Gena Davis institute on Gender in media tries to link violent games to mass shootings and police violence

Recommended Videos

Hawki

Elite Member
Legacy
Mar 4, 2014
9,651
2,179
118
Country
Australia
Gender
Male
Of course they are.

When some straggot verbally harasses you in the street for "looking gay", what do you think they're responding to?
Stereotypes informed by prejudice.

But okay, since you found that confusing let me rephrase. What if everyone based their decisions about who they were attracted to and wanted to sleep with not on some internalized sense of what sexual category they fall into (which is identity, by the way) but rather on how they felt at the specific time when the possibility became available.
Well I don't see the scenario you're describing actually existing. What you seem to be suggesting is that everyone is more or less bisexual. If this isn't the case, it doesn't matter what category one falls into, people with opposite-sex attraction are going to be attracted to the opposite-sex, people with same-sex attraction are going to be attracted to the same-sex, then there'll be people attracted to both, and so on.

If you're asking what changes in the long run, I guess people can be with who they want to be, and society's better for it. If in the short term...okay, maybe not sexual assault, but if everyoe acts on how they feel in the moment, then what do you think that means practically?

I mean, it's a pretty basic description of how sex works, and how sexual and relationship dynamics function as a cultural baggage around sexual acts and indeed sexual relationships. You were the one insisting that I was talking about fetish stuff ("domination") when I talked about "active" and "passive" roles earlier, you were the one who insisted I was talking about "bro culture" rather than "heterosexual culture" and insisting that most straights never do stuff like this. What on earth did you expect if not an explanation?
It's still not an explanation at all. It's still stuff like "topping" and all these other terms I've never heard of until now.

If you want to discuss sexual positions and sexual dynamics, fine, but don't expect me to do it with you.

Sexual dynamics structure the way people physically behave around people they are in a sexual relationship with or are attracted to. When we see couples acting out intimacy in films, the dynamics of their interaction alters the way we see them. For example, compare the way Neo kisses Persephone with the way Neo and Trinity kiss in the elevator (and the fact that I've phrased it that way is giving it away). When Neo kisses Persephone, he is topping. He leans in for the kiss, she parts her lips a bit. He is actively doing the kissing, and she is receptive. It's an extremely gendered kiss between a man and a woman acting out conventional male and female roles. When Trinity and Neo kiss, they both kind of throw themselves at each other. They each put their hand on the back of the other's neck, which is a pretty strong gesture. There's no clear top and bottom. It's not weird, it doesn't register as overtly the "wrong" way to kiss, but it's also much less gendered. It's not unheard of or weird to see straight kisses depicted that way, but it is far more indicative of the way you'd shoot a same-sex kiss (without a clear masculine/feminine dynamic).
Okay...sure...maybe? But you can see my earlier comments on that kiss as to why it is the way it is (in my view) rather than what's written here.

I'd argue my case (again), but it seems we simply look at media completely different.

That's not my point.

My point is about whether that scene is pandering at all. I think your arguments for not liking the scene are fine. I don't think I like it either (although I don't seem to find it as obnoxious as you do) but you specifically stated that you felt the scene was pandering to straights. My argument is that I disagree, and I wonder if part of the reason you registered that scene in particular as pandering is precisely because it didn't actually pander to you, because it's not very effective as a heterosexual fantasy.

It was a very, very small point though, and I'm happy to drop it.
Okay, fine, you may be right. But as I hope I've demonstrated, even if the pandering is effective, I don't necessarily enjoy pandering (again, ThaddeusxJune). As a fantasy, it's effective. But it's still pandering, and it doesn't really add anything from a story or character perspective.
 

Hawki

Elite Member
Legacy
Mar 4, 2014
9,651
2,179
118
Country
Australia
Gender
Male
So, reading the posts by various other users...this seems like a circle jerk of sorts. Outrage over outrage.

There's definitely been outrage over (supposed) sexualization in games - off the top of my head, there was when Fox News misrepresented Mass Effect as "a game about a man having sex with whomever he wants" (or something like that). On the other side, you get people descending into a frothing rage about Abby being too butch. And if you want another example of that, take the reaction to the new She-Ra, about not being feminine enough. But to get back to the "woke" side, then you also have complaints about there not being enough overweight characters, female or otherwise.

Frankly, it's boring.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BrawlMan

Mister Mumbler

Pronounced "Throat-wobbler Mangrove"
Legacy
Jun 17, 2020
1,904
1,782
118
Nowhere, Middle of
Country
United States
But there has been a downward trend in that stuff, and literally, any female character with any degree of a feminine design comes out like Dead Or Alive 5 and 6, or any anime game there has been outrage from reviewers, tweets, and likely emails among insiders to censor.
"People keep on complaining about the character designs in this game!"
"Oh, what game?"
"Dead Or Alive."
 

The Rogue Wolf

Stealthy Carnivore
Legacy
Nov 25, 2007
17,491
10,275
118
Stalking the Digital Tundra
Gender
✅
But there has been a downward trend in that stuff, and literally, any female character with any degree of a feminine design comes out like Dead Or Alive 5 and 6, or any anime game there has been outrage from reviewers, tweets, and likely emails among insiders to censor.
Meanwhile, a female character gets a redesign that makes her breasts appear smaller, and apparently this is a ploy by the SJWs and feminists.


We all know that a woman-shaped group of polygons having smaller virtual tits is just one more step towards the womyn cutting off our balls and making us hold their purses.
 

Cicada 5

Elite Member
Apr 16, 2015
3,136
1,706
118
Country
Nigeria
Meanwhile, a female character gets a redesign that makes her breasts appear smaller, and apparently this is a ploy by the SJWs and feminists.


