A theory on the joker (Mainly comic book version)

Recommended Videos

SpectacularWebHead

New member
Jun 11, 2012
1,175
0
0
So I was leafing through a few old batman comics, and some newer ones, and I began thinking: Batman isn't afraid of dying, but The Joker seems to be actively seeking it. Each of his endeavours has I high chance to kill a lot of people, and there is always a possibility that he could die.

So my thought was this: Is Batman and the jokers plots against him some elaborate suicide attempt by the Joker? Joker has said before that "His cannon was fixed 'gainst self slaughter", and his plans to kill thousands always have some kind of punchline. But if you look deeper and past all the showmanship, the joker is really just trying to raise the stakes to make batman kill him. And it has to be batman, He just won't allow anyone else the honour of killing him. And of course it has to look good, because no-one should ever know that he WANTED to die.

Another point would be the times batman seems to be about to kill him, and he tells him to go ahead and do it. I'd always assumed that he was just trying to point out batman never would or will, but looking at this theory, maybe it's a triple-bluff that batman never calls. After these instances the joker pretty much always says "I knew you wouldn't, you never will" in a kind of sneering way. But perhaps that contains how sad he is that batman won't ever put him out of his misery.

And the jokers misery has been something covered in previous comics. There've been two instances I know of where joker has been made sane, and he is genuinelly sorry for his crimes and despairing for his victims. This points to the fact the joker secretly wants to die. He wants batman to die with him, sure, but the jokers death would be like a euthanisation for him.

There's always a sadness and a pity you can attribute to the joker, largely in his backstory. It seems likely that the reason he hates batman so desperately is because batman made him then refused to kill him, leading him to become what he is now. That's why batman has to kill him then die with him, only then can the joker forgive him. Whilst I imagine there are no plans to permanantly kill batman or the joker, I think that they have to die together. They're too connected and they can't be killed any other way.

Anyway, Thoughts?
 

Relish in Chaos

New member
Mar 7, 2012
2,660
0
0
Well, the Joker?s ultimate goal seems to be getting Batman to break his one rule, which would mean killing him. I mean, if Batman should kill anyone in his however many years of claiming to protect Gotham City, it?s the Joker, his greatest enemy with the highest murder count who repeatedly escapes from Arkham Asylum just to fuck with Batman.

The Joker does essentially kill himself in The Dark Knight Returns, when Batman doesn?t have it in him to break his neck any further than paralysis. I would like it, though, if DC Comics actually bothered to take the risk and have Batman kill the Joker, or both of them die together. Even if it was just in a miniseries or something that wasn't connected to the mainstream continuity (which they reboot every so often to keep things fresh anyway).

Actually, you could make the argument that, due to the ambiguous nature of its ending, Batman killed the Joker in The Killing Joke, to tie in the whole ?one of us is going to kill each other in the end? thing. I wouldn?t put it past for Batman to just have just finally flipped when the Joker refused his offer for rehabilitation, and in laughing along with the Joker in his joke, he finally understand what was so funny about it and put him out of his misery, since the Joker genuinely looked sad at what had happened to himself (even if he couldn?t remember the origin behind), the world, and that he was too far past the point of being cured.
 

Froggy Slayer

New member
Jul 13, 2012
1,434
0
0
As always with a character in comic books that have been running so long, your theory depends on the writer.
 

Queen Michael

has read 4,010 manga books
Jun 9, 2009
10,400
0
0
Relish in Chaos said:
The Joker does essentially kill himself in The Dark Knight Returns, when Batman doesn?t have it in him to break his neck any further than paralysis. I would like it, though, if DC Comics actually bothered to take the risk and have Batman kill the Joker, or both of them die together. Even if it was just in a miniseries or something that wasn't connected to the mainstream continuity (which they reboot every so often to keep things fresh anyway).
I'm totally going to spoil The Nail by Alan Davis now.
He totally does that in The Nail by Alan Davis.
(The first third to be exact.)
 

