Sympathy for the Devil's Advocate: My Time Following the #GamerGate Movement [Part One]

Recommended Videos

Attison Graves

New member
Sep 11, 2014
7
0
0
Hey, there, fellow Escapists! I'm a long-time lurker and a big fan of the site.

I recently decided that I wanted to challenge myself to write something meaningful. I've spent so much time over the last couple of years starting and dropping stories that I never came back to, that I was beginning to feel like it was just wasting my time. Not willing to just 'quit writing', I decided that I wanted to try my hand at writing something with a little depth and importance.

As a gamer, of course, it's hard to overlook the internet's biggest ongoing issue in the gaming world.

And so, with every intention to try to remain neutral and understanding, I decided that I was going to sit down and finally give the whole #GamerGate thing a really hard look. Of course, I'm not neutral. I'm a frustrated, irritable, oftentimes self-important jerk. It also didn't help that I'm very much opposed to the movement of enforced political correctness, which seems to have taken root at the very heart of the matter for those demanding social progress.

If I can't be a voice of neutrality, however, then at least I'll be a voice of moderation.


"Sympathy for the Devil's Advocate: My Time Following the #GamerGate Movement Thus Far" [Part One]


Before I begin, allow me to offer a little background on myself. I'm a mediocre musician. I'm a gamer. I'm an unpublished author with aspirations far beyond my limited talent, but I don't let that stop me from trying anyway. I fancy myself to be a funny guy, but I fear I've got at least a little of my father's awful sense of humor hidden away inside me somewhere. Above all else, though? I'm a very firm believer in the idea of human rights, civil rights, equal rights, and freedom for all.

Here are a couple less-important facts. I'm terrified of speaking in public, I suffer from severe anxiety, and I've been clinically depressed since about the sixth grade. I'm also a straight white man in his late twenties. When people tell me my Irish heritage doesn't 'qualify' as an oppressed minority and therefore my thoughts and opinions don't matter, I have to remind myself that punching them in the face doesn't make my position any more right. I have some anger management issues, too. It might be because I've got so much Irish in me.

But I digress. The first part of this would-be article is going to focus a little on me. Before I get too far into my thoughts and ideas on the GamerGate movement, I feel that it's important for people to understand the place that I come from and why I believe what it is that I do. So many editorials and one-off articles have come out of this thing without any context as to who is writing them, that it's easy for people on both sides to forget that there are actual humans involved. Actual humans with actual feelings, something I myself sometimes forget. So without further ado, allow me to introduce myself.

I am Attison Graves. That's not my real name, mind you, it's a character. Among my many other 'flaws', I'm an avid roleplayer and a lover of all things game. This year saw me going to my first-ever Board Game Night, where I horribly lost my first game of Settlers and won my first game of Timeline. My friends and family all know me as the 'loser son who never grew up and got out of his parents' house'. Yes, that's right, I am literally the stereotypical nerd living in his mother's basement. Only in my case, I live upstairs. With my girlfriend.

For as long as I can remember, I've loved... love. I've made it my life's mission to build bridges and spread tolerance and understanding wherever I may go. I don't get out much, thanks to the anxiety, but with the help of gaming I have been able to share my values and beliefs and make a lot of friends along the way and we all have pretty similar views on the need for equality and diversity in games. Nothing makes me happier than to see women making games, playing games, and critiquing games. Nothing makes me happier than to see my fellow "gamers" embracing people of all colors, creeds, genders, and sexualities. That's not to say that there isn't an extremely crass, extremely bigoted subset of individuals who attack any attempt to branch out beyond their demographic, but I can honestly say that I have never seen or been supplied with any evidence to suggest that this is "The Norm".

Of my three oldest childhood friends, one confided in me at a very young age that she was a lesbian. The other turned out to be a libertarian, and the other a complete sociopath... so that might be why I have such a strange worldview these days. I don't know. What I do know is, I've always firmly believed that it was important to treat people like people. Nobody deserves to be mocked or ridiculed for things beyond their control. Do something awful intentionally, and I'll gladly tell you exactly what I think of you, but I'll never judge you for being a gay/bi-sexual/pansexual black/asian/hispanic/eldritch horror of either gender. In fact, unless you take offense to my being on your side, I will happily stand next to you and shout down anyone who thinks that it's OKAY to be bigoted and cruel.

