So, what TV show episodes, movies, video games, etc. Do you pretend never happened? Was there ever a form of media that you thought was so bad you pretend that it does not exist?
Not even the part where that one dude catches an arrow that's flying at him in his hands, stops it, turns it around to face the guy that fired it, releases it, and it proceeds to fly back to the archer at full-speed and kill him? Really? Come on...Marter said:I like to pretend that The Scorpion King 2: Rise of a Warrior didn't happen.
As a huge Madoka Magica fan, I don't particularly agree with that.CrazyGirl17 said:Also, Puella Magi Madoka Magica: Rebellion Story. Fans of the show should understand why.
Eh, fair enough. I'm not opposed to a bit of difference in opinions.[Kira Must Die said:]As a huge Madoka Magica fan, I don't particularly agree with that.CrazyGirl17 said:Also, Puella Magi Madoka Magica: Rebellion Story. Fans of the show should understand why.
Whether you think the film was necessary is up to you, as the original show ended perfectly, but I do think Rebellion adds more to Homura's character. The thing is that I don't find what she did hard to buy, because I always figured that someone who's been through what she have wouldn't be all right in the head. Repeating the same timeline almost a hundred times for the sake of saving a friend, to the point where it became a necessity for her to live, how would that change a person? At what point would loyalty to a friend turn into obsession, which is how I always felt about Homura. Even after the series, she's still trapped in her own obsession with Madoka, still willing to do anything for her sake, even if it goes against what Madoka would've wanted. That doesn't make her a bad character, in fact it makes her even more interesting to me. I think the film adds to the series, and has some neat ideas, which is what I'm always open to when it comes to Madoka.
My only problem is that it shouldn't have been a twist. I feel it would've sat better with viewers if it was a gradual change over the course of the film, to when it gets to that point you're fearing for what Homura might do.
CrazyGirl17 said:Eh, fair enough. I'm not opposed to a bit of difference in opinions.[Kira Must Die said:]As a huge Madoka Magica fan, I don't particularly agree with that.CrazyGirl17 said:Also, Puella Magi Madoka Magica: Rebellion Story. Fans of the show should understand why.
Whether you think the film was necessary is up to you, as the original show ended perfectly, but I do think Rebellion adds more to Homura's character. The thing is that I don't find what she did hard to buy, because I always figured that someone who's been through what she have wouldn't be all right in the head. Repeating the same timeline almost a hundred times for the sake of saving a friend, to the point where it became a necessity for her to live, how would that change a person? At what point would loyalty to a friend turn into obsession, which is how I always felt about Homura. Even after the series, she's still trapped in her own obsession with Madoka, still willing to do anything for her sake, even if it goes against what Madoka would've wanted. That doesn't make her a bad character, in fact it makes her even more interesting to me. I think the film adds to the series, and has some neat ideas, which is what I'm always open to when it comes to Madoka.
My only problem is that it shouldn't have been a twist. I feel it would've sat better with viewers if it was a gradual change over the course of the film, to when it gets to that point you're fearing for what Homura might do.
Personally, I think my problem with how the movie turned out is the fact that it took the bittersweet ending of the series and made it... that... apparently all for the sake of deconstructing happy endings. This I feel, is both cruel and mean-spirited towards characters who deserved better...
Though like you said, Homura was probably a bit off her rocker by this point, I can kinda see that. You also mentioned that the whole thing should have been gradual, and I think that might have made it less grating. But no... that's not what we got is it? *SIGH*
That being said, Kyubey's fate is quite cathartic...