DrOswald said:
Do people really think Alyx Vance is sexy? I mean, she is as well written as you could expect an girlfriend insert in a FPS to be, but sexy? I see significantly sexier women every single day on university campus. She is not designed or meant to be a sexy character.
And I seriously disagree that Alyx Vance is a better developed and more interesting character than most Final Fantasy female leads. I mean, compare Yuna, who goes through a very interesting character arc throughout her game interwoven with concepts and commentaries of sacrifice, faith, duty, freedom and individuality. The deepest characterization we ever get of Alyx is that she built a robot gorilla she calls dog. No contest.
Alyx Vance is a perfectly serviceable character and an excellent fit for her place in Half Life 2, but holding her ups as one of the greats seems strange to me. Seems to me like some serious nostalgia blindness.
Final Fantasy hasn't had a likable female lead since Terra and Celes.
Let me just get this out of the way real quick: Final Fantasy has never been particularly well-written. For the entries all the way up to VI, they get a pass since storytelling in video games was still in its infancy and it was hard to tell a good story with the limited resources they had. When FF VII rolled around, the graphics improved and they had more resources to tell a story...but the writing didn't improve one bit, and has been stuck in the 90s ever since.
And that is the problem with most Final Fantasy characters. They're little more than pretty anime stereotypes. I like Alyx because she's more nuanced and subtle than any example you can get out of Final Fantasy, and doesn't give me any speeches about the power of friendship or some shit.
Alyx actually seems human, and behaves in a way most humans would, unlike her Final Fantasy counterparts.