Best and worst characters to be stuck on an island with?

[Olorune]

Best: I would have to say anyone from FarCry2. They know how to survive.
Worst: That god-d*** flying purple thing from Sonic:Unleashed!!! I can't stand cutesy little side kicks like him or her or whatever the hell it was.

 

[Jingermanoo]

Best: That boy from Lost In Blue. He's already got the t-shirt.

Worst: That girl from lost In Blue.

 

[Lazy Kitty]

Best: girls from hentai games (including furry).
Worst: The Overlord

 

[Seydaman]

Best: Alex Mercer

Worst: Alex Mercer?

You are ze clevar
Best: Batman, because he could just get a private helichopter, or....Niko because he can spawn boats
Worst:Very much any villian

 

[ironlordthemad]

best: marcus fenix because you wouldn't have to have a bullshit conversation and you would just get the job done

worst: possibly Dom Santiago because he would be constantly searching for his wife on an island she could never be on!

 

[Mr Mc Twiggy]

Best: Guybrush Threepwood from the Monkey Island games, he'd find a way off with a toothpick, some gum and a boot strap!

Worst: Le Chuck from the Monkey Island games, he'd kill you...

 

[TheRundownRabbit]

Worst: Cloud

Best: 60,000 points for whoever guesses

 

[Azulito]

Best: God from Black and White

Worst: God from Black and White

 

[Dimbo_Sama]

Best: Ash from Evil Dead (he was in games so it counts)

Worst: ....NAVI!!!

 

[TheSentinel]

Best: Tim from Braid. he can Time Travel us off the island, or just die a bunch of entertaining ways, always coming back to life after.

Worst: Kerrigan from StarCraft. You know why.

 

[Floppertje]

Best: Johnny Gat. Because he's cool.

Worst: Johnny Gat. Because he's a homicidal maniac who would kill me before i could tell him he's awesome.

also, I'm new. hello

 

[digipinky75910]

Good answers, but I think the spirit of the question emphasizes *STUCK* and hence if you suggest someone who can rescue you from the island, you cease being STUCK. Who'd be handy in a survival situation?

Eh, prolly Snake= best
Worst: First thing that came to mind was those excitable protagonists who always end up in trouble: Ash Ketchum, Yugi Muto..

 

[Brnin8]

Best: Jack from Bioshock, all you would have to say to make him help you off the island is "Would you kindly get us off this island", you could probably just sit back and relax while he did it too.
Worst: Probably Francis of L4D because while he would be funny at first, he wouldn't be helpful and you would just get angry with him.

 

[TheHitcher]

Best: Alyx Vance
Worst: Some psycho bad guy I guess...

 

[Diablini]

Best: John Locke (Horay for Action Grandpa!)
Worst: Eric Cartman

 

[ZeroMachine]

Worst: mario, freeman , reason: they never talk or just say "its ah me amario!"
Best: Master chief, Reason: get him to build a giant tree fort in like five hours and he is around my age.

... Master Chief is in his fourties.

Best: Captain Price

Worse: Garth (?) from KOTOR, you'd have to deal with his whiny soap opera problems 24/7 before he'd even think about trusting you.

It's Carth, and I actually agree on that... he may even be worse than my worst, Pyramid Head.

 

[badgersprite]

Best: Zidane, because he always finds some way to escape and be inevitably awesome. Or maybe Tidus because he can hold his breath and swim like who knows what the fuck.

Worst: Vaan. Oh my god! SHUT UP!

 

[Above]

BEST:Sackboy,entertainment watching him blow himself up xD

WORST:Sephiroth from FF7...Does that need an explanation?