TIEM TO NECROZ
*ahem* anyone who thinks ike in brawl is op'd, need's to quit running into the slowest moves in the game, your granny has a reaction time fast enough to avoid ikes smashes, and quick draw, AND aether(only time aether should be used as an attack is dropping from the ledge to do it towards anyone stupid enough to stay that close to the ledge on you...just don't do it against a pit mario or squirtle, or as a follow up to his down throw at low damage on the opponent, and even then that is only if you predict where your opponet is going to DI properly.)
Ike has the slowest smashes in the game(DDD's fsmash is slower, but the rest of his aren't) and these moves are so pitifully easy to dodge that NO ONE and i mean NO one, should EVER get hit by em, period.
If this topic was started sometime in 2008 I could understand noobs still nott knowing how to dodge or shield, but it was in 2012, and by this time in brawls lifecycle people should feel downright ashamed of themselves for getting hit by ikes horribly slow moves, and more so to think he's opd cuz they're the ones walking into a slow as hell move like ike's Fsmash and Usmash, not only do all of these moves that noobs complain about(fsmash, usmash, quick draw, and often aether) suffer from horrible Startup lag, ALL of them suffer from horrible ending lag as well, this makes ike a sitting duck when he misses, and unless the ike is absolutely crazy good at prediction, he'll ALWAYS miss these moves(there is a reason you'll rarely ever see a pro ike player in brawl using his Fsmash or Usmash, these moves are just too risky and easy to avoid.)
you want Overpowered? http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TSkCGa_J5wY this is what the ice climbers can do to a player should they be lucky enough to get a grab in on em.
If anything Ike is UNDERPOWERED, NOT op'd, with one of his recovery options being easy to destroy(quick draw, just jump out in front of the ike when he's offstage and airdodge it, or if you're low enough damage take the hit, the ike will lose all the momentum from quick draw and fall to his doom) another being a strictly vertical one that has near zero horizontal ability(aether, not to mention like i said above squirtle, pit and mario looooove to see an ike use aether near the ledge, as its a free kill from their mirror shield, cape and water gun moves) and having some of the slowest moves in the game that are both easy to dodge and leave him a sitting duck, it really doesn't matter how physically powerful the moves are, sure ike's Fsmash could kill you as low as 50-60% damage, but the honest truth is if you were dumb enough to get hit by the thing then you deserved to lose your stock.
Ike needs to be buffed in the speed department in the next smash, now if they do that then obviously he'll need to have the physical power toned down a bit(cuz if the moves were actually fast enough to hit with the power they have now then they WOULD be opd) but overall speeding him up will make him go from being a lousy-mediocre character, to a decent to possibly good one.
now of course characters who need help more then ike are link, ganon and zelda(the zelda crew aside from shiek, who was still nerfed from melee, but fairly ok in brawl, and toon link, who is pretty much the best out of the 4, all got the short end of the stick in brawl, with ganondorf being a walking punching bag, link having no recovery at all and being almost as bad as his was in smash64, and zelda having no offensive game at all, dins fire is just as easy to avoid as ikes smashes, and all anyone has to do to destroy every zelda player around, is force them to come to you, eventually the zelda will get tired fo hopelessly spamming dins fire when its not hitting, and will try to approach, and that is when she's screwed entirely, has a decent defensive game, but a lousy offensive one.)
the point i'm trying to make with all of this though is simple; Ike in brawl is not overpowered, but is actually underpowered, anyone who thinks he's OP'd seriously, its 2012, its pathetic that you're still getting hit by the slowest smashes in the game, learn where the shield button is, and learn how to spot dodge.
As i showed you all with the ice climber video, there are FAR FAR FAR more deadly characters in this game then ike, ike isn't even in the top 10(or even 20) of brawl's tier list.