Bioshock Infinate: Should I get this game? (Spoiler Free)

Recommended Videos

ejrocksthisworld

New member
Feb 14, 2010
82
0
0
So as the whole world knows, Bioshock Infinate has released to critical and commercial acclaim. I am seeing advertisements for Game of the Year already, let alone MovieBob made a post today in regards to Bioshock Infinate (I haven't watched it but my assumption is he LOVED it), Jim Sterling claims it to be a great game and even Yahtzee, FREAKIN YAHTZEE, thought it was a great game! So some of you might be wondering why I haven't purchased this game yet.
My reservations are because of my feelings towards the first Bioshock game. Better call out a witch hunt: I didn't really like Bioshock. I never finished it, and in fact returned the game to Gamestop a few weeks after purchase.
The irony of it all, I LOVE story driven games and unique characters. As a first person shooter, Bioshock took the world by storm with it's original tale. However, for me it was the gameplay that ruined the game. Being a completionist, there were moments in the game where I felt like I missed important details or gameplay elements that compelled me to restart from earlier points in the game. There were also gameplay moments where I felt entirely forced to restart the game. For a first person shooter, I felt that this particular game lacked in gameplay elements (the shooting part) that are engaging in, well, first person shooters. Granted, I fucking HATE games like Call of Duty, but enjoy shooters more akin to Halo (in fact, this is the only shooter I still play, and mainly due to my appeal to the Halo Universe). I liked the concept of ADAM as a secondary tool to be used against enemies, but at the time I struggled with balancing my newly acquired powers alongside my weaponry. Perhaps this portion was due to my lack of expertise in games that required the balance of two types of weaponry, seeing as though I absolutely adore Dishonored and the balance of weaponry and Outsider powers in that game. Finally, I didn't find the atmosphere of Rapture too appealing, and found it to be quite dark. To better explain myself, I can handle dark games (look to the world of Dishonored), but that combination combined with being trapped within a submerged city that is slowly tearing itself apart, all the while confined to narrow corridors and enclosed, dark spaces, left me feeling oftentimes claustrophobic, restricted, and trapped. Perhaps this was my downfall with this game.
I grant that if I had muscled my way further into the story I probably would of been captured by the amazing story and characters that litter the world ( I seriously didn't make it far into this game at all), and now that I am more comfortable with balancing different tools to dispatch my enemies through practice in other games, perhaps I wouldn't of missed so much in my initial run of Bioshock, therefore allowing me to dispose of my enemies easier, utilizing the world around me and thus not force myself to restart as much as I did.
Back to Bioshock Infinate: this game, on the other hand, seems to take what scared me away from the first game and twist it into something more appealing. From what I hear, this game seems to capture the darkness of the characters and story while disposing of the claustrophobic Rapture, opting instead for the open world of Columbia. It is the freedom that this game advertises itself as that has sparked my renewed interest in the franchise. Now that I feel as though I can master the balance of weaponry and utilize it properly, coupled with the open-world gameplay that commercials and critics portray it as, this game indeed seems to be damn well near perfect for someone like me.
To my fellow community of like-minded gamers: from your experience with this game, coupled with my fears of the previous game (and steps I have made since then to balance those fears), should I purchase this game? If so, why? If not, why not? I want to either dismiss my reluctance and go ahead and make the purchase, or confirm my fears and steer clear of this game. Thank you for any and all advice given!
 

everythingbeeps

New member
Sep 30, 2011
946
0
0
You know what one of my favorite things is? Word economy.

I didn't read your whole post. I'm not going to. It's not a big enough decision to justify all that goddamn text.

If you didn't like Bioshock, you probably won't like this. Let's leave it at that.
 

Requia

New member
Apr 4, 2013
703
0
0
The gameplay is improved from Bioshock, but still mediocre, (I suspect it'll be a lot better on PC, as my biggest complaint is the iron sight implementation, and on PC that wouldn't matter as much). I did find the gun and Vigor balance decent, as I used quite a bit of both. If you're a completionist the game may drive you batshit because the lack of a map makes it hard to pick through everything for all the voxophones and silent video things.
 