This whole kerfuffle strikes a chord near and dear to me, and I certainly have my own personal biases in the matter, but even more than that I find it absolutely fascinating. As someone with a deep unabashed love for philosophy, history, and psychology... the idea of engaging with a social movement built up around the hobby and community I have always believed myself to be a part of is terrifically exciting.

So, now that I've got my motives and personal background out of the way, Part Two will get into the nitty-gritty details of what I saw on my first day of staring at Twitter for 16 hours. In the meanwhile, I want to thank anyone who bothered to read this far down. If you have thoughts or opinions on the movement or my godawful writing, I hope that you'll share them civilly.

Regardless of where you stand, above all else: be excellent to one another.
 

Thaluikhain

Elite Member
Legacy
Jan 16, 2010
19,538
4,128
118
Huh...ok, was you to put something about Gamergate in your thread about Gamergate.

Can I ask why you felt it was important to instead talk about yourself? Because, IMHO, starting off like this isn't really a good sign. Sure, it'd be great if this did turn out to be insightful and illuminated, but I'm not going to be surprised if it doesn't.
 

jademunky

New member
Mar 6, 2012
973
0
0
Good to meet you Attison. I appreciate that you put yourself and your background up there, best of luck with your writing aspirations.

I'm pretty firmly in the anti-gg camp myself, they would have to back off their anti-feminist stance for me to take them and their goals seriously. Anyway, cant wait to read your opinions on it.
 

Attison Graves

New member
Sep 11, 2014
7
0
0
No intro necessary, I've blathered on about myself long enough in my first post.


Sympathy for the Devil's Advocate: My Time Following the #GamerGate Movement Thus Far" [Part Two]

Part two of this 'article' will focus on my first day watching and observing the GamerGate hashtag.

My first glimpse of the GamerGate movement didn't come from 4Chan or the Sideways8infinitychan thing, because as a general rule I've always been a bit leery of getting involved in places like that. They have their own vernacular and culture, and it can be difficult to get in close enough to really see through some of the unseemly awfulness crusted around the outside to the nougaty center. Reddit also once tried to steal my soul, so my time reading things there was very limited and I never really got to see much of it before it was shut down. Much of what I saw was not pretty. Some of it was downright bone-chilling. I abhor and condemn the harassment and abuse of anyone, and there was some very real harassment and filth coming out of the amorphous cloud defending 'gamers' against those who would challenge them and their identities. I don't have names, and if I did I wouldn't give them out anyway, but there's no denying what was seen by all the media as a seething mass of hatred directed at a woman who dared speak up against the status quo actually happened.

Sexism, racism, and discrimination of all kinds exists across every spectrum of our civilization. That includes gamers. Is it the majority? I've not seen that to be the case, but it is very definitely a vocal and unashamed group within the community. And after spending some time watching and speaking with individuals who have associated themselves with the #GamerGate movement, I find myself sincerely believing that this is a mutual enemy we all share. Perhaps there are some numbers out there we can use to assess just how big the problem is, but I don't have them and I don't really even know where to start. I'll leave that up to an actual journalist.

I use the hashtag specifically in my writing, because the entirety of my experience with the movement comes from interacting with those who participate in it on Twitter. I'm not a very avid Twitter-er-er myself, but I put aside my fear of the alien social media client in order to take some time to watch and see what these folks were saying. There's so many articles and internet-users talking about how GamerGate is just a hate group, or a sexist campaign whose only goal is to silence women in gaming, that I couldn't help but feel that surely there must be more to it than that. I've played EVE Online, so believe me when I say that I'm sure it's POSSIBLE that there's such at thing as a tens-of-thousands strong army of trolls lurking out there in the depths of cyberspace... but how likely is it that there's absolutely nothing more than that to what's going on?

