, you cant quite shake the feeling off that someone, somewhere, is watching you.

So, Is it Shit?

In the context of single player, yes. Multiplayer? Hell no.

There is nothing more tragic than sitting in your room, straddled over a drum-chair made of anything drum-chair-sized around you, pretending to be part of a band that doesnt exist, pretending to be cooler than you could ever hope to be. But the simple fact remains that if you get a few friends around, slam a few beers back, crank up the volume and let rip, you could no doubt be in heaven.
Rock Band could be the perfect solution to those family barbeque situations, where the 'oldies' want to break out the karaoke machine. Now the younger generations have something better than fucking Buzz! to save our souls.

Thank you Harmonix.
 

Larenxis

New member
Dec 13, 2007
1,648
0
0
I find your reviews rather crude and harsh, perhaps you should bring down the swearing just a notch.

I, of course, love Rock Band, but I can't even imagine playing it alone.
 

Nickolai

New member
Feb 22, 2008
72
0
0
Sorry mate, but I just can't agree with you, and not because I reviewed Rock Band first. No offense is meant by this, just trying to get that out of the way now.

I found it lacking in critical areas, such as the other instruments, online play, and what it's faults are. You mentioned it had several faults. All I read was the difficulty with the drums, and the feeling that you looked like an idiot while playing it. Did you find any other problems besides the drums? I know the drums are a huge innovation. Hell, the first solo career path I did was Medium Drums.

What about the new guitar? How about any problems with Xbox Live? Any improvements that could be made. What about saying what makes this game fun to play? Is it the music, the thrill of pretending to actually be on stage with Avenged Sevenfold, hearing the roar of the crowd, begging for just one more? Is it playing with 1,2 or 3 other people, coordinating efforts and doing your best not to mess up what's the best?

To be honest, this read more like a walkthrough or FAQ rather then a full-fledged review. I'd even go so far as to say that it's basically a blog entry of your experience with the game over a couple weeks. Sorry, but I really don't like this review.

As for the game, I agree that multiplayer is worlds better then single player. Although Xbox Live seems to have been lagging as of late. Maybe it's just me, but it's pretty bad IMO.
 

SeaCalMaster

New member
Jun 2, 2008
464
0
0
Ah, I love reviewing reviews.

First of all, the grammar. Oh dear God, deliver me from evil.
Second, you made the comment that Rock Band is something that "should have been thought of years ago." However, all the component parts of the game existed long before Rock Band hit the shelves. There have been separate games for the guitar part, drums part, and vocal part for many years, and they all had the simulated stardom aspect. The only thing Rock Band did was to bring them all together.
Third, the review felt rather sparse. You spent most of it talking about how you got it, how you set it up, how you created your band, etc. You should have spent more time talking about the actual game, i.e. did you like the songs, did the controllers work well, is it fun, is the career mode any good. The only thing you actually addressed was how you looked while playing the game, which implies (to me at least) that you're extremely self-conscious and will probably take this post rather harshly. You shouldn't, as I'm only trying to be helpful, but you will anyway.

P.S. Stop trying to be Yahtzee. Your attempt is not coming across well, and even if it were, you would still be "cramping his style."
 

SeaCalMaster

New member
Jun 2, 2008
464
0
0
TheNecroswanson said:
Edit: hey, Seacal, people have been using vulgarity and humor for years. Mr. Croshaw didn't invent it.
I know, but this particular post is extremely reminiscent of his style.
 

Crazyshrink

New member
Dec 29, 2007
40
0
0
Any time Bruce Campbell and Jimi Hendrix are in a conversation, I like it.
And how come no one really talks about the singing? For my first rock band we got the best singer from the school choir and she failed three times but i did a bob dylan impression and had a 87%
 

Protag

New member
Jul 1, 2008
20
0
0
I thought i made it clear that i bought it for the drums, therefore, i only reviewed the drums.

Im not trying to be yahtzee, im just trying to get my point across in a vulgar and belittling way to the reader, whats wrong with that? You all act as if Ben invented swearing. Besides, my reviews arent really proper reviews, they are more like opinions on aspects of things. Whenever i come across as not reviewing every aspect is usually because it was late and i couldnt be arsed.

P.S like i said, im new to the reviewing thing, and i just want some pointers on the first couple of reviews. So your saying more content, more detail right? I'll try to improve when i review Alone In The Dark.
 

mjhhiv

New member
Jun 22, 2008
758
0
0
"The vocalist I thought should be female, so I dont come across as a chauvinistic sexist pig. I like her. I called her 'Tits'."

I could have sworn I'd heard Yahtzee say that before. Honestly, I liked your review because it was a lot like Yahtzee's reviews. It was funny and entertaining (IMO, I'm sure not everyone likes this sort of humor), and if you could add detail and content, you'd be pretty good. Detail and content are the two biggest parts of reviewing, however.
 

Protag

New member
Jul 1, 2008
20
0
0
Thanks man, i did actually call her tits you know, probably because im juvenile.

Im here mainly for advice, and i hope to improve my game as time goes on.
 

Melaisis

New member
Dec 9, 2007
1,014
0
0
In the context of single player, yes. Multiplayer? Hell no.
Huge kudos for this: You seem to have hit the nail on the head where other reviewers simply beat around the bush, which usually consists of: 'Er... well it was like Guitar Hero... but better if you play together...'