I'm glad that I wasn't crazy to think Return of the King was so fun back in the day. I've often longed for a pseudo-open-world action-RPG like The Witcher 2 or Kingdoms of Amalur to be made in the LoTR universe, without being focused on the Fellowship for once.
It really makes me sad that Spider-Man 2 got the webslinging so right and every game since then has decided it needed to focus on the combat. And with the technology we have nowadays we could do so much more with the webslinging too.
And though they're not really "movie" games, I think that the Star Wars: Jedi Knight series deserves an honorable mention for being just about the greatestthree four (I count the first Dark Forces to be in the series, then Dark Forces II, Jedi Outcast, and Jedi Academy as a spin-off type thing) Star Wars games ever made. And Luke Skywalker was a character in . . . two? of them, so that's the tie-in. Coughitscloseenoughcough.
It really makes me sad that Spider-Man 2 got the webslinging so right and every game since then has decided it needed to focus on the combat. And with the technology we have nowadays we could do so much more with the webslinging too.
And though they're not really "movie" games, I think that the Star Wars: Jedi Knight series deserves an honorable mention for being just about the greatest