Instead of relying on the silence of the media following their rather blatant hit-pieces, I chose to step up and do what should have been done from the very beginning and investigate. It may be because I'm an insomniac, and sitting awake at 2:30 in the morning gives rise to the investigative reporter in me, but I found myself staring at an endless stream of tweets all bearing the GamerGate hashtag for something like sixteen straight hours. In that time, I observed people sharing thousands upon thousands of messages of hope and support and very sincere demands for answers from the people claiming to be informed members of the gaming press about how things could have gotten this bad. In that sixteen hour stretch, I saw three instances of very blatant trolling in the name of #GamerGate, each one quickly shot down and condemned by others who clearly understand that they are currently fighting an information war. Another common tweet you'll see is a reminder to not 'touch the poop', encouraging supporters of the GamerGate movement to avoid stepping into the fecal trap of trolls looking to bait them into loaded conversations and arguments which might reflect poorly on the group as a whole.

Because Twitter is such an open platform, it's very difficult to prevent widespread trolling, but I've seen a very concerted effort by repeat-tweeters to do precisely that. On the other hand, there seems to be very little attempt by anyone to prevent the abuse being directed at them. Death threats, suggestions to go 'kill themselves', hateful comments towards women and other self-identified minority gamers for 'not towing the line' are everywhere. And then, of course, there's the extremely hyperbolic comparisons of those who participate in the movement to terrorists. I've no doubt that this is because, currently, many of the people who would be attempting to address the issue are in fact the very same voices who are presently being actively boycotted and cried foul upon by the GamerGate crowd. (I might add that I have not changed my reading habits at all, and that I believe wholeheartedly that the only way to understand a problem is to examine it from every solution. Not shutting out possible avenues)

The problem is that these trolls don't ascribe to one 'side' or the other. They play them off against one another because as long as everyone is fighting and bickering and making blind accusations about what 'everyone on the other side' is doing... nobody is talking about the actual issues. And as far as I'm concerned, the deepest issue ought to be a community-wide "How can we make this hobby we all love better for everyone involved?"

By the end of the first day, I'd made my first 'tweet' since the month I made my account. Why? I read this article:

http://chobituary.blogspot.com/2014/10/amnesia.html

Aside from being an important glimpse into the mind of a female gamer supporting the movement, it was a fascinating read into the mind of a person who shared a very similar trouble I've had with the 'equality and diversity in gaming' line. It feels so very... disingenuous... when I keep seeing the people supposedly being 'oppressed and marginalized' claiming that they're being attacked if they don't agree with the way their 'equality' is being pushed. When I see things like "Sure, there will always be women stupid enough to buy into GamerGate" it diminishes my capacity to believe that the individual saying this actually believes in their own cause.

Again, it's frustrating that I have to state that I'm definitely not trying implying every person calling themselves a feminist is just 'pretending' or else I'll face down a deluge of people whom I largely AGREE with screaming that I'm a sexist or a bigot. I've been down that road far too many times. But when you raise respectful, legitimate concerns with the way certain individuals behave and get descended upon by a group of fanatics willing to harass and belittle and threaten to ruin your life... it behooves me to point out that this is what we need to do away with if we're ever going to get to the point of bringing both sides together for civil discourse.

On the GamerGate side of things, the constant hostility has turned many within the movement into cynics and isolationists. There are many who fall into the very same trap they've accused journalists of, the comfort of insularity. These types will refuse to speak with and communicate with anyone who disagrees with them, and those who behave in even the least suspicious of ways are often met with accusations of 'subversive intent' or 'being a shill'. They even fight amongst themselves, often seeing treachery in those who take a less-aggressive or moderate stance. While thankfully I've managed to avoid most of this during my initial interactions, I've no doubt that my opinions and ideas may well run me afoul of the most intense members of the movement. My willingness to converse with the 'enemy', for instance, will no doubt limit how far beneath the veil I can get.

As I prepare to take a break from all this thinking and typing (so I can go back to playing some Mount & Blade and cook up some pizza), I'd like to ask anyone reading this who wants to share their thoughts and opinions with me to feel free to do so. I see a few of you have already replied, and that's awesome. Don't be afraid to get in-depth with me and tell me exactly where you stand. Even if I think you're wrong, I respect everyone and their opinion... and at the end of the day what this all boils down to is respect.

In Part 3 I'll talk a bit more about some of the things I've read and people I've talked to, as well as my thoughts on watching The Escapist's Greg Tito talking with TotalBiscuit, Erik Kain, et al in what was a very excellent move towards breaking the silence and trying to build some bridges and find middle ground. Major props to Greg.