That one guy who keeps questioning everything

[Jafe_45]

Have you ever gotten a new game and you have one person who knows it and tries to help everyone on their way, but then this one guy reads the whole instruction manual or whatever and starts to question every little thing that the guy leading the game and who's trying to help the others (by secretly cheating because everyone else sucks) does?

 

[Dr Pussymagnet]

No, it's probably just you.

 

[DeadlyYellow]

No, it's probably just you.

I agree with this guy.

Either just stop telling him you've got a new game, or stay off the internet.

 

[Phlakes]

...That's an oddly specific problem. And no, it's never happened to me.

 

[Pyro Paul]

that question is just all over the place and makes no sense...

are you asking about people that just blindly question regardless?
or are you asking about the "know" vrs. "experience" conflict?

 

[OliverTwist72]

"Hey if you just go and talk to that guy now you can..."

*fist in face*

Problem solved.

 

[Grouchy Imp_v1legacy]

There's always someone willing to endlessly question everything. What you have to ask yourself is: What good does it do?

 

[Sarah Frazier]

Have you ever gotten a new game and you have one person who knows it and tries to help everyone on their way, but then this one guy reads the whole instruction manual or whatever and starts to question every little thing that the guy leading the game and who's trying to help the others (by secretly cheating because everyone else sucks) does?

Kind of? When I played Dark Heresy for the first time, the one guy who actually 'knew' the system did everything he could to cheat the heck out of it and still convince the GM, who was also learning the system, that it was legal. He wasn't asking questions, just arbitrarily saying how abilities stacked in a way to let him do everything he wanted before anybody else stood a chance at trying. Only after everybody worked together to read all the subtexts did the group learn he'd been lieing, but by then nobody wanted to play.

 

[Nudu]

No, it's probably just you.

What this guy said.

 

[The_root_of_all_evil]

... and starts to question every little thing ...

Have you ever gotten a new game? Yes

You ever have one person who knows it and tries to help everyone on their way? Yes

Ever have one guy read the whole instruction manual and start to question every little thing that the guy leading the game and who's trying to help the others (by secretly cheating because everyone else sucks) does?

No.

Delectatio morosa

Mute is there for a reason.