We all know that a woman-shaped group of polygons having smaller virtual tits is just one more step towards the womyn cutting off our balls and making us hold their purses.
And the redesign of Tifa's boobs was barely noticable.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BrawlMan

Gergar12

Elite Member
Legacy
Apr 24, 2020
4,385
931
118
Country
United States
Diversity of thought for me but not for thee
People are paying to go to college to get a job, they are paying for it, I am paying for it. How are gender studies relevant to today's economy.

Edit: Constant useless journal articles that are basically. Games marketed to males are bad, games marketed to males are bad.
 

Gergar12

Elite Member
Legacy
Apr 24, 2020
4,385
931
118
Country
United States
Meanwhile, a female character gets a redesign that makes her breasts appear smaller, and apparently this is a ploy by the SJWs and feminists.


We all know that a woman-shaped group of polygons having smaller virtual tits is just one more step towards the womyn cutting off our balls and making us hold their purses.
I literally don't care about that, in my opinion, Tifa is hot here, I care about the downward trend and puritanism of today's feminists. They exclude vs create. and their voice creates larger corrective responses than the counter ones do.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dwarvenhobble

Silvanus

Elite Member
Legacy
Jan 15, 2013
13,054
6,748
118
Country
United Kingdom
It's not fringe. When it's entire media outlets attacking Dead Or Alive 5 and 6. That's if CNN or MSNBC decided to attack pens, but you call it fringe.

Edit: Also the numerous journal articles from gender study professors about hyper-sexualization in games.
Right, but DOA isn't an example of these sensibly designed female characters that you said were equally targeted by the media. DOA is pretty highly sexualised.
 

Casual Shinji

Should've gone before we left.
Legacy
Jul 18, 2009
20,519
5,335
118
I literally don't care about that, in my opinion, Tifa is hot here, I care about the downward trend and puritanism of today's feminists. They exclude vs create. and their voice creates larger corrective responses than the counter ones do.
Again, could I get some examples of this?

Because Tifa was a prime example of the SJW feminists supposedly coming for the hot babes, eventhough Tifa still looked traditionally hot, had traditionally big boobs, and showed a lot of skin. All those anime games are still doing their hot sexy waifu thing unobstructed.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BrawlMan

TheMysteriousGX

Elite Member
Legacy
Sep 16, 2014
8,580
7,215
118
Country
United States
People are paying to go to college to get a job, they are paying for it, I am paying for it. How are gender studies relevant to today's economy.

Edit: Constant useless journal articles that are basically. Games marketed to males are bad, games marketed to males are bad.
Lmao, even if this were true:
A) Diversity of thought even includes thought you don't like
and
B) Putting a paper out in a journal that a dozen people are gonna read isn't exactly stopping the release of Bayonetta 3 my dude. We just had a fantastically broken "AAA" game that came out who's most hilarious bug was that it couldn't keep your character's fully rendered penis from clipping out your pants. 15 years ago, Hot Coffee caused lawsuits, nowadays sex games are on Steam

The "outrage" about sex in games has certainly changed, it's just been rocketing into way more permissible as long as we aren't sexing up kids.
 

Gordon_4

The Big Engine
Legacy
Apr 3, 2020
6,787
6,045
118
Australia
Right, but DOA isn't an example of these sensibly designed female characters that you said were equally targeted by the media. DOA is pretty highly sexualised.
And honestly, deflating Kasumi - who incidentally was 14 in the first game - from what I think was a EE to D and yelling about THE END is like panicking because a plane has gone from 38,000 feet to 36,000 feet. Every woman in DOA is still drop dead gorgeous - Helena you saucy crumpet you - they just look 3% less absurd.
 

Silvanus

Elite Member
Legacy
Jan 15, 2013
13,054
6,748
118
Country
United Kingdom
And honestly, deflating Kasumi - who incidentally was 14 in the first game - from what I think was a EE to D and yelling about THE END is like panicking because a plane has gone from 38,000 feet to 36,000 feet. Every woman in DOA is still drop dead gorgeous - Helena you saucy crumpet you - they just look 3% less absurd.
Exactly! And for what it's worth, I'd be a little less irked by the endless parade of mega-skimpy female outfits if I could also have equally skimpy male outfits.

But nooooo, I have to minimise my game and open another tab if I want to look at man-ass. It's discriminatory I tell you!
 

Gordon_4

The Big Engine
Legacy
Apr 3, 2020
6,787
6,045
118
Australia
Exactly! And for what it's worth, I'd be a little less irked by the endless parade of mega-skimpy female outfits if I could also have equally skimpy male outfits.

But nooooo, I have to minimise my game and open another tab if I want to look at man-ass. It's discriminatory I tell you!
To be fair, Tekken at least allows you to earn money in the arcade mode to buy costume stuff for characters. Loin cloths and speedos galore homey.
 

Silvanus

Elite Member
Legacy
Jan 15, 2013
13,054
6,748
118
Country
United Kingdom
To be fair, Tekken at least allows you to earn money in the arcade mode to buy costume stuff for characters. Loin cloths and speedos galore homey.
Well, sure, but they're all absurdly proportioned muscleheads.

Where my twinks at?
 

Satinavian

Elite Member
Legacy
Apr 30, 2016
2,109
879
118
Well, sure, but they're all absurdly proportioned muscleheads.
I feel similar about all the skinny big brested women.

I mean, nothing against big breasts or skinny women but the combination often just feels ... wrong, even uncanny.