SnootyEnglishman said:
I would like to put up Bioshock for this award
No thanks, System Shock 2 had the exact same story yet yet executed the details much better.
They only better thing Bioshock did storywise was that Andrew Ryan was a better false antagonist than Xerxes and the mind control twist.
SS2 did it better, the two examples that come
SHODAN was a better character than Fontaine (Though they both had god complexes, SHODAN let you know you needed her to survive, whereas Fontaine lost all his power over you after the reveal)
The Many were actuslly sympathetic, whereas the splicers were just victims of their own stupidity
I'm going to go with Silent Hill 2, you could study that story for a class