Taking a "Break"

Recommended Videos

funkyjiveturkey

New member
Jan 18, 2013
97
0
0
so me and my gf have been together for a while, 18 months this friday actually, and we've been close friends for years before. a few months ago she moved to Toronto for college (i live in an adjacent town an hour away), we both have our licenses but no cars so we rarely get to see each other, maybe once every week or 2. for the past 2 months we've been trying to talk to as much as we can over phone, skype, etc.

Finally last week she breaks it to me that she just wants to go back to being good friends for a while because she can't handle being in a long distance relationship right now on top of school. she feels that we never get to see each other, and that there's some expectation that we always have to make each other feel better. she feels that if we stay together and things keep going the way they are, we're going to break up. my fear is, taking a break like this, talking less, and abandoning the whole idea WILL make us break up and make things worse.

after our talk i had gone to her dorm to visit her for halloween. we talked it over and i thought shit was worked out. we had basically reached the conclusion that we dont need a break. we hung out, did things together, even ended up having sex. two days after i had gone home i skyped with her and she broke into tears saying she cant keep doing this and that she NEEEDS this break. i told her i need a few days to let all of this sink in and think it over. we talked on sunday, im probably going to talk to her tomorrow about this. she's explained all of this a million times to me but i still cant understand it, especially because she doesnt even know what she needs and keeps flip-flopping what she says.

it got so bad with her flipping her position i didnt speak to her for 3 days because i couldnt take all the mixed signals. finally we skyped a few nights ago. she seems cheery and eager to talk to me, giving me the goo-goo constantly throughout the conversation and even saying she still adores me, but still saying she doesnt know what she needs. after a whole conversation of talking as "just friends" i feel more confused than ever. today in particular i feel especially like shit because today would've been 18 months together (literally not an anniversary by any stretch of the word, but i was still going to mail her a present which is just sitting my closet gathering dust now)

thing is, the conditions of the break are basically that we dont do anything physical, or even really relationship oriented, but we are still loyal to each other and we still hang out. we arent on bad terms, she's just very stressed and doesnt know what she needs, and this really worries me. in a month shes coming home for holidays and we'll get to spend all of december together, but i dont know where we will be by then. she swears this isn't a break up and that she still loves me but at the same time shes saying she cant be with me right now.

i'm hurting real bad, escapists. what do i do?
 

EeveeElectro

Cats.
Aug 3, 2008
7,055
0
0
To me, it sounds like because she's young, and now a college student she wants the freedom being a student entails.
She possibly wants to go out a lot, drink, get chatted up by men, explore her sexuality a bit more and experiment before it's time to settle down.
It's a massive social pressure on students to 'fit in'. Maybe all her buddies are single and she feels the odd one out having to be loyal? It could be any reason, although it does sound like she's not interested in a proper relationship.

Obviously it's not everyone, but the stigma is that student life and early adult life is supposed to be fun-loving and care free.
Some people can handle long distance and long-term relationships but some people can't. That's fine, wanting different things isn't a bad thing but you getting strung along certainly is.

On the other hand, she sounds like she's accustomed to you by now, loves you, finds comfort in having you around and is struggling to break up properly.

When you're not on bad terms with someone, but you want to go your separate ways, it is hard to end it.

It sounds a little bit like she wants you there for back-up, someone to fall back on when she's lonely but I could just be cynical.

I'd personally finish it, playing with your emotions like this is unfair and she she doesn't seem mature enough to be able to handle a long distance relationship.
Maybe then she'll realise how important you are and that's your choice if you think it's worth working at.
 

Vegosiux

New member
May 18, 2011
4,381
0
0
Seems to me like she's not sure what she actually wants. Stuff like that happens; part of life. I'd suggest just go with a scaled-down friendship thing, and whatever happens, happens. If along the way you decide that you do not wish to continue with her, then you talk to her and tell her so.

And, excuse my patronization, but a relationship ending at that age is no big deal in the grand scale. Yes, it sucks for a while, but eventually the pieces align again and you go on.

But one bit of information is a bit absent from your OP; which is - what do you want? This is as much a part of your life as it is of hers.
 

Jux

Hmm
Sep 2, 2012
868
4
23
If she says she needs a break, that is a pretty clear message. Give her whatever space she needs. That being said, don't put your life on hold for her. I made that mistake and wasted years. I don't really understand the concept of 'needing a break but not breaking up' thing. Can someone clarrify what this means relationship wise for me? It really sounds like a precursor to a fadeaway breakup. Kind of wishy washy, don't-want-to-hurt-your-feelings BS.
 

TheCallawayKid

New member
Aug 18, 2013
8
0
0
A break is her not being able to tell you that she wants to break up, sorry man I know it sucks but that's the heavy truth. I agree with Jux, don't pine for her, I've done it too and it'll just break your heart further.