I love Dragon Age Inquisition, let's start there. I feel like any of the sins of DA2 is forgiven utterly and Bioware is back on the right track(Note: DO NOT DISCUSS THIS, THIS IS NOT THE ISSUE AT HAND). There were, however, a few things I had issues with and the most silly one by far is the revelation during the Solas romance about the vallaslin, the elven facial tattoos. Solas reveals to the protagonist that what they thought were markings to honor the gods were in truth slave markings, marks of ownership that slave owners put on their slaves to honor the gods, but the honor was theirs, not the slave's. It's "yet another thing that dalish got wrong" as Your Character might say, which in my case at least made my girl utterly heartbroken.
Now, his explanation of how it was makes sense, but as someone who's done a lot of cultural studies that REALLY RUBBED ME THE WRONG WAY. It's silly, but I couldn't let that one pass, at all. Why? Because IT DOES NOT WORK LIKE THAT. No matter what it was back then, that doesn't define what it is now. Cultures are arbitrary constructions, with values ascribed, not inherent. If the Dalish are using it to honor the gods, then that's what it is, no matter what it was thousands of years ago. Why? Because they say it is. For instance the word "Gay", which means "homosexual" now, but once meant "cheerful". Is anyone seriously going to claim that people are actually saying "the rights of cheerful" when they use the term "gay rights"? No, because that'd be bloody stupid. So what we have here is Solas dragging up some archaic meaning of what my character held dear in order to give her feeling of self worth a big, fat kick. Well meaning, maybe, but nevertheless idiotic.
Now... this gripe of mine is SILLY, also with the dalish being so much for "reclaiming" their past I suppose an argument could be made for it being different, but I don't buy into that. So, dear fellow escapists, what silly or irrelevant titbits in this or that game has rubbed you the wrong way to a disproportionate degree? Not legitimate concerns, but little bits that made you think "yeah I'm probably being stupid but gah!"
Now, his explanation of how it was makes sense, but as someone who's done a lot of cultural studies that REALLY RUBBED ME THE WRONG WAY. It's silly, but I couldn't let that one pass, at all. Why? Because IT DOES NOT WORK LIKE THAT. No matter what it was back then, that doesn't define what it is now. Cultures are arbitrary constructions, with values ascribed, not inherent. If the Dalish are using it to honor the gods, then that's what it is, no matter what it was thousands of years ago. Why? Because they say it is. For instance the word "Gay", which means "homosexual" now, but once meant "cheerful". Is anyone seriously going to claim that people are actually saying "the rights of cheerful" when they use the term "gay rights"? No, because that'd be bloody stupid. So what we have here is Solas dragging up some archaic meaning of what my character held dear in order to give her feeling of self worth a big, fat kick. Well meaning, maybe, but nevertheless idiotic.
Now... this gripe of mine is SILLY, also with the dalish being so much for "reclaiming" their past I suppose an argument could be made for it being different, but I don't buy into that. So, dear fellow escapists, what silly or irrelevant titbits in this or that game has rubbed you the wrong way to a disproportionate degree? Not legitimate concerns, but little bits that made you think "yeah I'm probably being stupid but gah!"