You have to be Evil to be Beneficial

Recommended Videos

Da Chi

New member
Sep 6, 2010
401
0
0
If you could do one thing to help the world what would it be?
Could be anything. But one catch is that you have to do something horrible to balance your actions.
Like Karmic Balance.
For every good action you have to do something equally abhorrent. Every life saved, one would be lost. An Eye for an Eye so to speak.

Would you help the world by becoming a monster?
Would you do something selfish for your own personal gain?
Would you avoid the option to help people to preserve your soul?


I've been pondering this. If I was to cure cancer, I would instead have to kill the equal number of people every year, and rob people of money for medical bills, make people sick and altogether ruin lives. And I would have to deal with the burden of doing all this till the day I die. Let's say there there is no way I could die unless by natural causes, would I be able to handle it. Could I be a saviour for some and the destruction for others. Would I be able to bear that weight? In all honesty I don't think I could.

So that being said, I could do something less grandiose and have less of a consequence. Let's say I were to save the life of a single family member. In turn, I would only have to kill someone of equal importance to me. Who would I kill? How could I possibly decide on the person?

Tell me how you would react in these situations. I'm a firm believer in karma and have been wondering about the consequences of greatness.
Maybe share you're own hypothetical and see if people could handle it.
 

JRCB

New member
Jan 11, 2009
4,387
0
0
Kill pretty much everyone and then have the ability to remove the damage done to the planet.

Yeah, I'd be a bit of a monster.
 

warprincenataku

New member
Jan 28, 2010
647
0
0
I'd help out all the orphanages in my city by burning down a few of them. Less orphanages means more financial aid goes to each.
 

Griphphin

New member
Jul 4, 2009
941
0
0
This is an interesting topic, and upon thinking about it I wouldn't do anything. If it's equal, I don't feel it would be right to save one person's life if it means killing another.
What makes one person better than another?
 

bak00777

New member
Oct 3, 2009
938
0
0
kill all the idiotic douchebags, there that is both beneficial, and im sure some people will think that is evil... done and done.
 

Xpwn3ntial

Avid Reader
Dec 22, 2008
8,023
0
0
Griphphin said:
This is an interesting topic, and upon thinking about it I wouldn't do anything. If it's equal, I don't feel it would be right to save one person's life if it means killing another.
What makes one person better than another?
Your relationship with them and their merits.

OT: I can't really think of anything. I guess I could solve world hunger by cutting down the population of the planet.
 

Da Chi

New member
Sep 6, 2010
401
0
0
Griphphin said:
This is an interesting topic, and upon thinking about it I wouldn't do anything. If it's equal, I don't feel it would be right to save one person's life if it means killing another.
What makes one person better than another?
It's what I'm trying to grasp. Could you be the one who decides who lives and who dies? Each person is better than someone else in some way. I'm trying to find out what people value over EVERYTHING. Because you have to do something so despicable it means you have to choose your cause with caution.
 

hittite

New member
Nov 9, 2009
1,681
0
0
I invent a working FTL drive and build several colony ships. Which is a good thing since I cause every volcano on Earth to erupt simultaneously (yes, even Yellowstone).
 

Da Chi

New member
Sep 6, 2010
401
0
0
bak00777 said:
kill all the idiotic douchebags, there that is both beneficial, and im sure some people will think that is evil... done and done.
Then you would have to kill all intelligent and eloquent people. Rid the world of intelligence to remove ignorance?
 

Da Chi

New member
Sep 6, 2010
401
0
0
Xpwn3ntial said:
I can't really think of anything. I guess I could solve world hunger by cutting down the population of the planet.
So you snap your fingers and no-one will starve again, but let's say one billion people die INSTANTLY. Would you do it?
 

008Zulu_v1legacy

New member
Sep 6, 2009
6,019
0
0
I am going to Hell, I know this. So I have been preparing, I have been buying people's souls in order to trade for more hospitable living conditions.
 

