Why do people choose?

Recommended Videos

Akeroh

New member
Feb 2, 2011
16
0
0
It might just be me, but lately, especially with the whole BF3 vs MW3 fanboy raeg that's going on, I have to wonder...
Why do you have to choose? I mean, If you make enough disposable income to buy games regularly, why does it matter which one is better...I mean, you can easily buy them both. I understood it when I was a little kid and it was xbox vs playstation, because you really only got one or the other and yours had to be the best.
That's also the thing I don't get about the backlash of nostalgia games, that whole angry birds argument, and MODRN WARPHAIR IS TEH GAMING DESTROY. The thing is, it's not a black and white thing... Especially the whole angry birds thing. It's a freakin' dollar. You can afford a freakin' dollar and pretty much anything else.
So, my question is, why is this fanboyism warranted when you can just as easily play both games?

*Edit* This calls for more clarification - I was using those games as examples. I'm not asking about why people choose not to buy a game because they think they won't enjoy it, or it looks too similar, etc, I'm asking why people care so much about specific games, to the point of trashing the other, or claiming that it is ruining gaming, why do they care so much if one game is going to be better than the one they arbitrarily choose, instead of simply playing both games, or just leaving the other one alone because people that are interested will buy both.
 

Phlakes

Elite Member
Mar 25, 2010
4,282
0
41
Because this is the internet. Don't try to apply logic to it. You'll just end up in a crocodile pond with a dozen or two thongs around your forehead.
 

Navvan

New member
Feb 3, 2011
560
0
0
Unless you literally have infinite money or so much money you can't spend it all then why purchase two games that are essentially the same or extremely similar to the point that they don't add anything or add so little the price isn't worth it?

So my answer would be, why buy both?

I can't rationalize irrational fan boy behavior so I'll just leave that part out.
 

Cazza

New member
Jul 13, 2010
1,933
0
0
It's about which one is better. Why Iam going to buy a game I believe I will not enjoy? Or won't enjoy as much as the other? Some of us don't have the money to buy both or the time to play both. With both games being a sequel in a in popular series everyone knows what they are getting. It's not a hard thing to decide which one your going to get. It's the series you like more.
 

shrekfan246

Not actually a Japanese pop star
May 26, 2011
6,374
0
0
Cazza said:
It not about choosing. It's about which one is better. Why Iam going to buy a game I believe I will not enjoy? Or won't enjoy as much as the other? Some of us don't have the money to buy both or the time to play both. With both games being a sequel in a in popular series everyone knows what they are getting. It's not a hard thing to decide which one your going to get. It's the series you like more.
The point is that just because you believe one is inferior, you don't need to take up your flaming sword and become a zealot that challenges the simplest notion that your sworn enemy, the inferior game, might be better than you thought. Your opinion is just that; Your opinion. There's no need to thrust it upon other people who probably won't be swayed anyway.
 

The Breadcrab

New member
Mar 20, 2011
171
0
0
Navvan said:
Unless you literally have infinite money or so much money you can't spend it all then why purchase two games that are essentially the same or extremely similar to the point that they don't add anything or add so little the price isn't worth it?

So my answer would be, why buy both?

I can't rationalize irrational fan boy behavior so I'll just leave that part out.
Basically this. Why buy two games that are similar? Especially when you don't have that much disposable income? I can only buy two games this fall, so I'm picking wisely.

Also, it's kind of fun to have a sense of pride and/or loyalty to a certain game. I don't support raging fan arguments over which is better, but it often feels satisfying and rewarding to stick with one game and love it rather than playing everything and merely 'liking' it. Get my drift?
 

Cazza

New member
Jul 13, 2010
1,933
0
0
shrekfan246 said:
Cazza said:
It not about choosing. It's about which one is better. Why Iam going to buy a game I believe I will not enjoy? Or won't enjoy as much as the other? Some of us don't have the money to buy both or the time to play both. With both games being a sequel in a in popular series everyone knows what they are getting. It's not a hard thing to decide which one your going to get. It's the series you like more.
The point is that just because you believe one is inferior, you don't need to take up your flaming sword and become a zealot that challenges the simplest notion that your sworn enemy, the inferior game, might be better than you thought. Your opinion is just that; Your opinion. There's no need to thrust it upon other people who probably won't be swayed anyway.
I'm just giving a reason. As to why people fight about it. I never take that flaming sword and duel zealots. I didn't even say which one I prefered.
 

shrekfan246

Not actually a Japanese pop star
May 26, 2011
6,374
0
0
Cazza said:
I'm just giving a reason. As to why people fight about it. I never take that flaming sword and duel zealots. I didn't even say which one I prefered.
Fair enough, I suppose I agree with your reason and simply take the stance that I don't understand why people use it EDIT: to argue about other games, that is.
 

Speakercone

New member
May 21, 2010
480
0
0
Let's say I go to a restaurant with a friend. I order pizza and he orders steak. Part of me would be looking at his steak and wondering if I made the right decision, even if I'm very happy indeed about my choice of meal. I might feel the need to reinforce my decision by reasoning that steak sucks compared to pizza. Right there, I'm a pizza fanboy.

One solution would be to just order both, but I only wanted one meal. Another answer is to enjoy the same meal as my friend so that we both enjoy something nice, or of course I could just have a taste of his steak.

Any way you slice it, it all comes down to being insecure in your decision and trying to rationalize it away. It's like a mental defence mechanism.

Also, I'm kinda hungry now.