A Game with the Most Replay Value

[DustStorm]

I've played Fallout 3 for 500 hours on the Xbox 360 so I'd say that would be one of the most replayable games I've owned. Actually, I can't wait to get it on PC so I can try out the game with mods. Also, Counter Strike since that game has been played by people since 1999 and it's still going strong with many of the same people.

 

[Valiance]

Rollercoaster Tycoon, of course.
And Metroid Prime.

And I do a playthrough of UT every few months. The maps that are usually my trouble-spots in the single-player campaign are CTF-November and AS-Overlord.

 

[Viivrabe]

KoTOR 2, i have played that through like 9 tomes and there is still content i have yet to see

 

[Caffeine Rage]

I have to agree with Mount & Blade: Warband. There is just a lot to do, even more so if you download a few mods. Just in single player, you can:

Trade and sell goods.
Terrorize the country side.
Rebel and form your own kingdom.
Loyally serve the king and his wishes.
Play your role in court, slowly rising to power.
Help a deposed leader retake their throne.
Spark a world wide war.

All of those are before you get into mods. It is an amazing game. Plus, multiplayer still looks pretty lively. Just yesterday there was a peak of 4,000 concurrent players.

Which reminds me, I need to go raiding my neighbors to the south!

 

[The Apothecarry]

This calls for a list:

Dynasty Warriors
TimeSplitters: Future Perfect (Multiplayer modes everywhere!)
Fallout 3 (119 hours for one save, 57 for the next)
Killing Floor
Halo: Reach
Soul Calibur IV
Resident Evil 5

 

[nbamaniac]

Batman: Arkham Asylum.. Combat NEVER gets old. I now solely play it for the challenge mode.

 

[TestSubject4]

I'd say Minecraft but it isn't really replaying, it's just continuing the dig.

 

[Sizzle Montyjing]

YOUR MUM!
(Christ, i need to stop doing that)
Seriously though, probably Half-Life or Oblivion. Not to sure.
I'm to vague.

 

[Rewold]

MGS3. Can't remember how many times I've beaten it. There's always new ways to play the game and new things to find.

 

[ImmortalDrifter]

Memorized? Fallout 3, Mass Effect 2.

Played a shitload of? Modern Warfare 2, Borderlands, Hunted: the Demons forge (not yet, but i will)

 

[gbemery]

Solitaire, any 4x game such as Civilization, Age of Empires, Sins of A Solar Empire, any game that has multiple endings like Chrono Cross.

 

[Bobbity]

I put over 900 hours into Wow before I quit. That was over a three or four year period, admittedly, but it's still pretty fucking depressing... Besides that, the amount of time I've spent playing Oblivion, Mount&Blade and so on begins to seem pathetic...

I've memorised most of the lore of Azeroth, spent ages exploring the world, and so on. I was the sort of player who'd go back and replay far older dungeons out of interest than new ones for gear, so even after all that time, I never got into raiding.

 

[tombman888]

Team Fortress 2, 552 hours, about a year.... Yeah, i'm addicted to it.

 

[Krantos]

Mount and Blade (obvious).

Divinity II: The Dragon Knight Saga. Surprising, but it really is a sweet game.

 

[JWRosser]

I've played Fallout 3 and New Vegas a fair amount of times.

Most of the Final Fantasy games, I feel, have a lot of replay value, and I've played through 7 - 13 copious amounts of times.

To be honest, I've played through many, many games at least twice: Arkham Asylum, Resident Evil, MVA2, Spyro etc etc

 

[Tallim]

Bulletstorm's Echo mode.
Nethack, Dwarf Fortress
Space Empires IV
Most NIS games.

Vagrant Story springs to mind also, but maybe that was just me.

 

[LostNumber]

WoW has easily taken the most amount of my time. I'm not completely sure on how long, but i'm sure it's into the high hundreds, if not thousands of hours. Playing in a changing world with hundreds of other people never gets old, and even though i'm taking a break right now, i'm sure i'll be back.

Other than that, Elder Scrolls: Oblivion and Fallout 3/New Vegas have sucked away a ton of time each. Also, when I was younger and got a PS1, I became obsessed with JRPGs and would constantly be replaying them (mostly PS-era Final Fantasy games).

 

[TacticalAssassin1]

For some reason Far Cry 2 always has me coming back for more.

 

[Deathninja19]

I'm cheating but the first level of Demon's Souls, it's the only level in that bloody game that I can do without looking at a guide or being cheap.

Oh and Mass Effect 1 but not 2 strangley, even though it's the better game it's not as fun for me as the first.

 

[nothtr]

Single player:

Rollercoaster Tycoon; you can beat each level in infinitely different ways.

If considering multiplayer games (which inherently have infinitely more replay value):

World of Warcraft, it is less about the actual quests, and more about the manner in which you level. I leveled a hunter to 60 (when it was the cap) then a rogue, then a warrior. They were all quite different experiences.

Any FPS with a steep learning curve. I guess you couldn't really call it 'replay' value, since the game never ends and you never really REplay it, you're just playing it indefinitely.