Pink Gregory

New member
Jul 30, 2008
2,296
0
0
everythingbeeps said:
If you didn't like Bioshock, you probably won't like this. Let's leave it at that.
Exactly what I was going to say.

Just because it resonated with Jim, Moviebob and Yahtzee doesn't mean it's going to resonate with you. Critics and writers though they are, they still have their opinions, and all three liked Bioshock, so it's a fairly reasonable suggested that you won't like it if you didn't like Bioshock.
 

Terminate421

New member
Jul 21, 2010
5,773
0
0
Its the only game that I can think of that allows you to summon fucking crows to shred people.

Totally worth the 60$
 

shrekfan246

Not actually a Japanese pop star
May 26, 2011
6,374
0
0
ejrocksthisworld said:
Back to Bioshock Infinate: this game, on the other hand, seems to take what scared me away from the first game and twist it into something more appealing. From what I hear, this game seems to capture the darkness of the characters and story while disposing of the claustrophobic Rapture, opting instead for the open world of Columbia. It is the freedom that this game advertises itself as that has sparked my renewed interest in the franchise. Now that I feel as though I can master the balance of weaponry and utilize it properly, coupled with the open-world gameplay that commercials and critics portray it as, this game indeed seems to be damn well near perfect for someone like me.
To my fellow community of like-minded gamers: from your experience with this game, coupled with my fears of the previous game (and steps I have made since then to balance those fears), should I purchase this game? If so, why? If not, why not? I want to either dismiss my reluctance and go ahead and make the purchase, or confirm my fears and steer clear of this game. Thank you for any and all advice given!
Since I've actually read your post and am not just replying off of personal bias, I'm going to say you'd probably have a greater enjoyment of Bioshock Infinite than the first Bioshock, but if you're not a PC gamer you might still end up not enjoying it enough to finish it. I'll stress "might", though.

It's not "open-world", at least not in the way people usually use the term. The first Bioshock has largely more intricate level design, but Infinite's atmosphere is certainly more open and grandiose. Completely opposite of Rapture's claustrophobic corridors, even though the level design is far more straight-forward.

My experience is only with the PC version, but the actual shooting and combination with the Vigors is a lot more satisfying than the first game. The guns feel and sound so much better, the Vigors are mostly unique and fun, and while the two-weapon limit seems a hindrance at first, you'll probably find a pair of weapons that suit you best and then go through the entire game with them anyway -- Alternatively, on higher difficulties it adds a lot of tension because you need to scramble around the battlefield searching for a replacement when your current weapon runs out of ammo. And while you're limited on the number of weapons you can carry, you can use all of the Vigors any time after you've obtained them. You can't upgrade everything, because money is used for everything, but you'd likely find a few things you really like to use and then focus on upgrading them.

The story is less political or philosophical than the first, but the trade-off is that it's also a bit more personal with the tight focus on Elizabeth as a character. And just as fantastically written, in my opinion, even if none of the villains really match up to Andrew Ryan (a rather tall order to begin with).

It does get my recommendation, to be honest, because even my friend who doesn't really like first-person games or shooters bought, played, and ended up loving Infinite. But as with anything you read on the internet, you should always take it with a vial of salts.
 

daveman247

New member
Jan 20, 2012
1,366
0
0
Yes if you liked the previous bioshocks. Bear in mind that the combat is faster here but the upgrade list is not as extensive.
 

Devetta

New member
Aug 14, 2009
30
0
0
My boyfriend hated Bioshock, but loves Bioshock Infinite. Get it, play it and see.
 

ejrocksthisworld

New member
Feb 14, 2010
82
0
0
Yes I apologize about the text. It's a ton to read through, but I figured it would be better for me to detail why I'm struggling with this decision instead of leaving it as: Should I purchase Infinate if I didn't care for Bioshock?
 

wurrble182

New member
Jul 20, 2010
94
0
0
the two games are like night and day in many respects, and yet like apples and more apples in other respects. just throw your money at it and hope for the best. you only live once eh?