Are these game appropriate for a NINE year old?

Recommended Videos

NLS

Norwegian Llama Stylist
Jan 7, 2010
1,594
0
0
Hmm, at least games like GTA. When I was 10 or 11 I think, my friend had PS2 with GTA3. We never played it to get any story or such out of it, we just played it to have sex with a hooker, and then run over her with the car.
If a game has a somewhat OK story that can be understood by the player and appreciated, I'm a bit more loose on the age restriction, but games like GTA are just way too easy to ignore any plot and go on a killing spree around for the sake of "fun".
 

TheZaius

Regular Member
May 7, 2008
72
0
11
I suppose it depends on what the kid has already seen. But if he's 4chan immature, then these specific games definitely wont help...

There are plenty of other games on Steam more appropriate for a 9-year-old who is maturity-disabled.
 
May 25, 2010
610
0
0
Let him play those games. I was playing games like that since I was younger than him and I'm fine now. Just whatever you do, keep him miles away from onine gaming. If he really has to play something online, let him play Counter-Strike. The longer he stays away from the online scenes of anything else, the better.
 

Arkhangelsk

New member
Mar 1, 2009
7,702
0
0
Well, I've played mature games since I was 12, and even then my parents were very aware of the content. Tell them to look at the games so they know what he's doing.
 

commasplice

New member
Dec 24, 2009
469
0
0
GeneticallyModifiedDucks said:
Just whatever you do, keep him miles away from onine gaming. If he really has to play something online, let him play Counter-Strike. The longer he stays away from the online scenes of anything else, the better.
This, definitely. I used to play Neopets in middle school, and I remember whatever chat/forum system they had going there being FLOODED with "f/12/CA \//4na cy|3r?" type shit.
 

Schwerganoik

New member
Jul 1, 2010
84
0
0
I played Doom when I was seven, and most people who know me consider me to be peaceful and long-tempered. Aside from graphic nudity (as opposed to nudity in renaissance art), the danger comes only when he can't tell fantasy from reality (and that result has to be taught by a person).
 

Con Carne

New member
Nov 12, 2009
795
0
0
If hes gonna play those games, then someone has to make him realize in terms that he can understand that 1. All this is just a game. and 2. If he starts to act all crazy and try to be like the game character, then give him an example of what its like (I'm not saying to buy a gn and shoot him if he's been playing GTA for a while. lol) But I'm sure you get the idea. Just so he understands the realism and what the consequences are for when things like that happen.
 

Biffy Cakeo

New member
May 24, 2010
109
0
0
Let him play MW1. Thats the least in my opinion. Hitman, hell no. GTA 3 and below are less straight out brutal in my opinion. L4D has got to be bad for a 9 year old. WaW is a little too brutal. Then again i'm fine after playing all these game 24/7. I started playing GTA3 at around 9. Didn't understand the story or anything but it hasn't really had an effect. Tell your parents anyway.
 

Mr Thin

New member
Apr 4, 2010
1,719
0
0
Those games aren't appropriate, you should talk to your parents about this, and you're not overreacting.

Questions; who's buying these games for him? Do they realize what they're doing and what the games are? How long has this been going on?

UnoticedShadow said:
about 4chan mature, constantly making aboriginal and ****** jokes when he's not quoting game jokes and the simpsons
Just read that. OK, seriously? It's bad enough when teenagers are like that, but this is just not on. If he's like that, I doubt stopping him from playing these games is going to do a damn thing to improve his character, kind of like trying to use a bucket to bail out a sinking ship; but you should definitely say something.

I mean, I'm all against close minded parents refusing their kids anything with violence, but here, in this case, action must be taken.
 

Leviathan_

New member
Jan 2, 2009
766
0
0
UnoticedShadow said:
AmrasCalmacil said:
Kid'll survive Mass Effect, he might not appreciate it as much as it deserves though, it's rated 12 over here, so, y'know.

How smart/mature would you say your brother is though?
about 4chan mature, constantly making aboriginal and ****** jokes when he's not quoting game jokes and the simpsons
Shut down your internet.... NAO, BEFORE IT'S TOO LATE!


I'd let him play those games though, I did the same thing and I'm completely fine
 

TheMadDoctorsCat

New member
Apr 2, 2008
1,163
0
0
Nomanslander said:
I don't know?

My dad showed me the exorcist, the shinning, taxi driver, and apocalypse now as a kid...and now I don't see anything wrong with that...=/
And yet you're sitting in a room, awake and alone at 2AM, your fingers covered in Cheeto dust, posting on forums and pretending to be human. And you think this HASN'T screwed you up?

(Oh wait... sorry... that's me.)
 

Biffy Cakeo

New member
May 24, 2010
109
0
0
ahlycks said:
UnoticedShadow said:
Okay so my brother has steam and everytime he sees me playing a game he decides that he has to have it.

However I'm seventeen and he's nine. but regardless of this fact a majority of his games are MA+15. Are the following games really that appropriate? should I have a word with my folks about this?

Hitman : Blood Money
Alien Vs Predator 2010 - Extreme Gore
Mass Effect - Sexual Referances, violence ect.
Modern Warfare 1 - High Level Violence
CoD World at War - Torture, executions ect
L4D 1&2 - Gore, not much but it's still enough to be MA+15
FallOut 3 - Gore and Adult references
Saint Row 2 - what doesn't this game have
Grand Theft Auto IV - see Saints Row 2

I cant even buy games that I normally would because I know he'll want them and I cant convince my parents to stop buying them.

Are there problems with these games being played by a nine year old or am I over reacting?