Da Chi

New member
Sep 6, 2010
401
0
0
hittite said:
I invent a working FTL drive and build several colony ships. Which is a good thing since I cause every volcano on Earth to erupt simultaneously (yes, even Yellowstone).
So you destroy the earth but invent a means to escape it. Interesting...
 

bak00777

New member
Oct 3, 2009
938
0
0
Da Chi said:
bak00777 said:
kill all the idiotic douchebags, there that is both beneficial, and im sure some people will think that is evil... done and done.
Then you would have to kill all intelligent and eloquent people. Rid the world of intelligence to remove ignorance?
not necsesarily(sp? idc) because the family member of said idiotic douchebags would find that pretty evil.
 

REAPER5594

New member
Nov 3, 2009
115
0
0
bak00777 said:
kill all the idiotic douchebags, there that is both beneficial, and im sure some people will think that is evil... done and done.
damn it! I've been Ninja'd
 

Da Chi

New member
Sep 6, 2010
401
0
0
bak00777 said:
Da Chi said:
bak00777 said:
kill all the idiotic douchebags, there that is both beneficial, and im sure some people will think that is evil... done and done.
Then you would have to kill all intelligent and eloquent people. Rid the world of intelligence to remove ignorance?
not necsesarily(sp? idc) because the family member of said idiotic douchebags would find that pretty evil.
True, but in your eyes the act is not as evil as beneficial. I want to know you're perspective on this. Would you kill everyone intelligent to kill everyone idiotic.
 

Da Chi

New member
Sep 6, 2010
401
0
0
REAPER5594 said:
bak00777 said:
kill all the idiotic douchebags, there that is both beneficial, and im sure some people will think that is evil... done and done.
damn it! I've been Ninja'd
Same question for you. Would you kill everyone Intelligent if it meant everyone idiotic dies.
 

bak00777

New member
Oct 3, 2009
938
0
0
Da Chi said:
bak00777 said:
Da Chi said:
bak00777 said:
kill all the idiotic douchebags, there that is both beneficial, and im sure some people will think that is evil... done and done.
Then you would have to kill all intelligent and eloquent people. Rid the world of intelligence to remove ignorance?
not necsesarily(sp? idc) because the family member of said idiotic douchebags would find that pretty evil.
True, but in your eyes the act is not as evil as beneficial. I want to know you're perspective on this. Would you kill everyone intelligent to kill everyone idiotic.
i see what you are saying now. Do i have to do the exact opposite of the beneficial thing, if not, ill go kick a puppy, that it EVIL!!!!!
 

Da Chi

New member
Sep 6, 2010
401
0
0
bak00777 said:
Da Chi said:
bak00777 said:
Da Chi said:
bak00777 said:
kill all the idiotic douchebags, there that is both beneficial, and im sure some people will think that is evil... done and done.
Then you would have to kill all intelligent and eloquent people. Rid the world of intelligence to remove ignorance?
not necsesarily(sp? idc) because the family member of said idiotic douchebags would find that pretty evil.
True, but in your eyes the act is not as evil as beneficial. I want to know you're perspective on this. Would you kill everyone intelligent to kill everyone idiotic.
i see what you are saying now. Do i have to do the exact opposite of the beneficial thing, if not, ill go kick a puppy, that it EVIL!!!!!
It doesn't have to be the exact opposite but it has to be equally evil as your benefit to mankind. So let's say for every idiot you kill, you have to kick ten puppies to death. Could you do that?
 

bak00777

New member
Oct 3, 2009
938
0
0
Da Chi said:
bak00777 said:
Da Chi said:
bak00777 said:
Da Chi said:
bak00777 said:
kill all the idiotic douchebags, there that is both beneficial, and im sure some people will think that is evil... done and done.
Then you would have to kill all intelligent and eloquent people. Rid the world of intelligence to remove ignorance?
not necsesarily(sp? idc) because the family member of said idiotic douchebags would find that pretty evil.
True, but in your eyes the act is not as evil as beneficial. I want to know you're perspective on this. Would you kill everyone intelligent to kill everyone idiotic.
i see what you are saying now. Do i have to do the exact opposite of the beneficial thing, if not, ill go kick a puppy, that it EVIL!!!!!
It doesn't have to be the exact opposite but it has to be equally evil as your benefit to mankind. So let's say for every idiot you kill, you have to kick ten puppies to death. Could you do that?
damn thats a lot of puppies, there so many douchebags, i dont think there is enough puppies, and i would prolly have to do it over several days, because my leg would get tired.

Just kidding, no i would not be able to kick all those puppies.