Relish in Chaos

New member
Mar 7, 2012
2,660
0
0
Queen Michael said:
Relish in Chaos said:
The Joker does essentially kill himself in The Dark Knight Returns, when Batman doesn?t have it in him to break his neck any further than paralysis. I would like it, though, if DC Comics actually bothered to take the risk and have Batman kill the Joker, or both of them die together. Even if it was just in a miniseries or something that wasn't connected to the mainstream continuity (which they reboot every so often to keep things fresh anyway).
I'm totally going to spoil The Nail by Alan Davis now.
He totally does that in The Nail by Alan Davis.
(The first third to be exact.)
I don't know how to use spoiler tags, so I didn't bother. So sue me.
 

Queen Michael

has read 4,010 manga books
Jun 9, 2009
10,400
0
0
Relish in Chaos said:
Queen Michael said:
Relish in Chaos said:
The Joker does essentially kill himself in The Dark Knight Returns, when Batman doesn?t have it in him to break his neck any further than paralysis. I would like it, though, if DC Comics actually bothered to take the risk and have Batman kill the Joker, or both of them die together. Even if it was just in a miniseries or something that wasn't connected to the mainstream continuity (which they reboot every so often to keep things fresh anyway).
I'm totally going to spoil The Nail by Alan Davis now.
He totally does that in The Nail by Alan Davis.
(The first third to be exact.)
I don't know how to use spoiler tags, so I didn't bother. So sue me.
Huh? I was just giving an example of a comic where what you're talking about happens; it wasn't meant as a remark about you or anything.
 

ulzugot

New member
Aug 8, 2011
40
0
0
This theory is not bad, but I think it goes much deeper than Joker just wanting to die. For example, In the Batman/Punisher: Deadly Knights, Punisher comes across the Joker. When Joker realizes that Castle is going to pull the trigger, his usual grin fades away.

I think that joker does not want to die, but rather he wants to break Batman psychologically and morally, and making Batman disobeying his "no killing" rule, is part of it. If joker would want to be killed by the Batman, he could have just staged it so that there is no option, but for clown to get killed. However, most of Joker's plans seem to push Batman's limits instead of forcing Batman to use lethal force.
 

Gidiel167

New member
May 13, 2009
110
0
0
It's because The Joker's greatest joke would be to make Batman break his one rule.
 

Relish in Chaos

New member
Mar 7, 2012
2,660
0
0
Queen Michael said:
Relish in Chaos said:
Queen Michael said:
Relish in Chaos said:
The Joker does essentially kill himself in The Dark Knight Returns, when Batman doesn?t have it in him to break his neck any further than paralysis. I would like it, though, if DC Comics actually bothered to take the risk and have Batman kill the Joker, or both of them die together. Even if it was just in a miniseries or something that wasn't connected to the mainstream continuity (which they reboot every so often to keep things fresh anyway).
I'm totally going to spoil The Nail by Alan Davis now.
He totally does that in The Nail by Alan Davis.
(The first third to be exact.)
I don't know how to use spoiler tags, so I didn't bother. So sue me.
Huh? I was just giving an example of a comic where what you're talking about happens; it wasn't meant as a remark about you or anything.
Ah, OK then. My mistake, sorry.
 

SpectacularWebHead

New member
Jun 11, 2012
1,175
0
0
ulzugot said:
This theory is not bad, but I think it goes much deeper than Joker just wanting to die. For example, In the Batman/Punisher: Deadly Knights, Punisher comes across the Joker. When Joker realizes that Castle is going to pull the trigger, his usual grin fades away.

I think that joker does not want to die, but rather he wants to break Batman psychologically and morally, and making Batman disobeying his "no killing" rule, is part of it. If joker would want to be killed by the Batman, he could have just staged it so that there is no option, but for clown to get killed. However, most of Joker's plans seem to push Batman's limits instead of forcing Batman to use lethal force.
That's because it HAS to be batman that kills him. This exact same thing happened with Red Hood. Batman is the only one who gets the honour of killing him.