I'd like to add that I have no problem with any of the content in any of these games, I have infact enjoyed them all. My only concern is whether they are appropriate for someone so young
nope. None of them are ok for 9 year olds. I hate it when little kids do this. I remember when i was 9. All i played was games like Dragon Warrior and pokemon blue. Why cant they just play games that are for there age group? In fact, i still do not play M games. Well, Persona 3, but can you really count that as M?
I kind of agree. I do play games out of my age group but I'm sure I have a good grasp on reality. I play pokémon and Mario kart alot aswell as L4D and Fallout. Most M games are terrible gore wise, but if everything was viva pinata that would kill me. Tenchu Z was a great game with slight gore (Throat slitting, blood.) but that was nothing compared to Shadow of Rome. Both good games. Both gore filled. Both didnt scar me. Pokémon ftw. I believe it's up to the parents too decide if there child can cope with bludgeoning people with a leg.
 

jj90

New member
Oct 24, 2008
404
0
0
Aby_Z said:
Just, whatever you do, keep him away from the mic...
ill second that :p

OT: meh let him play, if he murders everyone he was gona do it anyway, the games will have no affect in that way at all :D
 

Cerrax

New member
Feb 15, 2009
164
0
0
I think this is a big issue that parents should be dealing with in a different manner than just censoring the games from their children. Much like minors are required to have an adult present to watch an R-rated movie, parents should at least watch their kids play these games, if not play with them. Simply denying the kid those games will make him rebellious and simply letting him play them can skew his perception of what is socially acceptable.

By taking time to understand a kid's hobbies and help him understand what in that hobby is right and wrong, you can form a powerful bond and teach important life lessons. I watched violent and sexually explicit movies and TV when I was young, but I watched it with my parents. Even some of the games I bought, my parents watched me play them. They wanted to understand what I was absorbing and expressed their discontent at images or actions that were inherently violent or morally questionable.

Something as simple as discouraging an act can have a profound affect on a child. If a 9 year old plays Fallout 3 and blows off an innocent woman's leg, discourage it. Let him know that it was not acceptable to do that, even though the game gives no indication that it is wrong (except maybe a bad Karma score, but who the hell pays attention to that anyway?) He may shrug it off or make an excuse like "I didn't mean it". He may even laugh. But that simple comment has already begun to sink in. The more you express praise for good behavior in games and discourage the bad, the more he will catch on to it.

As for games where killing is main goal (which is most of the games on the list), I would discourage him from playing them, but he decides he wants to, ask if you can play with him, or possibly watch him play. If the games feature multiple paths to complete an objective (like Fallout), offer for him to take the less violent or morally questionable option. He'll develop better problem solving skills, and avoid unnecessary wrongs.

I think society as a whole has forgotten just how important role models and a child's interaction with them is to a child's development.
 

elvor0

New member
Sep 8, 2008
2,320
0
0
ahlycks said:
UnoticedShadow said:
Okay so my brother has steam and everytime he sees me playing a game he decides that he has to have it.

However I'm seventeen and he's nine. but regardless of this fact a majority of his games are MA+15. Are the following games really that appropriate? should I have a word with my folks about this?

Hitman : Blood Money
Alien Vs Predator 2010 - Extreme Gore
Mass Effect - Sexual Referances, violence ect.
Modern Warfare 1 - High Level Violence
CoD World at War - Torture, executions ect
L4D 1&2 - Gore, not much but it's still enough to be MA+15
FallOut 3 - Gore and Adult references
Saint Row 2 - what doesn't this game have
Grand Theft Auto IV - see Saints Row 2

I cant even buy games that I normally would because I know he'll want them and I cant convince my parents to stop buying them.

Are there problems with these games being played by a nine year old or am I over reacting?

I'd like to add that I have no problem with any of the content in any of these games, I have infact enjoyed them all. My only concern is whether they are appropriate for someone so young
nope. None of them are ok for 9 year olds. I hate it when little kids do this. I remember when i was 9. All i played was games like Dragon Warrior and pokemon blue. Why cant they just play games that are for there age group? In fact, i still do not play M games. Well, Persona 3, but can you really count that as M?
See Normally I'd just tell the guy to go for it if his brother is mature enough about it, I was "watching" hellraiser and the exorcist and the like when I was 3 and I turned out just fine, some stuff is probably a bit raw, like a few "sex" scenes in Saints row and GTA, but for the most part, either he wont understand or he wont care for the rest of it, he's just having a laugh.

The only reason ill say no here is because his brother has been described as "4chan mature".
Although in all fairness at 14/15 im pretty sure you should be able to cope with mature games.

these days alot of games for a 9 year old are rubbish. There is no Crash Bandicoot or Spyro like I was raised upon, I mean theres a few but compared to mature games alot of them are quite weak, or I can't see most kids having the concentraion span required, at that age they just want to shoot things.
 

SonicWaffle

New member
Oct 14, 2009
3,019
0
0
Straz said:
Mass Effect more than Fallout, as that game truly isn't that bad, and those sex scenes which have been talked up so much go as far as showing a bra, and maybe some seedy music.
So I'd say Mass Effect would be fine.
Mass Effect is probably OK, but I'd keep him away from Fallout 3. I doubt I could have handled the subtle horror of wandering alone through a broken, empty world when I was his age. It really is a frightening game when you stop and think about your surroundings and how lonely you are, rather than in the traditional sense of blood/gore/things going bump in the night.
 

mikecoulter

Elite Member
Dec 27, 2008
3,389
5
43
Try and use some kind of parental controls or mention it to your parents. Or just hide your Steam games list.