I agree with both Half-Life's and CoD. System Shock 2 had a great tutorial, but the little in-game blurbs that you had to read were really annoying, because you could easily miss one and not know what to do, and stopping to read them killed the immersion of the early levels.Grampy_bone said:I liked Thief and System Shock 2's tutorial levels.
System Shock 2 was the army recruiting programs!
The LotR movie games had excellent tutorials; when I play RotK with friends, I let them go through the tutorial and they usually are competent enough to play through the rest of the game with me in co-op and generally know what they're doing.