The Disney Monopoly

Recommended Videos

ShadowKatt

New member
Mar 19, 2009
1,410
0
0
I want to play a hypothetical game here. Hypothetical at least for now. Disney is a huge corporation, one of the biggest in the US. One of the biggest in the world for that matter. They have massive influence, and bottomless pockets.

Microsoft is another huge corporation with massive influence and bank accounts, and once upon a time in the distant year 1998, the United States engaged in an anti-trust lawsuit with Microsoft on the grounds of the technology giant becoming a monopoly. Microsoft lost that case, and was forced to restructure.

Microsoft and Disney have similar business practices. They both have something they do well, and rode that horse to riches. Once there, they shifted their focus to squiring. T His is not an unusual business practice. However, Disney may be an exception. The Disney corporation has spent a great deal of money in the past decade squiring not just IPs, but also entire studios. Pixar and Lucasarts have been some of the most prominent, but not the only ones. Disney has also been instrumental in influencing law, specifically copyright, however they control one of the largest lobby groups in the US that has also been involved in some of the Internets favorite attempts to civilize the internet with such propositions as SOPA.

SO that's the back story. Here's the hypothetical game. Given what we know, what would happen if Disney extended is influence by purchasing the likes of Paramount, Warner Brothers, and other big names in film industry? They've already shown they can, they have the ability. And if they did it would essentially create a monopoly in the film industry. If Disney owned the film industry, they could also own the theater industry, since theaters survive on showing movies and if Disney refused to give them, they would be out of their prime cash flow. The United States could engage in another anti-trust lawsuit, but Disney has the people, the power, and the influence to change or ignore the laws. They've done it with the Copyright law, rewriting it to suit them. So who would stop them and what would living in a Disney-controlled country be like?
 

Thaluikhain

Elite Member
Legacy
Jan 16, 2010
19,538
4,128
118
You can't dominate the film industry the way you can with computers.

Even if Disney took over the US's big film players, people can still make cheap indie films. Likewise, lots of films made outside the US.

But, yeah, the US film industry could be made to pump out lots of constant high budget rubbish, but, well, would anyone notice any difference?
 

Esotera

New member
May 5, 2011
3,400
0
0
Microsoft used to have something like 90% of the PC market which is almost a true monopoly, whereas Disney doesn't have anywhere near that much market share. Also, it's more likely that Disney would be acquired by a big corporation, I'm pretty sure Comcast tried this a while back, which is far more dangerous to competition than Disney acquiring IP rights like Star Wars & buying a few studios.

Also, my understanding of the film industry in the US is that it's an oligopoly, with the big five studios controlling most of what gets made. Refusing mergers of any of those big five & potentially breaking them up into smaller units would help increase competition.

ShadowKatt said:
what would living in a Disney-controlled country be like?
A bit like Disneyland...
 

briankoontz

New member
May 17, 2010
656
0
0
Disney's vision for idealized Americana is perhaps best represented by the town it directed - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Celebration,_Florida

Whether Disney produces "rubbish" is subjective, but what's not in question is that it produces what it considers to support and bolster it's image. Artistic quality is of much less importance to Disney than self-promotion. It's a particularly creepy kind of self-promotion at this point, with only the most just-hit-puberty, ridiculously photogenic, and intellectually and morally vacant people being allowed to champion the Disney mantle.

Corporations have a way of incorporating (pardon the pun) criticism into their business model, when they have to. I'd rather corporations be dismantled rather then simply morphing into something somewhat less objectionable to adhere to popular demand. Disney, like all corporations, is an amoral creature.
 

theboombody

New member
Jan 2, 2014
128
0
0
I read a biography on Walt Disney, and when the visionary behind it all has been gone a while and can't control it anymore, it just isn't the same. I think Disney's massive expansion after Walt's death is probably not a good thing. I'd like to see more Disney theme parks that people could go to, but I'm not really anticipating their control of the Star Wars franchise. Sci-fi just doesn't seem to be a proper Disney area.