10 year old girl Rapes 4 year old boy

[Wraith]

I'll just say this, I lost my virginity when I was 8 or 9. That's right 4th grade was all about sex for me, a female classmate and her sister. I can say kids can understand sex at that age, so much so, that it was rare in Elementary school for me to not hear about a guy getting at least to 3rd base with a girl. By 5th grade, I contracted my first STD from a 10th grader. (I know all this sound far fetched, but please believe me, this is real and has a point.)

So for this situation, I can believe that she knew what she was doing. Maybe not fully, but to an extent. I have been that young, doing worst shit, and enjoying it. But she is still young, still learning. Even if she did understand what was happening I do not believe she should be charged with anything. Tell her parents, have them punish her, maybe have a police officer visit to explain how people go to jail for stuff like that all the time. She is still at an age where this is all new this is a time for learning, not condemning.

Captcha: Bless You

You're welcome captcha.

 

[generals3]

.... Think back to when YOU were 10 years old. I remember when -I- was 10. I knew you DON'T FUCKING TOUCH PEOPLE THERE.

No, this does need some action by the state. Penitentiary isn't the thing for it though. This child needs social services intervention. Look into her family and get her a Psychologist, because there is NO reason a 10 year old should be -curious- about that shit at all. It should have been mostly demystified several years prior.

I would accept this as "Exploration" if she was doing that with someone closer to her age, or if she did it before she was school age. At 10 years old you're old enough to know that shit isn't acceptable.

Sexual curiosity is quite common among kids. For instance I read more and more cases of toddlers in pre-school "experimenting". And while it's less "sexual" and more of a "I wanna know more about what you have down there because I don't have it" kind of thing, the curiosity is there. And psychologists even note that people are actually also blowing things out of proportion because that has always existed, there is simply much more transparency about it (easier flow of information and consequently people are more likely to hear about it when it happens). I even once read an article about a group of cub-scouts (9-11y old) playing sex-games when their supervisors left them unsupervised in a dorm (they didn't expect that to happen and it was nap-time).
Now sure it's weird that in this case it involved someone much younger but most kids don't have that notion of "consent" and maturity as older people have.

 

[Quellist]

I spotted a Facebook comment on the article making the same allegation about the girl fingering the boy, but all signs are pointing to it being a lie.

So, one person made an assumption and passed it off as fact, and suddenly a bunch of other people bought into it? Somehow, that doesn't surprise me in the least.

But in the interest of fairness, I'll ask them directly.

Yeah, i reread that and edited my post, i think the first time i read it i was so shocked i blanked it, seriously...ewww

And normally, i'm not an easily shocked person

I too expressed in my original post how miffed I was that people were actually condoning what this girl did and seemed to be laughing it off as childish fun, I mean she's 10 not a toddler and by ten you know right from wrong, and if she really did have fingers stuck up his anus then that's pretty disgusting and I hope they they throw the book at her, that or that she gets some serious help.

Right, that changes things a lot. I just watched the video, assuming it would sum up what was going on, but it was likely for daytime television, so that part wasn't mentioned.

Given that, I'm still not sure. Though I am sure she needs to be punished by her mother, but I don't think the authorities need to be this involved. She was certainly mean to the little boy and took advantage of his size and innocence, for which punishment of some kind goes without saying.

As long as the little boy got out of this unharmed and no future kids get harmed.

Hey guys, I can't find any sort of source for the thing about her shoving her fingers up the boy's anus. Is it something you came across that I'm just missing, or are you just claiming that because this guy here...

She shoved two fingers up a 4 year old's anus while fondling his genitals.
"That girl had no idea that what she was doing was wrong."
Yeeeeah-no...

...tried to pass it off to you as fact despite later all but admitting here...

No... just that it's the only likely explanation for her to be prosecuted for rape, which she is.
I don't have access to the police report, but there has to be grounds for the prosecution to charge her with rape.
If I get access to the police report.

...that he made the whole thing up?

If it's the latter, then not cool guys. Not cool.

If you bothered to read my other post a few posts up I pointed out "if its true, which I doubt"

 

[Dragonbums]

So...from what I'm garnering from this article, without asking neither two children how they ended up in this situation, the girl gets charged for rape.

At this stage of a kids' life, it is very VERY possible that she doesn't know what a dick looks like, and the boy- equally ignorant of such things was willing to show her and she played around with it. (It can even be assumed that the girl showed her vagina to the boy earlier before the seen incident.). This probably was around the time when the lady saw the scene and called the cops.
This is a situation that calls for the birds and the bees talk. Not Juvenile detention.

This is ridiculous, however I read it happened in Texas and instantly I am not surprised.

 

[TakerFoxx]

If you bothered to read my other post a few posts up I pointed out "if its true, which I doubt"

I did. Both that post and the one I quoted implied that you had come across actual details of what took place, which is what I was asking you about.

Don't get me wrong, I agree with your original post. I was just mad at that guy for lying to so many people and irritated that so many people took what he said at face-value without bothering to double-check or question what he said.

 

[Pebblig]

The whole article reads as the case being handled in a rather over the top manner.

Also, the article is written terribly and I counted 2-3 spelling mistakes, which doesn't really help to report the story.

 

[DugMachine]

Pretty silly. Kids experiment like this at that age, they're curious. I highly doubt a 10 year old girl was touching this boys penis with the intent to sexually assault him. Parents have every right to be upset but getting the police involved? Give me a break.

Hell, I didn't figure out girls have vaginas until I was 8 cause me and a neighborhood girl were playing doctor. Luckily we never got caught

 

[Towels]

Ok, WTF? Did the Escapist turn into SomethingAwful.com?

We get these "look at this fucked up thing I just read" threads every now and then. Some give better food for thought than others. Personally the title in this one is a bit misleading, a bit too yellowy.

My Apologies, Escapist. Had a bad day.

Perhaps these things are healthy to discuss after all.