Captain Pooptits said:
TheMann said:
the C-10 is a sniper rifle of sorts. It would make no sense for a ghost to use a shotgun. In SC1 gameplay the ghosts can hit a target a lot further away than the marines can and for more damage. This couldn't happen with a shotgun. So the way I see it the C-10 is a multi-purpose high powered rifle, that can also fire a lock-down device or lase a target for a nuclear strike.
Anyhoo OT: Kerrigan certainly isn't played for sexiness in the standard sense, but she does carry a decent dose of fetish fuel. Now someone in the Starcraft universe that could be considered is Nova Terra from the canceled SC: Ghost game. I hear she has a cameo is SC2 (I still can't afford to buy that game yet grrr.) While she certainly is an attractive young women, when you hear her back-story and capabilities you quickly realize that she is absolutely fucking terrifying.
Fair enough, the Canister Rile is not a gun that shoots shot. However, it closely resembled a shotgun that fires metal slugs, in SC1. If you look at Kerrigan's portrait, you see she pumps her C-10 like a shotgun and the in game firing noise features the sound of a gun being pumped in between each shot. Also, if you look at the wire-frame of a ghost, there's no scope. In SC2 on the other hand, there's a great big fancy scope on the gun model and when using the Snipe ability you hear the stereotypically unrealistic "silenced" shooting noise that you hear in movies that feature noise suppressors.
Shotguns have a lot more range than the movies give them credit for, especially when using slugs instead of shot. Seems appropriate for the Ghosts to be using supercharged shotguns, since I imagine most zerg would shrug off a sniper round,
even a high caliber one.
I disagree.
A S&W 500- which is a
handgun has almost as much raw kinetic energy as a 12 gauge shotgun slug. Roughly 3,000 Foot pounds. If you use hot loaded cartridges with custom made shell casings- "John Ross" Custom loads- you can go higher.
The Springfield .30-06 sniper round is about 3500 foot pounds at max load. Which is about the utmost maximum you can squeeze out of a S&W 500 without making it explode, I think.
The 12 gauge has
slightly more power
3 1/2" 1-3/8" ounce
Muzzle Velocity: 1900 fps
Muzzle Energy: 3728 ft. lbs.
The .50 Barrett fires the .50 Browning Machine Gun Round- which is 15,000 foot pounds. That is more power than a 12 *or* a 10 gauge shotgun slug. The .700 Nitro Express is roughly the same.
With that much raw power, you could get decent penetration even with hollowpoint rounds at *very* long range. And although it's true that 12 guage shotgun slugs are very high caliber (.729 caliber) and 10 guage shotguns are even bigger, they have far far less kinetic energy. Shotgun slugs have horrible long range accuracy, even the rifled ones. Shotguns with rifled barrels (For better accuracy-they are generally superior to rifled slugs) cannot fire shot and are essentially just rifles.
So while the shotgun slugs might be a very big caliber, they actually don't have a lot of kinetic energy(In comparison to high power sniper rifles), and they are horribly innaccurate at long range. The .700 Nitro Express is only slightly smaller in terms of caliber, but much more accurate at long range and much, much more powerful than any shotgun cartridge currently around.
Simply put- you could not hit the target you are you are aiming at from long range unless you use a rifled barrel, which means you are using a rifle rather than a true shotgun, even if your gun is chambered for shotgun cartridges. And there is no shotgun cartridge on the planet that comes close to the most powerful rifle cartridges in terms of kinetic energy.
Shotgun slugs have longer range than pellets, yes, but they are
not long range cartridges. More like medium range. True rifle cartridges are really the only way to go for long range shooting.
EDIT: I know you said Supercharged shotguns, implying much more powerful ones than we currently use. My point was that Rifles can easily match, it not exceed, shotguns in terms of power, and that rifled slugs don't have as much long range accuracy as bullets fired from a rifled barrel. You can fit a shotgun with a rifled barrel, but this basically turns it into a rifle.