I don't know about how it was rated, but Alan Wake was a so bad its good game. It knew it was a cheap Stephen King rip off story, with stupid puzzles and repetitive gameplay, but I just had to laugh at the voice overs. Its hard to be spooked when I have someone repeating how I should find a generator over and over.
FF XIII was funny because I just couldn't care about anyone and yet they still kept on with the overly dramatic speeches about hope and crap. the combat system wasn't bad either.
I just want it noted by the way, I am thoroughly disappointed with these new captchas. I would rather look at nonsensical signs any day then this rubbish.