Warning: Contraversal, read at own risk. Would you rather.

[the_green_dragon]

Imagine if you will, being presenting with the choice:

Would you rather have sex with a girl you know used to be a guy Or a guy you know used to be a girl?

I'm talking fully trangender and with full functionality.

Would both options make you gay?

- Obviously you cant say Neither.

 

[White Lightning]

We can't say neither eh? Well in that case I choose both.

 

[FalloutJack]

- Obviously you cant say Neither.

Why? Because I'm being raped? (Hey, you SAID controversal.)

 

[the_green_dragon]

Hypothetical....
But I think I've come with a question so controversial no-one will answer it

 

[White Lightning]

Hypothetical....
But I think I've come with a question so controversial no-one will answer it

I'd hardly call this controversial... More like mildly difficult to answer. I can think of about 5 "Would you rather" questions worse this.

 

[Dags90]

I would choose an ftm because I'm gay. Because of the initial testosterone, most of the ftms I see who have done it have amazingly buff bodies.

 

[Colour Scientist]

A guy who was a girl.
For the record, I'm a woman. I'm not sexually attracted to the female form so I'm presuming I'd go for that one. I've never been in that particular situation though.

Edit: That question isn't nearly as controversial as you think it is.

 

[Casual Shinji]

Is this controversial? I answer questions like this during breakfast.

Anyway, girl that used to be a guy. And I'm assuming when you say "fully transgender with full functionallity" that you mean magic genie made it happen. No scars or inside out penis or any of that.

 

[Nouw]

I would make a reply but Mortai, bluntly, puts it the best way.

Well not attracted to people with dicks so the MtF as she no longer has one. Preferably neither as I'm not attracted to male genitalia and the fact the MtF used to be physically male bothers me.

Is this controversial? I answer questions like this during breakfast.

The Schwarzenegger is strong in this one.

 

[Helmholtz Watson]

Imagine if you will, being presenting with the choice:

Would you rather have sex with a girl you know used to be a guy Or a guy you know used to be a girl?

I'm talking fully trangender and with full functionality.

Would both options make you gay?

If I thought that the mtf was a women and I was attracted to them because I thought they were a women I don't think that it would make me gay.
However, to answer your first question, I would choose neither because I'm not attra-*sees last part of post*

- Obviously you cant say Neither.

*

[small]*no offense to any mtf readers[/small]

 

[FalloutJack]

Well, this isn't getting anywhere.

*Looks left, then right, then drops in a Change Of Subject Card and runs off*


DISCUSS!

 

[Jonluw]

Girl who used to be a guy, obviously.
Your hypothetical says the change in sex was perfect, so I'm all good. A vagina is a vagina.
I'm attracted to the female body, so it would be sort of hard for me to fuck someone with the body of a dude in the first place.

Also: Really not a particularly controversial question. Not even particularly hard to answer for someone who isn't fond of dicks.

 

[piinyouri]

These threads always end well.

FtM is my answer.

 

[TheNamlessGuy]

DELETED

 

[Spambot 3000]

I kill them both and have a threesome with their corpses.
CAN YA FEEL THE CONTROVERSY

 

[orangeban]

Oh this is just going to be a hilarious thread, I can tell, totally respectful to trans people, I'm sure.

 

[Smithburg]

I guess girl who used to be a guy. Boobs are boobs ya know.

 

[suitepee7]

the first one, so the one that used to be a guy but is now a girl.

i'm not really seeing much of an issue here, so long as they aren't just a dude with a vagina...

a more pressing question (and more controversial) would be asking who we'd fuck if only genetalia had been changed (a guy with a vagina, or a chick with a penis)

edit: should say, ima guy