Twilight_guy said:
I think the better question is why the hell you have to beat five guys when they called the 'Elite 4'. There have never been 4 of them, always 5. Anyways, I assume that champion is more like a hired position then just the best guy. I assume that there are lots of guys who can beat the elite 4 but they don't make the new guy the champion every time, they just say 'congrats' and keep the current guy. Deciding the champion could be an entirely different event.
Anywho, I've always thought forcing people to use one of there Pokemon's 4 move slots in order to use an HM was dumb. Why not have it so HMs can be used without having to teach them to a Pokemon or something?
I'd suggest to read the Pokemon Adventures manga someday. There it all does make more sense (the inventor of Pokemon himself suggests that every Pokemon fan should read this manga because there they created the kind of world they wanted to create but couldn't due to limitations [be it technical or from Nintendo themselfs]).
The Pokemon league is completely seperate from the Elite 4 and goes like a traditional tournament (like the upcoming tournament feature in Black 2 / White 2).
The Elite 4 are just a group of 4 of the strongest trainers in the region who have actually a goal they work for.
I hope that someday they adapt more ideas from the manga. I'd really like to see a traditional tournament as the final challenge before facing off the champion. It would challenge my skills a little more than just reading up on the movesets of the Elite 4.