Signa said:
AMEN OP!
Even if you are one of those people who didn't like those examples, then tell me where are those games current-gen equivalents? They don't exist, because everything that has any popularity is a FPS.
Legend of Grimrock, TES V: Skyrim, Rayman Origins, Pokemon Conquest / Black 2 / White 2, Dark Souls, Witcher 2, Orcs Must Die 2 (think of it because I just now preordered it), Paper Mario Sticker Star, Diablo 3, Mass Effect 3.
Games I can think of out of the blue when I'm thinking about the "not postapocalyptic setting" and the criteria that it is not allowed to be a FPS. Some of them may not fall into your definition of popular or even definition of "hardcore" (an often used excuse to dismiss examples when arguments fail) but all of them are of mid up to good quality (except the one that have yet to be released where I can't judge).
If you can't think of any games that fall not into the "postapocalyptic FPS" trope than you do your best to ignore literally everything else that the market has to offer.
FelixG said:
I just looked at the new release section on Steam
1 out of 21 games on the new release this week are post apocalyptic. about 4% of the games released recently are post apoc.
If you keep buying those, thats on you, its not an overused genre
May I add your quote to support my point?