I'm not arguing pro or anti piracy, i'm just confused. Yea there are many lost sales, but there is never a potential sale for every copy(you say there is but analogies don't prove this), unless each legit copy gives you one free bj.Saucycardog said:I'm saying that those copies had the potentiol to make $252 million becuase you got the game for free. If I got a cookie recipe from a bakery and made the cookies myself and gave them out for free, sure the bakery wouldn't be losing any money, but they would be losing business.yundex said:I don't get it, if I pirate every game ever released, does that mean i'd buy everything if piracy wasn't possible? They're all "lost sales" too.Saucycardog said:I understand your way of thinking, and I agree with you on the not-costing-money-to-make thing. But, I also see your point of thinking in that people wouldn't have bought it if they didn't pirate it. And I do disagree.Rednog said:Wait...what?Saucycardog said:Well, I kinda have to disagree with you. The game is valued at $60 and someone got it for free. Which means, the money it cost to make each of those copies was not payed back.Rednog said:The numbers seem a little screwy that 4.2 million people really downloaded the game. I mean why? Sure there is single player and lan, but considering you can't (at least in my knowledge) get to the multiplayer, then what is the point of downloading the game?
Also, because it has to be said over and over in each piracy thread, a download does not mean it is a lost sale.
Maybe its not a lost sale, but it sure is a waste of money.
Hold the phone.
What do you mean the cost to make each of the copies was not paid back? There were no physical copies made for these people. It's not like Activision made 4.2 million copies of the game, packed it up, and somewhere along the shipping lines people stole these copies off the trucks. This is an illegal copy of the game. Activision takes no direct loss of money.
And like I said, whoever (to my knowledge) is downloading this game isn't necessarily playing it online, so it's not like they are getting the full game's worth.
Also just because someone pirates a game does not mean that they would otherwise have bought the game if said illegal copy was not available. Thus it a pirated copy is not directly a lost sale of the game.
The game was valued at $60 and some people got it for free. Even if it did not cost money to create, it still had the potentiol to make $252 million. And I count that as a lost sale because no money was made off of those 4.2 million copies.
Look, I don't want to start a piracy arguement right now. Let's just drop it and we can all have our own opinions.
But if you don't want to argue over this, that's fine since I want to sleep now.